Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Estimating Latent Structure Models with Categorical Variables

One-Step Versus Three-Step Estimators

Bibliographic Data

ID7971052
AuthorsAnnabel Bolck (Netherlands Forensic Institute), Marcel A Croon (Tilburg University), Marcel Croon, Jacques A Hagenaars (Tilburg University), Jacques Hagenaars
Year2004
Volume12
Issue1
Pages3-27
Publication date2004-01-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenuePolitical Analysis (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 1047-1987 • E-ISSN: 1476-4989
PublisherCambridge University Press (CUP) (PUBLISHER)
DOI10.1093/pan/mph001
OpenAlexW2061736358
LanguageEN
Citations received445
References cited18

We study the properties of a three-step approach to estimating the parameters of a latent structure model for categorical data and propose a simple correction for a common source of bias. Such models have a measurement part (essentially the latent class model) and a structural (causal) part (essentially a system of logit equations). In the three-step approach, a stand-alone measurement model is first defined and its parameters are estimated. Individual predicted scores on the latent variables are then computed from the parameter estimates of the measurement model and the individual observed scoring patterns on the indicators. Finally, these predicted scores are used in the causal part and treated as observed variables. We show that such a naive use of predicted latent scores cannot be recommended since it leads to a systematic underestimation of the strength of the association among the variables in the structural part of the models. However, a simple correction procedure can eliminate this systematic bias. This approach is illustrated on simulated and real data. A method that uses multiple imputation to account for the fact that the predicted latent variables are random variables can produce standard errors for the parameters in the structural part of the model

Categorical variable · Econometrics · Estimator · Imputation (statistics · Latent class model · Latent variable · Latent variable model · Local independence · Logit · Missing data · Statistics · Structural equation modeling · Advanced Causal Inference Techniques · Bayesian Modeling and Causal Inference · Computer Science · Mathematics · Statistical Methods and Bayesian Inference

  • Understanding employees’ work location preferences. An exploration of German data using latent class analysis

    Open Access•Marie-Therese Wiese, Ricarda Reich et al.•Community Work & Family•2026

  • Patterns of Digital and In-Person Sexual Behaviors Among Adolescents

    Open Access•Judith Kotiuga, Emma Sell-Goodhand et al.•The Journal of Sex Research•2026

  • Negative emotional eating patterns in Chinese adolescents

    Open Access•Hongbin Weng, Wesley R Barnhart et al.•Appetite•2025

  • Understanding the ecological context of mental, emotional, and behavioral health problems

    Open Access•Patricia Logan-Greene, Brad Linn et al.•Journal of Community Psychology•2019

  • PoLCA

    Open Access•Drew A Linzer, Jamie B Lewis et al.•Journal of Statistical Software•2011

  • Informative tools for characterizing individual differences in learning

    Open Access•Marian Hickendorff, Peter A Edelsbrunner et al.•Learning and Individual Differences•2018

  • Are Commitment Profiles Stable and Predictable? A Latent Transition Analysis

    Open Access•Chester Chun Seng Kam, Chester Kam et al.•Journal of Management•2016

  • A Multifoci Person-Centered Perspective on Workplace Affective Commitment

    Open Access•Alexandre J S Morin, Julien Morizot et al.•Organizational Research Methods•2011

  • Eliminating Bias in Classify-Analyze Approaches for Latent Class Analysis

    Bethany C Bray, Stephanie T Lanza et al.•Structural Equation Modeling: A…•2015

  • General Growth Mixture Analysis of Adolescents' Developmental Trajectories of Anxiety

    Alexandre J S Morin, Christophe Maïano et al.•Structural Equation Modeling: A…•2011

  • Extensions of Auxiliary Variable Approaches for the Investigation of Mediation, Moderation, and Conditional Effects in Mixture Models

    Open Access•Matthew J W McLarnon, Thomas A O’Neill•Organizational Research Methods•2018

  • Prediction from Latent Classes

    Karen Nylund‐gibson, Ryan P Grimm et al.•Structural Equation Modeling: A…•2019

  • Robustness of Stepwise Latent Class Modeling With Continuous Distal Outcomes

    Zsuzsa Bakk, Jeroen K Vermunt•Structural Equation Modeling: A…•2016

  • Finding latent groups in observed data

    Open Access•Sarah L Ferguson, E Whitney G Moore et al.•International Journal of…•2020

  • The GRoLTS-Checklist

    Open Access•Rens Van De Schoot, Marit Sijbrandij et al.•Structural Equation Modeling: A…•2017

  • Auxiliary Variables in Mixture Modeling

    Tihomir Asparouhov, Bengt Muthén•Structural Equation Modeling: A…•2014

  • Sozialkapital Intersektional

    Chantal Hinni•Sozialkapital Intersektional•2022

  • Profiles of parental response, intersectional microaggressions, and mental health problems among sexual and gender minority youth of color

    Open Access•Shixin Fang, Meg D Bishop et al.•Journal of Research on Adolescence•2026

  • Causal Beliefs and the Potential for Political Backlash Against AI

    Open Access•Sophie Borwein, Beatrice Magistro et al.•Public Opinion Quarterly•2026

  • Unpacking the heterogeneity of pre-service teachers’ ChatGPT acceptance

    Open Access•Pei‐Hua Chen, P S Chen et al.•International Journal of STEM…•2026

  • Exploring Latent Profiles of Metacognition and Their Impact on Computational Thinking and Mathematical Modeling Competency in High School Students

    Open Access•Yu Zhou, Bin Jing et al.•Journal of Intelligence•2026

  • Consequences of increased farm resilience on food security in Tajikistan

    Open Access•Bekhzod Egamberdiev, Ihtiyor Bobojonov et al.•Food Security•2026

  • From co-parenting patterns to identity development and malevolent creativity in Chinese late adolescents

    Open Access•Qing Fan, Qianqian Fan et al.•Thinking Skills and Creativity•2026

  • Working Students and Precarious Employment

    Open Access•Peter A Creed, Michelle Hood et al.•Journal of Career Assessment•2026

  • Individual differences in the executive functions of perfectionism profiles

    Open Access•Yan Zhou, Yu Yang et al.•Learning and Instruction•2026

  • Text comprehension across print and audio

    Open Access•Anisha Singh•Contemporary Educational Psychology•2026

  • Secondary school students’ social and emotional skills and academic literacy

    Open Access•Xuehan Lyu, Mengnan Zhang et al.•Educational Psychology•2026

  • Expectancy-value motivation profiles and their relation to specific maths tasks

    Open Access•Triinu Kilp-Kabel, Saku Määttä et al.•Educational Psychology•2026

  • Schools’ Agency Matters

    Open Access•Qingqing Li, 倩穎 趙•The Asia-Pacific Education…•2026

  • A latent profile approach for classifying internet gamers based on motives for online gaming

    Open Access•Bin‐Na Kim, Hyo Shin Kang et al.•Journal of Behavioral Addictions•2023

  • Adolescent students’ perceptions on parental supervision

    Open Access•Itahisa Mulero-Henríquez, José Alexis Alonso-Sánchez et al.•Educación XX1•2025

  • When is universal SEL effective under authentic conditions? Using LPA to examine program implementation in elementary classrooms

    Open Access•Hui Zhao, Pui-Wa Lei et al.•Frontiers in Education•2023

  • Visual distraction, inhibitory control, and children’s math performance

    Open Access•Kerry Lee, Patrick Lemaire et al.•Frontiers in Education•2026

  • The influence of professional identity on learning engagement among teacher education students

    Open Access•Yanlan Chen, Yuanrui Chen et al.•Frontiers in Education•2025

  • Heterogeneity in academic burnout and its association with professional identity among undergraduate nursing students

    Open Access•Mingfen Tao, Xinyue Chen et al.•Frontiers in Public Health•2026

  • Artificial intelligence readiness and its relationship with thriving at work among Chinese nurses

    Open Access•Xinyue Chen, Wanyu Ding et al.•Frontiers in Public Health•2026

  • A study on the impact and buffer path of the internet use gap on population health

    Open Access•Yuanyuan He, Lulin Zhou et al.•Frontiers in Public Health•2022

  • A Latent Class Analysis of University Lecturers’ Switch to Online Teaching during the First Covid-19 Lockdown

    Open Access•Tomas Kaqinari, Elena Makarova et al.•Education Sciences•2022

  • Tridimensional Acculturation and Academic Self-Concept of Minoritized Primary Students in Swiss Multicultural Classrooms

    Open Access•Simona Schmid, Andrea Haenni Hoti et al.•Education Sciences•2026

  • Scared, Bored or Happy? Latent Profile Analyses of Primary School Students’ Academic Emotions about Math

    Open Access•Jelena Radišić, Francisco Peixoto et al.•Education Sciences•2024

  • Examining the Relationships Between Students’ Achievement Goals and Their Academic Achievement in an OER-Based Course

    Open Access•Hengtao Tang, Yan Yang et al.•Education Sciences•2026

  • Retention and effectiveness of group interpersonal psychotherapy (IPT-G) to treat depression at scale in Uganda and Zambia

    Open Access•Frey B Assefa, Leah Tanner et al.•BMJ Global Health•2025

  • Are We Ready for AI? A Latent Profile Analysis Based on AI Readiness Among Singaporeans

    Open Access•Tingting Yang, Hyunjin Kang•Mass Communication & Society•2026

  • Resilience profiles predict polysubstance use in adolescents with a history of childhood maltreatment

    Giorgia Picci, Ashley N Linden-Carmichael et al.•Addiction Research & Theory•2023

  • Heterogeneity in Prosocial Motivations and Well-Being

    Open Access•Gen Li, Frank Fincham•Journal of Happiness Studies•2026

  • Variations in Adaptation Profiles Among Chinese Immigrant Mothers and Their Children

    Open Access•Diyang Qu, Bowen Chen et al.•Journal of Happiness Studies•2023

  • Temperament in Middle Childhood

    Open Access•Diana Wright Guerin, Kathleen S J Preston et al.•Journal of Happiness Studies•2025

  • Perceptions of Scientific Authorship Revisited

    Open Access•David Johann•Science and Engineering Ethics•2022

  • Pain Profiles among Young Adult Cannabis Users

    Janna Ataiants, Ekaterina V Fedorova et al.•Substance Use & Misuse•2021

  • Latent Class Analysis of Substance Use and Behavioral Addictions in Adolescents

    Gema Aonso‐diego, Ana Estévez•Substance Use & Misuse•2026

  • Stepwise Latent Class Analysis in the Presence of Missing Values on the Class Indicators

    Open Access•Ö Emre C Alagöz, Jeroen K Vermunt•Structural Equation Modeling: A…•2022

  • Bias-Adjusted Three-Step Multilevel Latent Class Modeling with Covariates

    Open Access•M Aldenderfer, Johan Lyrvall et al.•Structural Equation Modeling: A…•2024

  • Latent Class Model with Covariates

    Tseng Mingchi•Structural Equation Modeling: A…•2026

  • How to Perform Three-Step Latent Class Analysis in the Presence of Measurement Non-Invariance or Differential Item Functioning

    Open Access•Jeroen K Vermunt, Jay Magidson•Structural Equation Modeling: A…•2021

  • Three-Step Latent Class Analysis with Inverse Propensity Weighting in the Presence of Differential Item Functioning

    Open Access•Felix J Clouth, Steffen Pauw et al.•Structural Equation Modeling: A…•2023

  • Bayesian Computation via the Gibbs Sampler for Mixture Models with Gaussian Distal Outcomes

    Lilia Carolina Carneiro Costa, Leila Denise A F Amorim et al.•Structural Equation Modeling: A…•2021

  • Multilevel Mixture Modeling with Propensity Score Weights for Quasi-Experimental Evaluation of Virtual Learning Environments

    Walter L Leite, Zeyuan Jing et al.•Structural Equation Modeling: A…•2021

  • Teacher, Center, and Neighborhood Characteristics Associated with Variations in Preschool Quality in Childcare Centers

    Open Access•Benjamin L Bayly, Karen L Bierman et al.•Child & Youth Care Forum•2021

  • Head Start’s impact on long-term School Success

    Open Access•Benjamin L Bayly, Brittany Rhoades Cooper et al.•Child & Youth Care Forum•2023

  • The relationship between cognitive engagement and students’ performance in a simulation-based training environment

    Shan Li, Juan Zheng et al.•Interactive Learning Environments•2023

  • A profile analysis of computer-supported collaborative learning motivation in Chinese higher education

    Kai Wang, Boyuan Duan et al.•Interactive Learning Environments•2026

  • Parenting behaviors and child psychopathy

    Open Access•Jiaxin Deng, J S Deng et al.•Current Psychology•2022

  • Latent profiles of effort roles and their impact on task experience and behavior

    Open Access•Johanna Stähler, Wanja Wolff et al.•Current Psychology•2026

  • Uncovering the associations between different motivations and the heterogeneity of problematic smartphone use

    Open Access•Xi Shen, Xinqi Zhou et al.•Current Psychology•2024

  • Multidimensional Profiles of Addictive Smartphone Use

    Open Access•Hwajin Yang, Germaine Y Q Tng et al.•Current Psychology•2022

  • Mental health profiles in post Covid-19 Vietnam

    Open Access•Nguyen Tan Dat, Cao Tran Thanh Trung et al.•Current Psychology•2026

  • Typologies of helicopter parenting and parental affection

    Open Access•W Hwang, Eunjoo Jung et al.•Current Psychology•2024

  • Students’ profiles of social and learning behavior at school

    Open Access•Annette Lohbeck•Current Psychology•2026

  • Academic stress and depression among engineering undergraduates

    Open Access•Xiaochen Cao, Yan Zhang•Current Psychology•2026

  • Heterogeneity in the developmental trajectories of college adjustment among Chinese college freshmen

    Open Access•Youguo LIAO, Jianwen Chen et al.•Current Psychology•2026

  • Determining key predictors of students’ latent profiles in mathematical literacy

    Open Access•Ceylan Gundeger Kilci•Current Psychology•2026

  • Boredom coping profiles among international students in canada and canadian students

    Open Access•Chun Ho But, Johnson Ching-Hong Li et al.•Current Psychology•2023

  • Home literacy environment, literacy interest and emergent literacy in China

    Open Access•Zilin Bai, Ting Qi et al.•Current Psychology•2025

  • Mobile phone dependence associated with left-behind status and family cohesion

    Open Access•Lilan Chen, Wenyuan Jiang•Current Psychology•2025

  • The spillover effects of commuting role reattachment on thriving at work and family

    Open Access•Lele Wang, Lanxia Zhang et al.•Current Psychology•2026

  • An examination of the heterogenous nature of literacy development in Spanish-speaking preschool children

    Emily J Solari, Tricia A Zucker et al.•Early Education and Development•2023

  • Profiles and Predictors of Physical Abuse and Behavior Problems in Chinese Preschool-Aged Children

    Chen Chen, Nanxi Chen et al.•Early Education and Development•2024

  • Profiles of Dysregulation Moderate the Impact of PreschoolTeacher–Student Relationships on Elementary School Functioning

    Benjamin L Bayly, Karen L Bierman•Early Education and Development•2022

  • Latent Profile Analysis of Working Memory

    Open Access•Isabelle C De Vink, Lisette Hornstra et al.•Creativity Research Journal•2024

  • Creativity Under Stress at Work

    Shengjie Lin, Zorana Ivcevic et al.•Creativity Research Journal•2025

  • “I’m buying organic, but not like you….” Multiple ways of being an organic food consumer

    Leonardo Cei, Luca Rossetto•Journal of Environmental Planning…•2026

  • Covid ‐19 vaccine attitudes and facilitators among people in Australia who inject drugs

    Open Access•Olivia Price, Lisa Maher et al.•Drug and Alcohol Review•2023

  • An empirically based typology of temporary alcohol abstinence challenge participants using latent class analysis

    Open Access•Nathalie Kools, Andrea D Rozema et al.•Drug and Alcohol Review•2024

  • A Latent Profile Analysis of Protean Career Attitude and Vocational Identity Status

    Open Access•Eun Young Moon, Jungkyu Park et al.•Journal of Career Development•2024

  • Exploring the heterogeneity of home literacy practices

    Open Access•Jiali Wang, J Marc Goodrich et al.•Early Childhood Research Quarterly•2026

  • A latent profile analysis of adaptive teaching and its associations with self-efficacy in special education needs and professional collaboration

    Open Access•Bahaddin Demirdiş•International Journal of…•2026

  • How teacher collaboration profiles connect to literacy instructional practices

    Open Access•Jaehong Jang, Hawon Yoo et al.•International Journal of…•2022

  • A person‐centered perspective on employees' human resource management values and their implication for organizational commitment

    Open Access•Sophie Drouin‐Rousseau, Alexandre J S Morin et al.•Canadian Journal of Administrative…•2024

  • International students’ psychosocial well-being and social media use at the onset of the Covid-19 pandemic

    Open Access•Y Anthony Chen, Tingting Fan et al.•Computers in Human Behavior•2022

  • Adolescent social media use profiles

    Open Access•Federica Angelini, Ina M Koning et al.•Computers in Human Behavior•2026

  • Parent and Caregiver Relationships and Mental Health Symptom Profiles of Youth in Foster Care

    Open Access•Lenore M Mcwey, M Cui et al.•Child and Adolescent Social Work…•2022

  • The reading profiles of late elementary English learners with and without risk for dyslexia

    Open Access•Jeremy Miciak, Yusra Ahmed et al.•Annals of Dyslexia•2022

  • Adolescent students’ digital engagement and achievement goal orientation profiles

    Open Access•Kaja Mädamürk, Hanna Tuominen et al.•Computers & Education•2021

  • Growth, Fixed, and Mixed Mindsets

    Open Access•Nigel Mantou Lou, Kathryn Everhart Chaffee et al.•Studies in Second Language…•2022

  • Examination of gender‐based video game‐playing classes

    Open Access•Bülent BAŞARAN, Ömer ŞİMŞEK•Journal of Computer Assisted…•2024

  • A latent profile analysis of teachers’ causal attribution for academic success or failure

    Open Access•Lyder Brun, Laurent Brun et al.•European Journal of Psychology of…•2022

  • All better than being disengaged

    Open Access•Katharina Schnitzler, Doris Holzberger et al.•European Journal of Psychology of…•2021

  • Identifying higher education students’ profiles of academic engagement and burnout and analysing their predictors and outcomes

    Open Access•Francisco Cano, Francisco Cano-García et al.•European Journal of Psychology of…•2024

  • Profiles of White parents' racial attitudes

    Open Access•Angus M Fraser, Wen Wang et al.•Family Relations•2026

  • Young adult grandchildren's intergenerational and digital solidarity with grandparents and depressive symptoms during the pandemic

    Open Access•Xiaoyu Fu, W Hwang et al.•Family Relations•2026

  • Latent structure analysis

    Paul Felix Lazarsfeld•Latent structure analysis•1968

  • Applied Latent Class Analysis

    Open Access•Jacques A Hagenaars, Allan L Mccutcheon•Applied Latent Class Analysis•2002

  • Loglinear models with Latent Variables

    Jacques A Hagenaars, Jacques Hagenaars•Loglinear models with Latent…•1993

  • Exploratory latent structure analysis using both identifiable and unidentifiable models

    Leo A Goodman•Biometrika•1974

  • Regression Among Factor Scores

    Open Access•Anders Skrondal, Petter Laake•Psychometrika•2001

  • Structural Equations with Latent Variables

    Open Access•K A Bollen•Structural Equations with Latent…•1989

  • Multiple Imputation for Nonresponse in Surveys

    Open Access•Donald B Rubin•Multiple Imputation for…•1987

  • The Analysis of Systems of Qualitative Variables When Some of the Variables Are Unobservable. Part I-A Modified Latent Structure Approach

    Leo A Goodman•American Journal of Sociology•1974

  • Categorical Causal Modeling

    Open Access•Jacques A Hagenaars•Sociological Methods & Research•1998

  • Assumptions and Comparative Strengths of the Two-Step Approach

    Open Access•James C Anderson, David W Gerbing•Sociological Methods & Research•1992

  • Optimal Procedures for Estimation of Factor Scores

    Open Access•Willem E Saris, Marius De Pijper et al.•Sociological Methods & Research•1978

  • Estimating True Changes when Categorical Panel Data are Affected by Uncorrelated and Correlated Classification Errors

    Open Access•Francesca Bassi, Jacques A Hagenaars et al.•Sociological Methods & Research•2000

Unique citing works445
Citations per year20,23
Citation span2004 - 2026 (23)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedYes
Citation typesNeutral: 441

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae