Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Holding Mayors Accountable

New York's Executives from Koch to Bloomberg

Bibliographic Data

ID6231896
AuthorsR Douglas Arnold (Princeton University), Nicholas Carnes (0009-0000-3506-8273, Duke University)
Year2012
Volume56
Issue4
Pages949-963
Publication date2012-10-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueAmerican Journal of Political Science (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0092-5853 • E-ISSN: 1540-5907
PublisherWiley (PUBLISHER • GB)
DOI10.1111/j.1540-5907.2012.00603.x
OpenAlexW2146674762
LanguageEN
Citations received50
References cited45

How do citizens evaluate the performance of their mayors? Previous studies have examined mayoral performance either with cross‐sectional surveys or by comparing pairs of consecutive elections. In this article, we use 150 surveys conducted in New York City between 1984 and 2009 to carry out the first time‐series analysis of mayoral approval. We show that fluctuations in crime and the economy affect mayors’ ratings and that black and white citizens react similarly to changing local conditions (although their initial evaluations of mayors often diverge sharply). We also show that how New Yorkers rate mayors in the polls is closely related to how they vote for mayors at the polls

Affect (linguistics · Business · Political science · Public relations · White (mutation · Electoral Systems and Political Participation · Fiscal Policies and Political Economy · Psychology · Public Administration · Public Policy and Administration Research

  • From kilometres to detachment

    Open Access•Jakub Jusko, Petr Voda•Territory Politics Governance•2026

  • Test-based accountability and educational equity

    Open Access•John J Gregg, Stéphane Lavertu•Economics of Education Review•2023

  • School performance and retrospective voting

    Open Access•Nicola Maaser, Martin Strobl•European Journal of Political…•2024

  • The effect of debt intensity on the asymmetric cost behavior

    Open Access•Sotirios Karatzima, Vasilios Christos Naoum et al.•Journal of Public Budgeting…•2024

  • The Buck Stops with the Education Mayor

    Open Access•J Celeste Lay, Michael D Tyburski•Politics & Policy•2017

  • Concede or Resist? Experimental Evidence on How Partisanship Shapes Local Officials’ Responses to Preemption

    Open Access•Alexandra Artiles•American Politics Research•2025

  • Crime, Policing, and Voter Turnout in Chicago's 2023 and 2019 Mayoral Elections

    Open Access•B Mccarthy, J Hagan et al.•Urban Affairs Review•2025

  • Spotlighting the Economy

    Open Access•Richard Burke•Urban Affairs Review•2024

  • Do sleep disruptions promote social fragmentation

    Open Access•John B Holbein, Charles Crabtree•Politics and the Life Sciences•2023

  • Public sentiment in times of terror

    Open Access•Ashani Amarasinghe•Journal of Development Economics•2023

  • Do School Report Cards Produce Accountability Through the Ballot Box

    Open Access•Vladimir Kogan, Stéphane Lavertu et al.•Journal of Policy Analysis and…•2016

  • Smart cities' actions, performance and reporting practices on climate change challenges

    Open Access•Sotirios Karatzima, Sotirios Karatzimas•Cities•2024

  • Who wins when? Election timing and descriptive representation

    Open Access•Zoltan L Hajnal, Vladimir Kogan et al.•American Journal of Political…•2025

  • Intergovernmental alignment and the electoral value of mayors

    Open Access•Alexandru Savu•Public Choice•2024

  • Do political protests mobilize voters? Evidence from the Black Lives Matter protests

    Open Access•Oliver Engist, Felix Schafmeister•Public Choice•2022

  • Are retrospective evaluations of local governments moderated by perceptions of influence

    Open Access•Richard Burke•Social Science Quarterly•2024

  • Electoral Accountability and Control in US Cities

    Holger Sieg, Chamna Yoon•Journal of Political Economy•2022

  • Ideology and Vote Choice in U.S. Mayoral Elections

    Open Access•Michael W Sances•Political Behavior•2018

  • Conditional relationships in dynamic models

    Open Access•Zach Warner, Garrett N Vande Kamp et al.•Political Science Research and…•2026

  • Mobilize for Our Lives? School Shootings and Democratic Accountability in U.S. Elections

    Open Access•Hans J G Hassell, John B Holbein et al.•American Political Science Review•2020

  • Age and Homeownership Drive the Local Turnout Gap

    Open Access•Katherine Levine Einstein, Maxwell Palmer et al.•Urban Affairs Review•2025

  • Mayors, Accomplishments, and Advancement

    Open Access•Eric S Heberlig, Justin Mccoy et al.•Urban Affairs Review•2017

  • When Voters Matter

    Open Access•Michael W Sances•Urban Affairs Review•2021

  • Voter Responsiveness to Signals of Local Government Financial Health

    Open Access•Carolyn Abott, Matthew B Incantalupo et al.•Urban Affairs Review•2025

  • Avoiding Punishment? Electoral Accountability for Local Fee Increases

    Open Access•Katy Hansen, Shadi Eskaf et al.•Urban Affairs Review•2022

  • Political Consequences of the Endangered Local Watchdog

    Open Access•Meghan E Rubado, Jay T Jennings et al.•Urban Affairs Review•2020

  • Do Teachers Want Democracy? Deliberative Culture and Teachers’ Evaluations of Schools

    Open Access•Jonathan E Collins•Urban Affairs Review•2020

  • Can Good Politicians Compensate for Bad Institutions? Evidence from an Original Survey of Italian Mayors

    Maria Carreri•The Journal of Politics•2021

  • The Politics of Potholes

    Charla M Burnett, Craig M Burnett et al.•The Journal of Politics•2017

  • Why Are Subnational Governments Responsive

    Chris Tausanovitch•The Journal of Politics•2019

  • Relative Unemployment, Political Information, and the Job Approval Ratings of State Governors and Legislatures

    Open Access•Jeffrey E Cohen•State Politics & Policy Quarterly•2020

  • Crime and Presidential Accountability

    Open Access•Benjamin S Noble, Andrew Reeve et al.•Public Opinion Quarterly•2022

  • Retrospective Voting in Big-City US Mayoral Elections

    Open Access•D J Hopkins, Lindsay M Pettingill•Political Science Research and…•2018

  • Strategic government communication about performance

    Open Access•Justin De Benedictis-Kessner•Political Science Research and…•2022

  • Local leaders and the pursuit of growth in US cities

    Open Access•Maria Carreri, Julia A Payson•Political Science Research and…•2024

  • Do citizens hold mayors accountable for local conditions? Evidence from Italian municipalities

    Giorgio Di Pietro•Local Government Studies•2019

  • When Are Local Incumbents Held Accountable for Government Performance? Evidence from US School Districts

    Open Access•Julia A Payson•Legislative Studies Quarterly•2017

  • Pass the buck or the buck stops here? The public costs of claiming and deflecting blame in managing crises

    Open Access•David Ryan Miller, Andrew Reeve et al.•Journal of Public Policy•2022

  • Local Elections and Representation in the United States

    Carole Warshaw, Christopher Warshaw•Annual Review of Political Science•2019

  • The electoral politics of immigration and crime

    Open Access•Allison Mickel•American Journal of Political…•2025

  • Partisanship, Economic Assessments, and Presidential Accountability

    Open Access•Zoe Ang, Andrew Reeve et al.•American Journal of Political…•2022

  • Racial Inequality in Democratic Accountability

    Open Access•P Flavin, Michael T Hartney•American Journal of Political…•2017

  • Are Perceptions of Local Conditions Rooted in Reality? Evidence From Two Large-Scale Local Surveys

    Open Access•Thomas M Holbrook, Aaron C Weinschenk•American Politics Research•2020

  • Holding mayors accountable? Policing and mayoral approval in American cities

    Min Hee Go•The Social Science Journal•2025

  • Do actions speak louder than words? Evidence on voter behavior from Madrid Rio Park

    Open Access•Joaquín Artés, Enrique García-Viñuela et al.•Electoral Studies•2022

  • There's (rarely) a new sheriff in town

    Open Access•Michael Zoorob•Electoral Studies•2022

  • Accountability for the Local Economy at All Levels of Government in United States Elections

    Open Access•Justin De Benedictis-Kessner, Carole Warshaw•American Political Science Review•2020

  • Left Behind? Citizen Responsiveness to Government Performance Information

    Open Access•John B Holbein, John Holbein•American Political Science Review•2016

  • Noisy Retrospection

    Open Access•Adam M Dynes, John B Holbein•American Political Science Review•2020

  • Presidential Approval and Public Security in Mexico's War on Crime

    Open Access•Vidal Romero, Beatriz Magaloni et al.•Latin American Politics and Society•2016

  • The Nature and Origins of Mass Opinion

    Open Access•John R Zaller, John Zaller•Nature and Origins of Mass Opinion•1992

  • Political Monopolies in American Cities

    Jessica Trounstine•Political Monopolies in American…•2008

  • City Limits

    Paul E Peterson•City Limits•1981

  • Tides of Consent

    Open Access•James A Stimson•Tides of Consent•2004

  • Economics and Elections

    Michael S Lewis-Beck•Economics and Elections•1990

  • The Urban Voter

    Karen M Kaufmann, Karen Kaufmann•The Urban Voter•2004

  • Economics and the 1999 Elections

    Manfred Gerstenfeld•Israel at the Polls 1999 : Israel•2020

  • Government Performance as a Basis for Machine Support

    Open Access•Ester R Fuchs, Robert Y Shapiro•Urban Affairs Quarterly•1983

  • Who Is Held Responsible When Disaster Strikes? the Attribution of Responsibility for a Natural Disaster in an Urban Election

    Kevin Arceneaux, Robert M Stein•Journal of Urban Affairs•2006

  • Gubernatorial popularity in three states

    Open Access•Robert E Crew, Robert E Jr Crew et al.•The Social Science Journal•1996

  • A Note on the Dynamics and Idiosyncrasies of Gubernatorial Popularity

    Open Access•Greg D Adams, Peverill Squire•State Politics & Policy Quarterly•2001

  • Assessing the President

    Richard A Brody•Assessing the President•1991

  • Voting for Minority Candidates in Multiracial/Multiethnic Communities

    Open Access•Robert M Stein, Stacy G Ulbig et al.•Urban Affairs Review•2005

  • Revitalizing Urban Research

    Open Access•Elaine B Sharp•Urban Affairs Review•2007

  • Is Urban Politics a Black Hole? Analyzing the Boundary Between Political Science and Urban Politics

    Open Access•Joshua Sapotichne, Bryan D Jones et al.•Urban Affairs Review•2007

  • Follow the Leader? Presidential Approval, Presidential Support, and Representatives' Electoral Fortunes

    Paul Gronke, Jeffrey W Koch et al.•The Journal of Politics•2003

  • Accountability and Local Elections

    Christopher R Berry, William G Howell•The Journal of Politics•2007

  • Presidential Approval and Legislative Success

    Brandice Canes-Wrone, Scott De Marchi•The Journal of Politics•2002

  • Relative Unemployment and Gubernatorial Popularity

    Jeffrey E Cohen, James D King•The Journal of Politics•2004

  • Black Mayors/White Mayors

    E Howell, Steven Howell et al.•Public Opinion Quarterly•2004

  • Performance and Race in Evaluating Minority Mayors

    Susan E Howell, William P Mclean•Public Opinion Quarterly•2001

  • FDR to Clinton, Mueller to

    Open Access•Paul Gronke, Brian Newman et al.•Political Research Quarterly•2003

  • Retrospective Voting in Gubernatorial Elections

    Open Access•Craig J Svoboda•Political Research Quarterly•1995

  • Comparing Dynamic Specifications

    Open Access•Niels Beck, Nathaniel Beck•Political Analysis•1991

  • All Politics Is Local

    Open Access•Jessica Trounstine•Perspectives on Politics•2009

  • Changing White Attitudes Toward Black Political Leadership

    Open Access•Andra Gillespie•Perspectives on Politics•2007

  • Representation and Accountability in Cities

    Jessica Trounstine•Annual Review of Political Science•2010

  • State Economies and State Taxes

    Richard G Niemi, Harold W Stanley et al.•American Journal of Political…•1995

  • When Mayors Matter

    Open Access•Elisabeth R Gerber, D J Hopkins•American Journal of Political…•2011

  • The Political Dynamics of Urban Voting Behavior

    Joel Lieske•American Journal of Political…•1989

  • The Study of Local Elections

    Open Access•Melissa Marschall, Paru Shah et al.•PS Political Science & Politics•2011

  • White Residents, Black Incumbents, and a Declining Racial Divide

    Open Access•Zoltan L Hajnal•American Political Science Review•2001

  • Economic and Referendum Voting

    Open Access•Lonna Rae Atkeson, Randall W Partin•American Political Science Review•1995

  • Vote Choice in Suburban Elections

    Open Access•J Eric Oliver, James E Oliver et al.•American Political Science Review•2007

  • Presidential Popularity from Truman to Johnson

    Open Access•Joanne Mueller, John E Mueller•American Political Science Review•1970

Unique citing works50
Citations per year5
Citation span2016 - 2026 (11)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 50

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae