Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

The International Law and Politics of Climate Change

Ratification of the United Nations Framework Convention and the Kyoto Protocol

Bibliographic Data

ID6284684
AuthorsJana Von Stein (0000-0001-7915-7315, Department of Political Science University of Michigan, corresponding author)
Year2008
Volume52
Issue2
Pages243-268
Publication date2008-04-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueJournal of Conflict Resolution (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0022-0027 • E-ISSN: 1552-8766
PublisherSAGE Publications Inc (PUBLISHER)
DOI10.1177/0022002707313692
OpenAlexW2141387892
LanguageEN
Citations received101
References cited39

A considerable challenge for the creators of international environmental agreements is how to design mechanisms that deter defection without deterring participation. Relatively ``soft'' law often garners widespread participation, but it creates few concrete incentives for states to improve behavior. ``Harder'' commitments make shirking more difficult, but these institutional features may deter from joining the very states whose practices are least consistent with the treaty's requirements. Empirical analyses of ratification of the core agreements of the climate change regime support these propositions. Flexibility provisions provide one mechanism for states to mitigate this dilemma. The findings with regard to one flexibility mechanism strongly support this argument. The results with regard to a second flexibility mechanism, however, tend to follow an opposite pattern. The author offers a preliminary interpretation of this finding. Finally, this article provides insight into how international social networks and the strength of domestic nongovernmental organizations affect ratification

Argument (complex analysis · Business · Dilemma · Economics · Flexibility (engineering · Incentive · International law · Interpretation (philosophy · Law and economics · Mechanism (biology · Microeconomics · Political science · Politics · Ratification · Treaty · Climate Change Policy and Economics · International Development and Aid · Law · World Trade Organization Law

  • The Kyoto Agreement and the pursuit of relative gains

    Sevasti-Eleni Vezirgiannidou•Environmental Politics•2008

  • Committed to Rights

    Open Access•Audrey L Comstock•Committed to Rights : Volume 1•2021

  • China's Strategic Multilateralism

    Chad Rector, Margaret M Pearson et al.•China's Strategic Multilateralism•2018

  • The Diffusion of International Environmental Agreements

    Open Access•Elif Korkmaz Tümer, Mehmet Güçlü•Regulation & Governance•2026

  • Do political systems have a lasting effect on climate change concern? Evidence from Germany after reunification

    Open Access•Yiannis Kountouris•Environmental Research Letters•2021

  • Reconciling the flexibility mechanisms of climate policies towards the inclusiveness of developing countries

    Open Access•Cemal Atıcı•Environment Development and…•2022

  • Democracy and climate change policies

    Open Access•Per G Fredriksson, E Neumayer•Ecological Economics•2013

  • Side Effects of Creating a Major Regional Development Bank

    Open Access•Volha Kryvets•Chinese Political Science Review•2022

  • The influence of institutions, governance, and public opinion on the environment

    Open Access•Shouro Dasgupta, Enrica De Cian•Energy Research & Social Science•2018

  • Does the Conceptualization and Measurement of Democracy Quality Matter in Comparative Climate Policy Research

    Open Access•Romy Escher, Melanie Walter-Rogg•Politics and Governance•2018

  • Foreign Aid and Climate Change Policy

    Open Access•Daniel Yuichi Kono, Gabriella R Montinola•Politics and Governance•2019

  • Institutional Design and Elite Support for Climate Policies

    Open Access•D Freire, Umberto Mignozzetti et al.•Journal of Experimental Political…•2020

  • Solving the Moro problem

    Open Access•Gene Carolan•Journal of Aggression Conflict…•2016

  • The dilemma of informal governance with outside option as solution

    Open Access•Daniel Verdier•International Theory•2015

  • The limits of reputation on compliance

    Open Access•Rachel Brewster•International Theory•2009

  • International institutions

    Open Access•Lisa L Martins•International Theory•2017

  • Ratification of multilateral environmental agreements

    Vally Koubi, Steffen Mohrenberg et al.•Journal of Civil Society•2020

  • Explaining Nonratification of the Genocide Convention

    Open Access•Brian Greenhill, Michael Strausz•Foreign Policy Analysis•2013

  • Regulating Conflict

    Open Access•Geoffrey P R Wallace•Foreign Policy Analysis•2011

  • International Treaty Ratification and Leader Turnover

    Open Access•Tobias Böhmelt•Foreign Policy Analysis•2018

  • The Institutional Design of Arms Control Agreements

    Sarah E Krep, Sarah E Kreps•Foreign Policy Analysis•2016

  • The political feasibility of potent enforcement in a post-Kyoto climate agreement

    Open Access•Stine Aakre•International Environmental…•2014

  • State power and diffusion processes in the ratification of global environmental treaties, 1981–2008

    Open Access•Yoshiki Yamagata, Jue Yang et al.•International Environmental…•2016

  • The self-selection of democracies into treaty design

    Open Access•Tobias Böhmelt, Edita Butkutė•International Environmental…•2018

  • Effects of funding mechanisms on participation in multilateral environmental agreements

    Open Access•Steffen Mohrenberg, Vally Koubi et al.•International Environmental…•2018

  • The effectiveness of soft law in international environmental regimes

    Open Access•Maximilian S T Wanner•International Environmental…•2020

  • Water resources data and information exchange in transboundary water treaties

    Open Access•Andrea K Gerlak, Jonathan Lautze et al.•International Environmental…•2010

  • Environmental-agreement design and political ideology in democracies

    Open Access•Tobias Böhmelt•International Environmental…•2022

  • A contingency theory of policy innovation

    Open Access•Yoshiki Yamagata, Jue Yang et al.•International Environmental…•2012

  • The political economy of international environmental agreements

    Open Access•Leo Wangler, Juan-Carlos Altamirano-Cabrera et al.•International Environmental…•2012

  • China, the United States, bargaining, and climate change

    Open Access•Robert Y Shum•International Environmental…•2013

  • Environmental agreement under the non-interference principle

    Open Access•Fikri Muhammad•International Environmental…•2021

  • The impact of environmental interest groups in international negotiations

    Open Access•Tobias Böhmelt, Carola Betzold•International Environmental…•2012

  • The effects of treaty legality and domestic institutional hurdles on environmental treaty ratification

    Open Access•Gabriele Spilker, Vally Koubi•International Environmental…•2014

  • Diplomatic water cooperation

    Open Access•Lei Xie, Shaofeng Jia•International Environmental…•2016

  • Federalism's Fractured Decision Making in the Kyoto Protocol

    Open Access•Sarah Fisher•Politics & Policy•2015

  • The Political Economy of Carbon Capture and Storage Technology Adoption

    Elena V Mclean, Tatyana Plaksina•Global Environmental Politics•2019

  • Is There a Democracy–Civil Society Paradox in Global Environmental Governance

    Thomas Bernauer, Tobias Böhmelt et al.•Global Environmental Politics•2012

  • Is Democracy the Answer to Intractable Climate Change

    Angela Chesler, Debra Javeline et al.•Global Environmental Politics•2023

  • Right-Wing Populists and the Politics of Renegotiating International Environmental Agreements

    Open Access•Nguyen Huynh•Global Environmental Politics•2025

  • Assessing the Impact of Democratic Institutions and Administrative Capacity on National Carbon Emissions Reduction

    Open Access•Yue Sun, Yixin Dai et al.•Journal of Public Affairs•2025

  • Measuring countries’ cooperation within the international climate change regime

    Open Access•Michèle B Baettig, Simone Brander et al.•Environmental Science & Policy•2008

  • National climate policies in international comparison

    Open Access•Thomas Bernauer, Tobias Böhmelt•Environmental Science & Policy•2012

  • Potential for biofuel development in Tihvin and Boksitogorsk districts of the Leningrad region — The analysis of energy wood supply systems and costs

    Open Access•Vadim Goltsev, Ján Ilavský et al.•Forest Policy and Economics•2009

  • Understanding Climate Change Negotiations

    Larry Crump, Christian Downie•International Negotiation•2015

  • Limits to cooperation

    Elai Rettig•Israel Affairs•2016

  • The effect of vulnerability on climate change mitigation policies

    Open Access•Amit Tubi, Itay Fischhendler et al.•Global Environmental Change•2012

  • Climate policy innovation in the South – Domestic and international determinants of renewable energy policies in developing and emerging countries

    Open Access•Martin Stadelmann, Paula Castro•Global Environmental Change•2014

  • The political economy of passing climate change legislation

    Open Access•Samuel Fankhauser, Caterina Gennaioli et al.•Global Environmental Change•2015

  • Environmental Interest Groups and Authoritarian Regime Diversity

    Open Access•Tobias Böhmelt•Voluntas Revista Internacional de…•2013

  • Delayed ratification in environmental regimes

    Arran Hurley, Taedong Lee•The Pacific Review•2020

  • The future looks empty’

    Open Access•Osadolor Ebhuoma, Osadolor O Ebhuoma et al.•GeoJournal•2021

  • Reluctant ratifiers

    Giacomo Chiozza, Joseph M Grieco•International Interactions•2025

  • Learning and the Precision of International Investment Agreements

    Mark Manger, Clint Peinhardt•International Interactions•2017

  • Shallow commitments may bite deep

    Jessica Edry•International Interactions•2020

  • Exploring the nature of inter-country interactions in the process of ratifying international environmental agreements

    Open Access•Alexandre Sauquet•Public Choice•2014

  • Do Binding Beat Nonbinding Agreements? Regulating International Water Quality

    Open Access•Martin Köppel, Detlef F Sprinz•Journal of Conflict Resolution•2019

  • Term Limits and Environmental Treaty Commitments

    Open Access•Matthew Dilorenzo, Talor Stone•International Studies Quarterly•2021

  • Using Trade Provisions to Make Environmental Agreements More Dynamic

    Open Access•Jean-Frédéric Morin, Noémie Laurens et al.•International Studies Quarterly•2024

  • Designing the Optimal International Climate Agreement with Variability in Commitments

    Open Access•Jordan H Mcallister, Keith E Schnakenberg•International Organization•2022

  • Political Science Research on International Law

    Open Access•Emilie M Hafner-Burton, Emilie M Hafner‐burton et al.•American Journal of International…•2012

  • National Institutions and Global Public Goods

    Open Access•Michèle B Bättig, Thomas Bernauer•International Organization•2009

  • International regime formation revisited

    Open Access•Sophie Perrin, Thomas Bernauer•European Union Politics•2010

  • Is there an environmental version of the Kantian peace? Insights from water pollution in Europe

    Open Access•Thomas Bernauer, Patrick M Kuhn•European Journal of International…•2010

  • Cooperation by Treaty

    Open Access•Karolina M Milewicz, Duncan Snidal•International Organization•2016

  • Contestation and Resilience in the Liberal International Order

    Open Access•Alexander Thompson•Global Studies Quarterly•2024

  • External dimensions of E uropean environmental policy

    Open Access•Kai Schulze, J Tosun•European Journal of Political…•2013

  • The Politics of Energy

    Llewelyn Hughes, Phillip Y Lipscy•Annual Review of Political Science•2013

  • Strategies of Contestation

    Julia C Morse, Tyler Pratt•The Journal of Politics•2022

  • Compensating for the Climate

    Open Access•Daniel Yuichi Kono•Political Studies•2020

  • Signaling by Signature

    Open Access•David Hugh-Jones, Karolina Milewicz et al.•Political Science Research and…•2018

  • Power or Plenty

    Open Access•Emilie M Hafner-Burton, Emilie M Hafner‐burton et al.•Journal of Conflict Resolution•2008

  • What’s in a Claim? De Jure versus De Facto Borders in Interstate Territorial Disputes

    Open Access•Kenneth A Schultz•Journal of Conflict Resolution•2014

  • Intergovernmental Organizations and the Kantian Peace

    Open Access•Han Dorussen, Hugh Ward•Journal of Conflict Resolution•2008

  • IO Mediation of Interstate Conflicts

    Open Access•Hans E Hansen, Holley E Hansen et al.•Journal of Conflict Resolution•2008

  • Democratization and the Varieties of International Organizations

    Open Access•Edward D Mansfield, Jon C Pevehouse et al.•Journal of Conflict Resolution•2008

  • Why Do States Join Some Universal Treaties but Not Others? An Analysis of Treaty Commitment Preferences

    Open Access•Yonatan Lupu•Journal of Conflict Resolution•2016

  • Martial Law? Military Experience, International Law, and Support for Torture

    Open Access•Geoffrey P R Wallace, Geoffrey Pr Wallace•International Studies Quarterly•2014

  • Does Institutional Proliferation Undermine Cooperation? Theory and Evidence from Climate Change

    Open Access•Rowan•International Studies Quarterly•2021

  • Trade and Volatility at the Core and Periphery of the Global Economy

    Open Access•Julia Gray, Philip B K Potter•International Studies Quarterly•2012

  • Distributional Conflict Between Powerful States and International Treaty Ratification1

    Open Access•Christina J Schneider, Johannes Urpelainen•International Studies Quarterly•2013

  • Legal Traditions and Nonbinding Commitments

    Asif Efrat•International Studies Quarterly•2016

  • Do Arms Control Treaties Work? Assessing the Effectiveness of the Nuclear Nonproliferation Treaty

    Matthew Fuhrmann, Yonatan Lupu•International Studies Quarterly•2016

  • Thinking Ahead

    Open Access•Daniel J Blake, Daniel Blake•International Organization•2013

  • International Law and Public Attitudes Toward Torture

    Open Access•Geoffrey P R Wallace•International Organization•2013

  • Can International Nongovernmental Organizations Boost Government Services? The Case of Health

    Open Access•Amanda Murdie, A Hicks•International Organization•2013

  • Delayed Ratification

    Open Access•Yoram Z Haftel, Alexander Thompson•International Organization•2013

  • The marginal impact of Engos in different types of democratic systems

    Open Access•Tobias Böhmelt, Thomas Bernauer et al.•European Political Science Review•2015

  • Do indicators influence treaty ratification? The relationship between mid‐range performance and policy change

    Open Access•Shaina D Western•European Journal of Political…•2022

  • Civil society participation in global governance

    Open Access•Tobias Böhmelt, Vally Koubi et al.•European Journal of Political…•2014

  • International Environmental Regimes

    Tobias Böhmelt, Ulrich Pilster et al.•Australian Journal of Political…•2010

  • Network analysis approach to China’s cooperative multilateral strategy in Asia between 1995 and 2020

    Volha Kryvets•Asian Journal of Political Science•2023

  • Climate Change Politics

    Thomas Bernauer•Annual Review of Political Science•2013

  • A Comparison of International and Domestic Sources of Global Governance Dynamics

    Open Access•Thomas Bernauer, Anna Kalbhenn et al.•British Journal of Political…•2010

  • Profitable Participation

    Open Access•Christopher Marcoux, Johannes Urpelainen•British Journal of Political…•2014

  • Reserved Ratification

    Open Access•Heather Elko Mckibben, Shaina D Western•British Journal of Political…•2020

  • Interests, Norms and Support for the Provision of Global Public Goods

    Open Access•Michael M Bechtel, Federica Genovese et al.•British Journal of Political…•2019

  • Rational design in motion

    Open Access•Alexander Thompson•European Journal of International…•2010

  • Do parties matter for international environmental cooperation? An analysis of environmental treaty participation by advanced industrialised democracies

    Kai Schulze•Environmental Politics•2014

  • Drivers of ratification rates in global biodiversity governance

    Jae-Mahn Shim, Eunjung Shin et al.•Environmental Politics•2020

  • Consensus Treaties

    Scott Barrett•Journal of Institutional and…•2002

  • International Organization

    John J Kirton•International Organization•2017

  • Global Environmental Politics

    Pamela S Chasek, David Leonard Downie et al.•Global Environmental Politics•2018

  • Death Penalty Abolition and the Ratification of the Second Optional Protocol

    E Neumayer•The International Journal of…•2008

  • The Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties

    J S Stanford•University of Toronto Law Journal•1970

  • The Clean Development Mechanism

    Open Access•Robert Repetto•Policy Sciences•2001

  • Investments in Global Warming Mitigation

    Open Access•Nives Dolšak, Maureen Dunn•Policy Sciences•2006

  • The Incidence and Timing of PAC Contributions to Incumbent U.S. House Members, 1993-94

    Open Access•J M Box-Steffensmeier, Peter M Radcliffe et al.•Legislative Studies Quarterly•2005

  • Explaining Commitment

    Jay Goodliffe, Darren Hawkins et al.•The Journal of Politics•2006

  • Power or Plenty

    Open Access•Emilie M Hafner-Burton, Emilie M Hafner‐burton et al.•Journal of Conflict Resolution•2008

  • Why Do Countries Commit to Human Rights Treaties

    Open Access•Oona A Hathaway•Journal of Conflict Resolution•2007

  • Intergovernmental Organizations and the Kantian Peace

    Open Access•Han Dorussen, Hugh Ward•Journal of Conflict Resolution•2008

  • IO Mediation of Interstate Conflicts

    Open Access•Hans E Hansen, Holley E Hansen et al.•Journal of Conflict Resolution•2008

  • Democratization and the Varieties of International Organizations

    Open Access•Edward D Mansfield, Jon C Pevehouse et al.•Journal of Conflict Resolution•2008

  • Power Positions

    Open Access•Emilie M Hafner-Burton, Emilie M Hafner‐burton et al.•Journal of Conflict Resolution•2006

  • Democracy and Environmental Degradation

    Open Access•Quan Li, Rafael Reuveny•International Studies Quarterly•2006

  • States, NGOs, and International Environmental Institutions

    Open Access•Kal Raustiala•International Studies Quarterly•1997

  • Introduction

    Beth A Simmons, Frank Dobbins et al.•International Organization•2006

  • The Optimal Design of International Trade Institutions

    Open Access•B Peter Rosendorff, Helen V Milner•International Organization•2001

  • The Concept of Legalization

    Open Access•Kenneth W Abbott, Robert O Keohane et al.•International Organization•2000

  • International Norm Dynamics and Political Change

    Open Access•Martha Finnemore, Kathryn Sikkink•International Organization•1998

  • On compliance

    Open Access•Abram Chayes, Antonia Handler Chayes•International Organization•1993

  • Trading Human Rights

    Emilie M Hafner-Burton, Emilie M Hafner‐burton•International Organization•2005

  • Hard and Soft Law in International Governance

    Open Access•Kenneth W Abbott, Duncan Snidal•International Organization•2000

  • The Rational Design of International Institutions

    Open Access•Barbara Koremenos, Charles Lipson et al.•International Organization•2001

  • Is the good news about compliance good news about cooperation

    Open Access•George W Downs, David M Rocke et al.•International Organization•1996

  • Loosening the Ties that Bind

    Open Access•Barbara Koremenos•International Organization•2001

  • Is There a Broader-Deeper Trade-off in International Multilateral Agreements

    Michael J Gilligan•International Organization•2004

  • Politics and International Legal Obligation

    Open Access•Christian Reus-Smit•European Journal of International…•2003

  • The Regime Complex for Plant Genetic Resources

    Kal Raustiala, David G Victor•International Organization•2004

  • Do Democracies Exhibit Stronger International Environmental Commitment? A Cross-country Analysis

    Open Access•E Neumayer•Journal of Peace Research•2002

  • International Linkages and Environmental Sustainability

    Open Access•Hugh Ward•Journal of Peace Research•2006

  • Do Treaties Constrain or Screen? Selection Bias and Treaty Compliance

    Open Access•Jana Von Stein•American Political Science Review•2005

  • Contracting around International Uncertainty

    Open Access•Barbara Koremenos•American Political Science Review•2005

  • International Law and State Behavior

    Open Access•Beth A Simmons•American Political Science Review•2000

  • The Intergovernmental Network of World Trade

    Paul Ingram, Jeffrey Robinson et al.•American Journal of Sociology•2005

Unique citing works101
Citations per year5,61
Citation span2008 - 2026 (19)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedYes
Citation typesNeutral: 100

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae