Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Why Do Young Men Oppose Gender Quotas? Group Threat and Backlash to Legislative Gender Quotas

Bibliographic Data

ID6300440
AuthorsJeong Hyun Kim (0000-0001-6584-6793, Yonsei University), Yesola Kweon (0000-0003-1245-2779, Sungkyunkwan University, corresponding author)
Year2022
Volume47
Issue4
Pages991-1021
Publication date2022-11-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueLegislative Studies Quarterly (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0362-9805 • E-ISSN: 1939-9162
PublisherWiley (PUBLISHER • GB)
DOI10.1111/lsq.12371
OpenAlexW4206931231
LanguageEN
Citations received38
References cited66

Despite increasing efforts to implement legislative gender quotas, many countries still encounter substantial popular opposition to this policy. Previous work cannot explain why opposition to legislative gender quotas persists, particularly among young men, a group believed to be open to diversity. We develop and test a theoretical framework linking group threat to men's attitudes toward legislative gender quotas. While the salience of perceived group threat could trigger men's opposition to legislative gender quotas, we expect that this effect will be more profound among young men due to the heightened degree of economic insecurity experienced by younger generations. Using original survey experiments in South Korea, this study demonstrates the strong influence of group threat in the formation of negative attitudes toward legislative gender quotas among young men. These effects, however, are not mediated by traditional gender norms. Our findings have significant implications for the study of gender and politics and democratic representation

Backlash · Corporate governance · Demographic economics · Economics · Gender diversity · Legislature · Opposition (politics · Political science · Politics · Salience (neuroscience · Electoral Systems and Political Participation · Gender Politics and Representation · Law · Populism, Right-Wing Movements · Psychology · Social Psychology

  • Breadwinner backlash

    Open Access•Richard Clark, Roza Khoban et al.•American Journal of Political…•2026

  • Correcting Misperceptions Across Contexts

    Open Access•Min Hee Go, Yesola Kweon et al.•Public Opinion Quarterly•2026

  • All employees benefit

    Open Access•Nikola Komlenac, Liora Neugebauer et al.•Humanities and Social Sciences…•2023

  • Gender equality in academia

    Carolina Feliciana Machado, Regina Leite et al.•Studies in Higher Education•2025

  • A Systematic Review of Prevalence Rates and Associated Factors of Intimate Partner Violence Against Women in the Young Adult Population

    Open Access•Magaly L García-Senlle, Faraj A Santirso et al.•Trauma Violence & Abuse•2026

  • Gendered backsliding

    Open Access•Eunbin Chung, Youn Ki et al.•Frontiers in Political Science•2026

  • Increasing Women in Construction Using Public Procurement

    Open Access•Sarah Holdsworth, Orana Sandri et al.•Gender Work and Organization•2026

  • Intersectional discrimination, bullying/cyberbullying, and suicidal ideation among South Korean youths

    Open Access•Hyun Lee, Heejung Yi•International Journal of…•2022

  • Women’s issues, critical actors and the media

    Jaemin Shim•European Journal of Politics and…•2023

  • From frustration to radicalization

    Open Access•Álvaro Calvo Rodríguez, Monica Ferrín•Political Research Exchange•2026

  • Pro-equality initiatives increase expressed sexism among men but may improve trust among women football fans

    Open Access•Victor Araújo, Malu A C Gatto•Journal of Experimental Political…•2025

  • Adopting a gender quota policy in Qatar

    Open Access•Noora Lari•Gender in Management An…•2023

  • A gender-based pandemic? Covid-19 and attitudes towards gender and relief policies in South Korea

    Hannah June Kim, Phoebe W Moon•Journal of Asian Public Policy•2025

  • Perceptions of Feminism as a Threat

    Open Access•Eva Anduiza, Gefjon Off•Politics & Gender•2026

  • The Role of Misogyny in the 2022 Korean Presidential Election

    Open Access•Matthew Jenkins, Hannah June Kim•Journal of East Asian Studies•2024

  • Democracy and changing leadership preferences among young individuals

    Open Access•Hannah June Kim•Japanese Journal of Political…•2025

  • Enhancing Evaluations of Female Politicians’ Suitability for the Foreign Affairs Portfolio

    Open Access•Fahd Humayun•Political Research Quarterly•2025

  • Lower-Stakes Legislative Collaborations, Ethnicity, and Gender

    Open Access•William O’brochta•Political Research Quarterly•2024

  • Male Victimhood Ideology Among Korean Men

    Open Access•Joeun Kim•Sex Roles•2024

  • Economic Frustration and Resistance to Gender Equality among Young Korean Men

    Hanna Kim, Youngdeuk Park•Asian Survey•2024

  • Is there a growing gender divide among young adults in regard to ideological left–right self-placement? Evidence from 32 European countries

    Open Access•Richard Nennstiel, A Hudde•European Sociological Review•2025

  • Is there a gender youth gap in far-right voting and cultural attitudes

    Gefjon Off, Amy C Alexander et al.•European Journal of Politics and…•2025

  • Narratives of Backlash? Perceptions of Changing Status Hierarchies in Open-Ended Survey Responses

    Open Access•Magdalena Breyer, Tabea Palmtag et al.•Comparative Political Studies•2025

  • Economic Insecurity or Political Fragility? Group-based Threat and Declining Support for Gender Equality in South Korea

    Open Access•Hannah June Kim, Danbee Lee et al.•Asian Women•2025

  • Blaming feminists, claiming pain

    Open Access•Young-Im Lee•Women s Studies International Forum•2025

  • Opposition to Women Political Leaders

    Open Access•Yoshinobu Endo, Yoshikuni Ono•Women & Politics•2023

  • Young men, gendered labour market competition, and opposition to gender equality policy across 27 EU countries

    Open Access•Amy Alexander, N Charron et al.•West European Politics•2025

  • Who Gets to Speak? How Institutions and Political Careers Shape Gender Bias in South Africa’s Parliamentary Debates

    Open Access•Edalina Rodrigues Sanches, Ana Espírito-Santo•Politics & Gender•2025

  • Revisiting Candidate Gender Effects

    Open Access•Yesola Kweon, Woo Chang Kang et al.•Politics & Gender•2025

  • Limited Impact of Introducing Proportional Representation on Women’s Representation

    Open Access•Michał Gulczyński, Monika Koeppl-Turyna et al.•Political Studies•2025

  • We see symbols but not saviors

    Open Access•Yesola Kweon•Political Psychology•2024

  • The dual impact of meritocracy and denial of gender discrimination in political candidacy

    Open Access•Hanna Kim•Political Psychology•2025

  • Multidimensional and intersectional cultural grievances over gender, sexuality and immigration

    Open Access•Gefjon Off•European Journal of Political…•2024

  • Backlash or Progressive Mobilization? Voter Reactions to Perceived Trajectories of Women’s Representation

    Open Access•Magdalena Breyer•Comparative Political Studies•2024

  • Substantive representation for and by women

    Soojin Kim, Yunsoo Lee et al.•Asian Journal of Political Science•2025

  • Violence against politicians in Ireland

    Fiona Buckley, Lisa Keenan et al.•Irish Political Studies•2025

  • Electoral Gender Quotas and Democratic Legitimacy

    Open Access•Anthony Clayton, Diana Z O’brien et al.•American Political Science Review•2025

  • Men's decline and rising support for hostile sexism

    Open Access•Joeun Kim•Social Science Research•2025

  • A Grand Gender Convergence

    Claudia Goldin•American Economic Review•2014

  • Status threat, not economic hardship, explains the 2016 presidential vote

    Open Access•Diana C Mutz•Proceedings of the National…•2018

  • Cultural Backlash

    Open Access•P Norris, Ronald Inglehart•Cultural Backlash•2019

  • The Impact of Gender Quotas

    Susan Franceschet, Mona Lena Krook et al.•The impact of gender quotas•2012

  • Us Against Them

    Donald R Kinder, Cindy D Kam•Us Against Them•2009

  • Rising Tide

    Open Access•Ronald Inglehart, P Norris•Rising Tide•2003

  • Mothers and Sons

    R Fernandez, Alessandra Fogli et al.•The Quarterly Journal of Economics•2004

  • Powerful Women

    Lori Beaman, Raghabendra Chattopadhyay et al.•The Quarterly Journal of Economics•2009

  • Refusing to know a woman’s place

    A E Smith, Katherine Warming et al.•Politics Groups and Identities•2016

  • Campaigns, descriptive representation, quotas and women’s political engagement in Mexico

    Yann P Kerevel, Lonna Rae Atkeson•Politics Groups and Identities•2017

  • Contesting gender quotas

    Mona Lena Krook•Politics Groups and Identities•2016

  • Empowerment versus backlash

    Mona Lena Krook•Politics Groups and Identities•2015

  • Modern Sexism and the 2012 U.S. Presidential Election

    Elizabeth N Simas, Marcia Bumgardner•Politics & Gender•2017

  • Conceptualizing Backlash

    Ana Jordan•Canadian Journal of Women and the…•2016

  • When Women’s Gains Equal Men’s Losses

    Open Access•Joelle C Ruthig, Andre Kehn et al.•Sex Roles•2016

  • Perceptions of Gender Discrimination across Six Decades

    Open Access•Andre Kehn, Joelle C Ruthig•Sex Roles•2013

  • Support for Far Right Ideology and Anti-Migrant Attitudes among Youth in Europe

    Open Access•Inta Mieriņa, Ilze Koroļeva•The Sociological Review•2015

  • Intergroup Competition and Attitudes Toward Immigrants and Immigration

    Open Access•Victoria M Esses, Lynne M Jackson et al.•Journal of Social Issues•1998

  • The Dilemma of Gender Equality

    Open Access•Trine Iversen, Torben Iversen et al.•Daedalus•2020

  • You can win but I can't lose

    Open Access•Clara L Wilkins, J Douglas Wellman et al.•Journal of Experimental Social…•2014

  • Contextual Determinants of Feminist Attitudes

    Open Access•Lee Ann Banaszak, Eric Plutzer•American Political Science Review•1993

  • Playing the Woman Card

    Open Access•Erin C Cassese, Mirya R Holman•Political Psychology•2018

  • Reassessing Public Support for a Female President

    Barry C Burden, Barry Burden et al.•The Journal of Politics•2017

  • Making Space for Women

    Tiffany D Barnes, Abby Córdova•The Journal of Politics•2016

  • See Jane Run

    David E Campbell, Christina Wolbrecht•The Journal of Politics•2006

  • Mobilizing Sexism

    Open Access•Nicholas A Valentino, Carly N Wayne et al.•Public Opinion Quarterly•2018

  • Gender Quotas and Women's Substantive Representation

    Open Access•Susan Franceschet, Jennifer M Piscopo•Politics & Gender•2008

  • Change in Women's Descriptive Representation and the Belief in Women's Ability to Govern

    Open Access•Amy C Alexander•Politics & Gender•2012

  • Toward a Theory of Backlash

    Open Access•Joanna Mansbridge, Jane Mansbridge et al.•Politics & Gender•2008

  • Deservingness Heuristics and Policy Attitudes toward the Elderly in an Aging Society

    Open Access•Yesola Kweon, Byeonghwa Choi•Political Research Quarterly•2022

  • Electoral Systems and the Substantive Representation of Marginalized Groups

    Open Access•Yesola Kweon, James M Ryan•Political Research Quarterly•2022

  • Antiwomen But Proquota

    Open Access•Katrine Beauregard, Jill Sheppard•Political Psychology•2021

  • A Change is Gonna Come

    Open Access•Tatishe M Nteta, Tatishe Nteta et al.•Political Psychology•2013

  • Gender Attitudes and Public Opinion Towards Electoral Gender Quotas in Brazil

    Open Access•Frederico Batista Pereira, Nathália F F Porto•Political Psychology•2020

  • The Roots of the Gender Gap in Political Knowledge in Adolescence

    Open Access•Jennifer Wolak, Michael Mcdevitt•Political Behavior•2011

  • The Contingent Effects of Candidate Sex on Voter Choice

    Open Access•Yoshikuni Ono, Barry C Burden et al.•Political Behavior•2019

  • Extreme Pessimists? Expected Socioeconomic Downward Mobility and the Political Attitudes of Young Adults

    Open Access•Elena Cristina Mitrea, Monika Mühlböck et al.•Political Behavior•2021

  • Cheap Labor

    Open Access•Desmond King, David Rueda•Perspectives on Politics•2008

  • Elected Bodies

    Open Access•Lisa Baldez•Legislative Studies Quarterly•2004

  • Concepts of Representation among Female and Male State Legislators

    Open Access•Beth Reingold•Legislative Studies Quarterly•1992

  • Connecting Descriptive and Substantive Representation

    Open Access•Michele L Swers•Legislative Studies Quarterly•2005

  • Playing with different cards

    Open Access•Tània Verge Mestre, Tánia Verge et al.•International Political Science…•2014

  • Political opportunity structures and right‐wing extremist party success

    Open Access•Kai Arzheimer, Elisabeth Carter•European Journal of Political…•2006

  • Labour market risks and political preferences

    Open Access•Paul Marx•European Journal of Political…•2014

  • Why Are Gender Quota Laws Adopted by Men? The Role of Inter- and Intraparty Competition

    Open Access•Ana Catalano Weeks•Comparative Political Studies•2018

  • Roots of the Radical Right

    Open Access•Justin Gest, Tyler T Reny et al.•Comparative Political Studies•2018

  • Women’s Political Engagement Under Quota-Mandated Female Representation

    Open Access•Anthony Clayton, Amanda Clayton•Comparative Political Studies•2015

  • Partisanship and the gender gap

    Katrine Beauregard•Australian Journal of Political…•2018

  • Rising to the Top

    Open Access•Diana Z O’brien, Diana Z O''Brien et al.•American Journal of Political…•2015

  • Dimensions of Sociotropic Behavior

    Diana C Mutz, Jeffery J Mondak•American Journal of Political…•1997

  • Defending the Realm

    Open Access•Tiffany D Barnes, Diana Z O’brien et al.•American Journal of Political…•2018

  • Leading by Example

    Open Access•Christina Wolbrecht, David E Campbell•American Journal of Political…•2007

  • Incumbents' Interests and Gender Quotas

    Open Access•Guillaume Fréchette, Guillaume R Fréchette et al.•American Journal of Political…•2008

  • Who Gets What

    Open Access•Jane Green, Timothy Hellwig et al.•British Journal of Political…•2022

  • Who supports gender quotas in Ireland

    Lisa Keenan, Gail Mcelroy•Irish Political Studies•2017

  • Political conservatism as motivated social cognition

    John T Jost, Jack Glaser et al.•Psychological Bulletin•2003

  • Types of labor market policy and the electoral behavior of insecure workers

    Open Access•Yesola Kweon•Electoral Studies•2018

  • The Homecoming of American College Women

    Open Access•Claudia Goldin, Lawrence F Katz et al.•The Journal of Economic…•2006

  • Residues of a Movement

    Open Access•M Kent Jenning, M Kent Jennings•American Political Science Review•1987

  • Latin American Attitudes toward Women in Politics

    Open Access•Jana Morgan, Melissa Buice et al.•American Political Science Review•2013

  • Rethinking Tokenism

    Open Access•Janice D Yoder•Gender & Society•1991

  • Breadwinning Wives and 'Left-Behind' Husbands

    Open Access•L A Hoang, B S A Yeoh•Gender & Society•2011

Unique citing works38
Citations per year9,5
Citation span2022 - 2026 (5)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 37

Tools

Open DOI
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae