Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Sore losers? The costs of intra-party democracy

Bibliographic Data

ID6314712
AuthorsWilliam P Cro (0000-0002-1700-031X, Carleton University), William Cro, William Cross (0000-0003-0921-1464, Carleton University), Scott Pruyser (0000-0001-5557-0404, University of Calgary, corresponding author)
Year2019
Volume25
Issue4
Pages483-494
Publication date2019-07-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueParty Politics (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 1354-0688 • E-ISSN: 1460-3683
PublisherSAGE Publications Inc (PUBLISHER)
DOI10.1177/1354068817728216
OpenAlexW2753712221
LanguageEN
Citations received27
References cited63

Drawing upon the ‘satisfaction with democracy’ and ‘divisive primary’ literatures, this article examines how losers of intra-party elections respond to defeat and the consequences that these choices have on party organization and strength. In other words, do losers of intra-party elections continue to support the party or do they, like losers of general elections, feel less satisfied with democracy and withdraw their support (or even ‘exit’ the party)? Exploring rates of membership activism and satisfaction from a recent study of Canadian party members, this article demonstrates that losers of intra-party elections are more likely to exit the party, significantly less likely to remain active and engaged in party politics, and significantly more likely to report dissatisfaction with party membership. These findings suggest that parties must find a way of keeping losers engaged with the party

Communism · Democracy · Political economy · Political science · Politics · Primary election · Realigning election · Single non-transferable vote · Socialism · Sociology · Split-ticket voting · Electoral Systems and Political Participation · Gender Politics and Representation · Law · Public Administration · Social Media and Politics

  • The winner-loser gap and support for remote voting methods – evidence from Canadian municipal elections

    Open Access•R Michael Mcgregor, Scott Pruyser et al.•Journal of Information Technology…•2026

  • Throwing the baby away with the bathwater

    Open Access•Kwame Asamoah, Emmanuel Yeboah-Assiamah•SN Social Sciences•2024

  • Primarias abiertas legales en Chile. Reflexiones a diez (agitados y convulsivos) años de su sanción formal

    Open Access•A Gallo, Rodrigo Díaz Esterio•Colombia Internacional•2024

  • Do Losing Candidates Harbor Illiberal Attitudes

    Open Access•Michael Barber, Hans J G Hassell et al.•Political Behavior•2026

  • Youth’s low presence in parliament

    Daniel Stockemer, Kaitlin Gallant et al.•Politics Groups and Identities•2023

  • Choosing among the chosen? Electoral lists and party primaries in Europe

    Carles Pamies, Gonzalo C Garcia•Journal of Contemporary European…•2023

  • Regierungsfindung mit Basisbeteiligung

    Open Access•Oliver Kannenberg, Danny Schindler•Zeitschrift für Politikwissenschaft•2024

  • Party research and party support aid

    Open Access•Susan E Scarrow, Fernando Casal Bértoa•Party Politics•2026

  • Banking on victory? Gender, campaign spending, and candidate nomination outcomes in Canada

    Open Access•Scott Pruyser, Rob Currie-Wood•Party Politics•2025

  • Party primaries and turnout

    Open Access•Francisco Ramón Villaplana Jiménez, Adrián Megías et al.•Party Politics•2023

  • Can political parties narrow the intra-party winner-loser gap? An experimental test of the moderating impact of strategic communication

    Open Access•Leen Lingier•Electoral Studies•2024

  • May’s Law in changing times—an empirical assessment of the German case

    Open Access•Frederik Springer•Acta Politica•2026

  • Inclusive candidate selection and corruption

    Open Access•N Charron, Jana Schwenk•West European Politics•2023

  • Try, Try Again? Are Unsuccessful Leadership Contestants Sore Losers

    Scott Pruyser•Representation•2025

  • Intra-Party Democracy and Party Unity

    Susan E Scarrow•Representation•2021

  • Do Primaries Improve Evaluations of Public Officials? Experimental Evidence from Mexico

    Open Access•Sergio J Ascencio, Han Il Chang•Political Behavior•2024

  • What drives the intra-party democracy of the “Alternative for Germany

    Open Access•Anna-Sophie Heinze, Benjamin Höhne et al.•Party Politics•2024

  • More free-floating, less outward-looking

    Open Access•Danny Schindler•Party Politics•2021

  • Lost but not blown away

    Open Access•Leen Lingier, Anna Kern et al.•Party Politics•2024

  • The informal rules of candidate selection and their impact on intra-party competition

    Open Access•Marion Reiser•Party Politics•2024

  • District candidacies for the German Bundestag

    Danny Schindler, Anastasia Pyschny et al.•Journal of Legislative Studies•2023

  • Sour Grapes? Party Donors and Canadian Leadership Primaries

    Open Access•Scott Pruyser•Government and Opposition•2024

  • Intra-Party Leadership Contests and Effect on Levels of Satisfaction with Democracy on Party Voters

    Open Access•Yiannos Katsourides, Nikos Ioannidis•Government and Opposition•2025

  • The Politics of Loyalty

    Open Access•Fulvio Venturino, Antonella Seddone•Government and Opposition•2022

  • Democracy or discord? how citizens judge contested party leadership races

    Javier Astudillo, Toni Rodon•Democratization•2025

  • Incentives to Join a Local Party Association

    Open Access•Scott Pruyser•Canadian Journal of Political…•2025

  • The Local Determinants of Representation

    Open Access•William P Cro, William P Cross et al.•Canadian Journal of Political…•2019

  • Labour’s Grass Roots

    Patrick Seyd, Paul Whiteley•Labour's grass roots•1992

  • The Challenges of Intra-Party Democracy

    William P Cross, Richard S Katz•Challenges of Intra-Party Democracy•2013

  • Democracy within Parties

    Reuven Y Hazan, Gideon Rahat•Democracy Within Parties…•2010

  • Parties and Their Members

    Susan E Scarrow•Parties and their members•1996

  • Party Members and Activists

    Emilie Van Haute, Anika Gauja•Party Members and Activists•2015

  • The Selection of Political Party Leaders in Contemporary Parliamentary Democracies

    Klaus Detterbeck, Ingo Rohlfing et al.•Selection of Political Party…•2014

  • The Politics of Party Leadership

    William Cross, Jean-Benoit Pilet•The Politics of Party Leadership•2015

  • The Rise of Candidate-Centered Politics

    Martin P Wattenberg, Martin Wattenberg•Rise of Candidate-Centered Politics•1991

  • Politics, parties, & pressure groups.

    V O Key•Politics, parties, & pressure…•1964

  • Voter Turnout and the Dynamics of Electoral Competition in Established Democracies since 1945

    Open Access•Mark N Franklin, Cees Van Der Eijk et al.•Voter Turnout and the Dynamics of…•2004

  • Critical Citizens

    Pippa Norris•Critical citizens•1999

  • Democratic Phoenix

    Open Access•P Norris•Democratic Phoenix•2002

  • Losers' Consent

    Christopher Anderson, Christopher J Anderson et al.•Losers' consent•2005

  • Exit, Voice, and Loyalty

    Albert Otto Hirschman•Exit, voice, and loyalty•1970

  • The effects of primaries on electoral performance

    Open Access•Marino De Luca, Fulvio Venturino•French Politics•2016

  • Narrow Victories and Hard Games

    Open Access•Amber Wichowsky, Sarah Niebler et al.•American Politics Research•2010

  • Individualised Constituency Campaigns in Mixed-Member Electoral Systems

    Thomas Zittel, Thomas Gschwend•West European Politics•2008

  • Performance, leadership, factions and party change

    Robert Harmel, Uk Heo et al.•West European Politics•1995

  • Divisive Nominating Mechanisms and Democratic Party Electoral Prospects

    James I Lengle, Diana Owens et al.•The Journal of Politics•1995

  • Primary Divisiveness and General Election Success

    James E Piereson, Terry B Smith•The Journal of Politics•1975

  • Party Primaries

    Ofer Kenig, William P Cro et al.•Representation•2015

  • The Continued Relevance of Local Parties in Representative Democracies

    Open Access•Alistair Clark•Politics•2004

  • Winning, Losing and Satisfaction with Democracy

    Open Access•André Blais, François Gélineau•Political Studies•2007

  • Informal Influences in Selecting Female Political Candidates

    Open Access•Christine Cheng, M Tavits•Political Research Quarterly•2011

  • Incentives to Membership in Canadian Political Parties

    Open Access•Lisa Young, William P Cro et al.•Political Research Quarterly•2002

  • The Personalization(s) of Politics

    Gideon Rahat, Tamir Sheafer•Political Communication•2007

  • The politics of disgruntlement

    Open Access•Priscilla L Southwell•Political Behavior•1986

  • Parties and the Expansion of Direct Democracy

    Open Access•Susan E Scarrow•Party Politics•1999

  • Democracy and Political Parties

    Open Access•Gideon Rahat, Reuven Y Hazan et al.•Party Politics•2008

  • Two routes to personalized politics

    Open Access•Meital Balmas, Gideon Rahat et al.•Party Politics•2014

  • Candidate Selection Methods

    Open Access•Gideon Rahat, Reuven Y Hazan•Party Politics•2001

  • New Parties/New Politics

    Open Access•Patrick Seyd•Party Politics•1999

  • The Rise of Plebiscitary Democracy in Canadian Political Parties

    Open Access•Lisa Young, William P Cro et al.•Party Politics•2002

  • Democratizing a Democratic Procedure

    Open Access•Lars Bille•Party Politics•2001

  • The personalization of politics in Australia

    Open Access•I Mcallister•Party Politics•2015

  • Candidate campaigning in parliamentary systems

    Open Access•Rune Karlsen, Eli Skogerbø•Party Politics•2015

  • Party as linkage

    Open Access•Richard S Katz•European Journal of Political…•1990

  • The ‘paradox of enrollment

    Open Access•Susan E Scarrow•European Journal of Political…•1994

  • The Importance of Local Party Activity in Understanding Canadian Politics

    Open Access•William P Cro, William Cro et al.•Canadian Journal of Political…•2016

  • The Changing Leadership Electorate

    Open Access•D Stewart, David K Stewart•Canadian Journal of Political…•1997

  • Research Note

    Open Access•Scott Pruyser, William P Cro et al.•Canadian Journal of Political…•2016

  • Evolving membership strategies in Australian political parties

    William P Cro, William Cro et al.•Australian Journal of Political…•2014

  • The Relationship between Divisive Primaries and General Election Outcomes

    Patrick J Kenney, Tom W Rice•American Journal of Political…•1987

  • Democracy, Institutions and Attitudes about Citizen Influence on Government

    Open Access•Shaun Bowler, Todd Donovan•British Journal of Political…•2002

  • Divisive’ Primaries

    Open Access•Alan Ware•British Journal of Political…•1979

  • Candidate centred campaigning in a party centred context

    Open Access•Lieven De Winter, Pierre Baudewyns•Electoral Studies•2015

  • Candidate Selection in Canada

    Open Access•Scott Pruyser, Scott Pruysers et al.•American Behavioral Scientist•2016

  • Winning over voters or fighting party comrades? Personalized constituency campaigning in Austria

    Open Access•Nikolaus Eder, Marcelo Jenny et al.•Electoral Studies•2015

  • Personalization of campaigns in an SMP system

    Open Access•William P Cro, William Cro et al.•Electoral Studies•2015

  • So who really does the donkey work in 'multi-speed membership parties'? Comparing the election campaign activity of party members and party supporters

    Open Access•Paul Webb, Paul D Webb et al.•Electoral Studies•2017

  • Democratization of party leadership selection

    Open Access•Ofer Kenig•Electoral Studies•2009

  • Constituency candidates in comparative perspective - How personalized are constituency campaigns, why, and does it matter

    Open Access•Thomas Zittel•Electoral Studies•2015

  • The Divisive Primary Revisited

    Open Access•Donald Bruce Johnson, James R Gibson•American Political Science Review•1974

Unique citing works27
Citations per year3,86
Citation span2019 - 2026 (8)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 26

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae