Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Distinguishing Rivals That Go to War from Those That Do Not

A Quantitative Comparative Case Study of the Two Paths to War

Bibliographic Data

ID6273370
AuthorsJohn A Vasquez (0000-0001-8728-3688, Vanderbilt University, corresponding author)
Year1996
Volume40
Issue4
Pages531
Publication date1996-12-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessNo
TypeARTICLE
VenueInternational Studies Quarterly (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0020-8833 • E-ISSN: 1468-2478
PublisherOxford University Press (OUP) (PUBLISHER)
DOI10.2307/2600890
OpenAlexW2314689170
LanguageEN
Citations received79
References cited22

Many interstate enduring rivalries experience wars, some do not. This analysis presents and tests an explanation of whether, why, and how rivals go to war. It is argued that rivalries between equal states that do not go to war are those in which territorial issues are not at stake. Rivalries in the absence of territorial issues tend to go to war only by being embroiled in an ongoing war by a third party. A series of tests with emphasis on rivalries between major states occurring during 1816–1986 supports the territorial explanation. Two distinct paths to war are empirically identified—one leading to a dyadic war involving a territorial dispute(s) and a second path by which rivals without a territorial dispute join an ongoing war because of contagion factors

Economic history · Economics · Political economy · Political science · Politics · Spanish Civil War · Territorial dispute · Culture, Economy, and Development Studies · International Development and Aid · Law · Political Conflict and Governance

  • Conflict Management and Israeli-Palestinian Conflict

    Jacob Bercovitch, Seniha Ayse Kadayifci•Asia-Pacific Review•2002

  • The Democratic Peace and Territorial Conflict in the Twentieth Century

    Open Access•Paul K Huth, Todd L Allee et al.•Democratic Peace and Territorial…•2003

  • When Security Imperatives meet Sectarian Temptations

    Open Access•Basem Ezbidi•Cogent Social Sciences•2023

  • Conventional Arms Control Agreements in Europe

    Open Access•W Lippert•Central European Journal of…•2024

  • Securitization and State Sponsorship of Non-State Actors

    Open Access•Akbar Khan, Allauddin Kakar•Fudan Journal of the Humanities…•2023

  • Easier signed than done

    Annie Young Song, Justin V Hastings•Territory Politics Governance•2024

  • On the origins, persistence and termination of spatial and positional rivalries in world politics

    Open Access•Kentaro Sakuwa, William R Thompson•International Area Studies Review•2019

  • Superpower Dispute Initiation

    Open Access•Christopher K Butler•International Area Studies Review•2011

  • The Lasting Impact of Trump’s ‘Deal of the Century’ on the Question of Palestine

    Open Access•I Fraihat, Basem Ezbidi•Middle East Critique•2023

  • It takes all types

    Open Access•Brian C Rathbun•International Theory•2009

  • The Role of Political Leaders’ Emotions in Shaping International Rivalries

    Open Access•Christophe Thiers•Foreign Policy Analysis•2023

  • The Domestic Determinants of Foreign Policy Behavior in Middle Eastern Enduring Rivals, 1948-1998

    Open Access•Christopher Sprecher, Karl Derouen•Foreign Policy Analysis•2005

  • Complex Interstate Rivals

    Open Access•Brandon Valeriano, Matthew Powers•Foreign Policy Analysis•2014

  • Ideology, territorial saliency, and geographic contiguity

    Surinder Mohan•International Relations of the…•2016

  • What Causes Civil Wars? Integrating Quantitative Research Findings

    Open Access•Jeffrey Dixon•International Studies Review•2009

  • Territory, Proximity, and Spatiality

    Open Access•Harvey Starr•International Studies Review•2005

  • Territoriality and War in International Crises

    Open Access•Hemda Ben-Yehuda, Hemda Ben‐Yehuda•International Studies Review•2004

  • To war or not to war

    Open Access•Viet Hung Nguyen Cao•Japanese Journal of Political…•2025

  • Military capabilities and regime type

    Open Access•Surinder Mohan•International Politics•2018

  • Perceptions of Rivalry

    Open Access•David R Dreyer•PS Political Science & Politics•2013

  • Sino-Japanese strategic relations

    James Manicom, Andrew O’neil et al.•Australian Journal Of International…•2009

  • When do states fight limited wars

    Joseph Lepgold, Brent L Sterling•Security Studies•2000

  • Sanctioning as a goal unto itself

    Open Access•Suleyman Orhun Altiparmak, Cameron G Thies•Cambridge Review of International…•2025

  • Asymmetrical rivalry between China and Japan in Africa

    Miwa Hirono•The Pacific Review•2019

  • Are China and Japan rivals in Latin America? A rivalry perception analysis

    Katja Levy, C Rose•The Pacific Review•2019

  • Assessing the Dyadic Approach to Interstate Conflict Processes

    Open Access•Sarah E Croco, Tze Kwang Teo•Conflict Management and Peace…•2005

  • Legal Systems and Peaceful Attempts to Resolve Territorial Disputes

    Open Access•Emilia Justyna Powell, Krista E Wiegand•Conflict Management and Peace…•2010

  • Geographical Proximity and Issue Salience

    Open Access•Paul D Senese•Conflict Management and Peace…•1996

  • Issue Rivalries

    Open Access•Stephen Mark Mitchell, Sara Mclaughlin Mitchell et al.•Conflict Management and Peace…•2011

  • The Correlates of War Project

    Open Access•Susumu Suzuki, Volker Krause et al.•Conflict Management and Peace…•2002

  • The Chicken or the Egg

    Shawna K Metzger•International Interactions•2016

  • Time Present and Time Past

    Stephen B Long, Stephen Long•International Interactions•2003

  • Assessing the statistical rarity of wars between democracies

    J Joseph Hewitt, Garry Young•International Interactions•2001

  • Unraveling proxy wars

    Open Access•Natalia Tellidou•International Interactions•2024

  • Territorial nationalism in spatial rivalries

    Cameron G Thies•International Interactions•2001

  • The Construction of a Latin American Interstate Culture of Rivalry

    Cameron G Thies•International Interactions•2008

  • Control the issues, control the conflict

    Douglas M Gibler•International Interactions•1997

  • Toward a Multiprocess Model of Rivalry and the Democratic Peace

    William Reed, William L Reed et al.•International Interactions•2002

  • From “frozen conflict” to enduring rivalry

    Open Access•Laurence Broers•Nationalities Papers•2015

  • How Alliances Shape Rivalries

    Open Access•Prashant Hosur Suhas•International Studies Quarterly•2023

  • The Probability of War, 1816-1992. Presidential Address to the International Studies Association, March 25, 2002, New Orleans

    Open Access•John A Vasquez•International Studies Quarterly•2004

  • Unifying conceptualizations of interstate rivalry

    Open Access•David R Dreyer•Cooperation and Conflict•2014

  • Uncovering the Dangerous Alliances, 1495-1980

    Douglas M Gibler, John A Vasquez•International Studies Quarterly•1998

  • Classification of Interstate Wars

    John A Vasquez, Brandon Valeriano•The Journal of Politics•2010

  • Alliances, Arms Buildups and Recurrent Conflict

    Michael Colaresi, Michael P Colaresi et al.•The Journal of Politics•2005

  • Understanding Arms Race Onset

    Toby J Rider•The Journal of Politics•2009

  • Hot Hand

    Erik Gartzke, Michael Simon et al.•The Journal of Politics•1999

  • Hot Spots or Hot Hands? Serial Crisis Behavior, Escalating Risks, and Rivalry

    Michael Colaresi, Michael P Colaresi et al.•The Journal of Politics•2002

  • A Social Psychological Approach to Enduring Rivalries

    Open Access•Cameron G Thies•Political Psychology•2001

  • Time to Agree

    Open Access•Marco Pinfari•Journal of Conflict Resolution•2011

  • Rivalry and Diversionary Uses of Force

    Open Access•Stephen Mark Mitchell, Sara Mclaughlin Mitchell et al.•Journal of Conflict Resolution•2004

  • Power Parity, Preponderance, and War between Great Powers, 1816-1989

    Open Access•William B Moul, William Moul•Journal of Conflict Resolution•2003

  • Interstate Rivalry and Terrorism

    Open Access•Jon M Conrad, Justin Conrad•Journal of Conflict Resolution•2011

  • Explaining Rivalry Escalation to War

    Karen Rasler, William R Thompson•International Studies Quarterly•2000

  • Fully Informed and on the Road to Ruin

    Open Access•Jean-Pierre P Langlois, Catherine C Langlois•International Studies Quarterly•2005

  • Rivalry and State Support of Non-State Armed Groups (NAGs), 1946-20011

    Open Access•Zeev Maoz, Belgin San-Akca•International Studies Quarterly•2012

  • Identifying Rivals and Rivalries in World Politics

    William R Thompson•International Studies Quarterly•2001

  • When Do Diplomatic Protests Boomerang? Foreign Protests against US Arms Sales and Domestic Public Support in Taiwan

    Open Access•Koji Kagotani, Wen-Chin Wu•International Studies Quarterly•2022

  • Identifying and Classifying Complex Interstate Wars

    Open Access•Brandon Valeriano, John A Vasquez•International Studies Quarterly•2010

  • Territory, River, and Maritime Claims in the Western Hemisphere

    Open Access•David Lektzian, Baukje Prins et al.•International Studies Quarterly•2010

  • Contested Territory, Strategic Rivalries, and Conflict Escalation

    Open Access•Karen Rasler, Karen A Rasler et al.•International Studies Quarterly•2006

  • Repetitive Military Challenges and Recurrent International Conflicts, 1918-1994

    Joseph M Grieco•International Studies Quarterly•2001

  • Issue Conflict Accumulation and the Dynamics of Strategic Rivalry1

    Open Access•David R Dreyer•International Studies Quarterly•2010

  • Why Costly Rivalry Disputes Persist

    Open Access•Sijeong Lim, Seiki Tanaka•International Studies Quarterly•2022

  • Contentious Issues and World Politics

    Paul R Hensel•International Studies Quarterly•2001

  • The International Politics of Incomplete Sovereignty

    Open Access•Marshall M Lee, Melissa M Lee•International Organization•2018

  • The China–India Rivalry Reconceptualized

    Renaud Egreteau•Asian Journal of Political Science•2012

  • The Causes of War and the Conditions of Peace

    Jack S Levy•Annual Review of Political Science•1998

  • The Origins and War Proneness of Interstate Rivalries

    John A Vasquez, John Vasquez et al.•Annual Review of Political Science•2001

  • Greatpowerness’ as the key element of Russian self-consciousness under erosion

    Open Access•Mark Urnov•Communist and Post-Communist…•2014

  • The democratic embargo

    Open Access•Ryan Grauer, Dominic Tierney•European Journal of International…•2022

  • Reconfiguring The Arms Race-War Debate

    Open Access•Paul F Diehl, Mark J C Crescenzi•Journal of Peace Research•1998

  • Strategic Rivalries, Protracted Conflict, and Crisis Escalation

    Open Access•Michael Colaresi, William R Thompson•Journal of Peace Research•2002

  • Rivalries and the Democratic Peace in the Major Power Subsystem

    Open Access•Karen Rasler, William R Thompson•Journal of Peace Research•2001

  • Militarized territorial disputes

    Open Access•Krista E Wiegand•Journal of Peace Research•2011

  • Crisis Magnitude and Interstate Conflict

    Open Access•Hemda Ben-Yehuda, Hemda Ben‐Yehuda et al.•Journal of Peace Research•1998

  • Me, myself, and allies

    Open Access•David Sobek, Joe Clare•Journal of Peace Research•2013

  • The New Rivalry Dataset

    Open Access•James P Klein, Gary Goertz et al.•Journal of Peace Research•2006

  • Interstate Rivalry and the Recurrence of Crises

    Open Access•Baukje Prins, Brandon C Prins•Armed Forces & Society•2005

  • An encyclopedia of world history, ancient, medieval, and modern, chronologically arranged.

    William L Langer•An encyclopedia of world history,…•1952

  • Contexts of International Politics

    Open Access•Gary Goertz•Contexts of International Politics•1994

  • The Origins of the Second World War in Europe

    P M H Bell•Origins of the Second World War…•2014

  • The empirical importance of enduring rivalries

    Gary Goertz, Paul F Diehl•International Interactions•1992

  • On Escalation

    Open Access•Louis Lusky•Political Science Quarterly•1965

  • The Causes of the Second World War in Europe

    Open Access•John A Vasquez•International Political Science…•1996

  • Retreat from Doomsday

    John Mueller•Retreat from Doomsday•1996

  • Territorial Disputes and Interstate War, 1945-1987

    Stephen A Koc, Stephen A Kocs•The Journal of Politics•1995

  • Dangerous Dyads

    Open Access•Stuart A Bremer•Journal of Conflict Resolution•1992

  • Systemic Polarization and the Occurrence and Duration of War

    Open Access•Bruce Bueno De Mesquita•Journal of Conflict Resolution•1978

  • When Will They Ever Learn

    Open Access•Russell J Leng•Journal of Conflict Resolution•1983

  • Terror without Deterrence

    Open Access•Jacek Kugler•Journal of Conflict Resolution•1984

  • Power Differentials and War in Rival Dyads

    Daniel S Geller•International Studies Quarterly•1993

  • Security, Bargaining, and the End of Interstate Rivalry

    D Scott Bennett•International Studies Quarterly•1996

  • Enduring Rivalries

    Gary Goertz, Paul F Diehl•International Studies Quarterly•1993

  • The Initiation and Termination of Enduring Rivalries

    Gary Goertz, Paul F Diehl•American Journal of Political…•1995

  • Why Do Neighbors Fight? Proximity, Interaction, or Territoriality

    Open Access•John A Vasquez•Journal of Peace Research•1995

  • Incompatibility, Confrontation, and War

    Open Access•Peter Wallensteen•Journal of Peace Research•1981

  • Bipolarity and War

    Open Access•Frank Whelon Wayman•Journal of Peace Research•1984

  • Diffusion, Reinforcement, Geopolitics, and the Spread of War

    Open Access•Benjamin A Most, Harvey Starr•American Political Science Review•1980

  • General Deterrence between Enduring Rivals

    Open Access•Paul Huth, Bruce Russett•American Political Science Review•1993

  • Arms Races to War

    Open Access•Paul F Diehl•Sociological Quarterly•1985

Unique citing works79
Citations per year2,63
Citation span1996 - 2025 (30)
Citation velocityrecent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 79

Tools

Open DOISci-HubOpen Access
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae