Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

The Great Recession and Fertility in Europe

A Sub-national Analysis

Bibliographic Data

ID11294652
AuthorsAnna Matysiak (0000-0002-8883-3925, University of Warsaw, corresponding author), Tomáš Sobotka (0000-0002-6418-7105, International Institute for Applied Systems Analysis), D Vignoli (0000-0003-1227-5880, University of Florence)
Year2021
Volume37
Issue1
Pages29-64
Publication date2021-03-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueEuropean Journal of Population / Revue européenne de Démographie (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0168-6577 • E-ISSN: 1572-9885
PublisherSpringer Science and Business Media LLC (PUBLISHER)
DOI10.1007/s10680-020-09556-y
PMID33597835
OpenAlexW2794717344
LanguageEN
Citations received108
References cited53

This study investigates how the changes in labour market conditions and economic growth were associated with fertility before and during the Great Recession in Europe in 2002–2014. In contrast to previous studies, which largely concentrated at the country level, we use data for 251 European regions in 28 European Union (EU) member states prior to the withdrawal of the United Kingdom in January 2020. We apply three-level growth-curve model which allows for a great deal of flexibility in modelling temporal change while controlling for variation in economic conditions across regions and countries. Our findings show that fertility decline was strongly related to unemployment increase; this relationship was significant at different reproductive ages. Deteriorating economic conditions were associated with a stronger decline in fertility during the economic recession as compared with the pre-recession period. This evidence suggests the salience of factors such as broader perception of uncertainty that we could not capture in our models and which rose to prominence during the Great Recession. Furthermore, strongest fertility declines were observed in Southern Europe, Ireland and parts of Central and Eastern Europe, i.e. countries and regions where labour market conditions deteriorated most during the recession period. In Western Europe, and especially in the Nordic countries, fertility rates were not closely associated with the recession indicators

Demographic economics · Economic growth · Economics · European union · Fertility · Geography · Great recession · International economics · Labour economics · Macroeconomics · Population · Recession · Total fertility rate · Unemployment · Demography · Global Health Care Issues · Health disparities and outcomes · Insurance, Mortality, Demography, Risk Management

  • Recent changes in the spatial organisation of European fertility

    Open Access•Mathieu Buelens•Espace populations sociétés•2022

  • Regional social capital and fertility rate

    Open Access•Eetu Soini, Kateryna Golovina et al.•Biodemography and Social Biology•2026

  • Socioeconomic inequality in fertility responses to universal preschool reform

    Open Access•Dana Shay, Y Shavit et al.•Research in Social Stratification…•2026

  • Uncertainty and Narratives of the Future

    Open Access•D Vignoli, Giacomo Bazzani et al.•Analyzing Contemporary Fertility•2020

  • Austerity as reproductive injustice

    Open Access•Laura Sochas, Jenny Chanfreau•Social Forces•2025

  • If Not Now, When? Thinking about Childbearing in Ukrainian Cities during Russia's Full‐Scale Invasion

    Open Access•Anna Popovych, B Perelli-Harris et al.•Population and Development Review•2026

  • Google Trends as a Method to Predict New Covid-19 Cases and Socio-Psychological Consequences of the Pandemic

    Open Access•Tado Jurić•Athens Journal of Mediterranean…•2021

  • Spillovers from gender equality onto economic equality

    Open Access•Michael A Nelson, Rajeev K Goel•Journal of International…•2023

  • How will Covid-19 impact Australia's future population? A scenario approach

    Open Access•Elin Charles-Edwards, Tom Wilson et al.•Applied Geography•2021

  • Female, male, two-sex fertility rates and their population projections

    Open Access•Nan Li, Hong Mi et al.•Humanities and Social Sciences…•2025

  • The impact of changing economic conditions in the context of postponement of parenthood in three countries of former Yugoslavia

    Open Access•Goran Miladinov•SN Social Sciences•2021

  • Fertility decisions in the wake of Covid-19

    Open Access•Nishat Tasneem, Shah Md Atiqul Haq et al.•SN Social Sciences•2023

  • The impact of public health shocks on fertility intentions

    Open Access•Yiting Guo, Yuqi Mou et al.•Frontiers in Public Health•2025

  • Determinants of fertility intentions in a low-fertility region of Central Europe

    Open Access•Andrzej Ciborek, Zuzanna Chęcińska-Maciejewska et al.•Frontiers in Public Health•2026

  • Decrease in reproductive desires among non-parent heterosexual women during the Covid-19 pandemic in Poland

    Open Access•Urszula M Marcinkowska, Krzysztof Kasparek et al.•Frontiers in Public Health•2025

  • Effects of pandemics uncertainty on fertility

    Open Access•Yonglong Wang, Giray Gozgor et al.•Frontiers in Public Health•2022

  • Household structure decisions and positive wealth shocks

    Open Access•Leví Pérez, Álvaro Muñiz•Journal of Demographic Economics•2025

  • Fertility in the time of depression

    Open Access•Andrew Chase Holt, Arjina Akter et al.•Journal of Demographic Economics•2026

  • Motherhood employment penalty in Europe

    Open Access•Chiara Mussida, Dario Sciulli•Journal of Demographic Economics•2026

  • Labor Market Policy and Subjective Well-Being During the Great Recession

    Open Access•Robson Morgan, Kelsey J O’connor•Journal of Happiness Studies•2022

  • Taming the declining birth trend in OECD countries

    Open Access•Sakiru Adebola Solarin, Luis Alberiko Gil-Alana et al.•Mathematical Population Studies•2026

  • Stepping Down from Lifelong Posts

    Jian Xie, Junsen Zhang et al.•Journal of Labor Economics•2025

  • Economic Uncertainty and Postponed Parenthood

    Open Access•Mogens Christoffersen•Journal of Family Issues•2026

  • Do Media Narratives of the Economy Affect Childbearing? Findings From Multi-media News Coverage in Germany

    Open Access•Maria Francesca Morabito, Raffaele Guetto et al.•Population Research and Policy…•2026

  • Impact of the Covid-19 pandemic on pregnancy postponement – evidence from Japan

    Open Access•Midori Matsushima, Hiroyuki Yamada et al.•Journal of Biosocial Science•2023

  • Frontiers of self-realisation. How (un)certainty and imaginaries shape fertility intentions in Italy and Norway

    Open Access•Giacomo Bazzani, Lars Dommermuth et al.•Acta Sociologica•2025

  • Gender egalitarianism, perceived economic insecurity, and fertility intentions in Spain

    Xiana Bueno, M C Brinton•Population Studies•2019

  • Covid-19 Pandemic and Fertility

    Open Access•Ausra Maslauskaite•Filosofija. Sociologija•2021

  • Economic insecurity and material deprivation

    Open Access•Raffaele Grotti, Davide Gritti et al.•Demographic Research•2026

  • How much his or her job loss influences fertility

    Open Access•Alessandro Di Nallo, Oliver Lipps•Journal of Marriage and the Family•2023

  • Persistent joblessness and fertility intentions

    Open Access•A Busetta, Daria Mendola et al.•Demographic Research•2019

  • The impact of Covid-19 on fertility plans in Italy, Germany, France, Spain, and the United Kingdom

    Open Access•Francesca Luppi, Bruno Arpino et al.•Demographic Research•2020

  • Sex, digital media, and fertility intentions in China

    Open Access•Yan Fu, Fuqiang Guo et al.•Chinese Journal of Sociology•2026

  • Fertility intentions and perceived health status

    Open Access•Nasim Ahamed Mondal•Journal of Migration and Health•2024

  • Hard Hit

    Open Access•Reanne Frank, Elizabeth Wildsmith et al.•SSM - Population Health•2025

  • Korea on the edge

    Open Access•David Coleman, D Jackson Coleman•The Japanese Political Economy•2026

  • Growing Pains

    Open Access•Begoña Elizalde, Vicente Díaz Gandasegui et al.•Social Inclusion•2023

  • Disentangling the Role of Composition Factors in Fertility Responses to Unemployment

    Open Access•Thaís García-Pereiro, Roberta Misuraca et al.•Social Sciences•2024

  • Fertility Response to the Covid-19 Pandemic in Developed Countries – On Pre-pandemic Fertility Forecasts

    Open Access•Patrizio Vanella, Arthur L Greil et al.•Comparative Population Studies•2023

  • Fertility Decline in Iceland, 2013-2022

    Open Access•Ari Klængur Jónsson•Comparative Population Studies•2024

  • Subtle fertility recovery in cohorts who entered the labour market during the deep recession in Japan

    Open Access•Ayako Kondo•Asian Population Studies•2026

  • Factor Structure and Psychometric Properties of the Italian Version of the Childbearing Motivations Scale

    Open Access•Angelica Gattamelata, Antonio Gattamelata et al.•International Journal of…•2025

  • Household Earnings and Income Volatility in the UK, 2009–2017

    Open Access•Avram, Mike Brewer et al.•The Journal of Economic Inequality•2021

  • The Diffusion of Late Fertility Across European Regions (2006–2018)

    Open Access•Ingrid Setz, Marie‐caroline Compans et al.•Population Space and Place•2025

  • Scenario‐based fertility projections incorporating impacts of Covid‐19

    Open Access•Ann Berrington, Joanne Ellison et al.•Population Space and Place•2021

  • Gender Differences in the Timing and Chances of Parenthood Across Regions

    Open Access•Jessica Nisén, Johan Dahlberg et al.•Population Space and Place•2026

  • Delayed Retirement, Grandparental Support, and Adult Children’s Fertility Intentions

    Open Access•Jiayi Ma, Yazhen Yang et al.•Social Policy and Society•2026

  • Converging fertility trajectories across developed countries, 2010–2020

    Open Access•Chaoliang Zhang, F He et al.•BMC Public Health•2026

  • Universal Transfers, Tax Breaks and Fertility

    Open Access•Rannveig Kaldager Hart, Taryn Ann Galloway•Population Research and Policy…•2023

  • Not Even a Pandemic Makes Them Change Their Family Plans

    Open Access•Isabella Buber-Ennser, Ingrid Setz et al.•Population and Development Review•2024

  • Societal Pessimism and the Transition to Parenthood

    Open Access•Katya Ivanova, Nicoletta Balbo•Population and Development Review•2024

  • An Alternative Perspective on the Changing Relationships between Fertility and Replacement Level in European Countries

    Open Access•Nick Parr•Population and Development Review•2023

  • Pandemic Roller-Coaster? Birth Trends in Higher-Income Countries During the Covid-19 Pandemic

    Open Access•Tomáš Sobotka, Kryštof Zeman et al.•Population and Development Review•2024

  • Beyond the Great Recession

    Open Access•Nathan Seltzer•Demography•2019

  • Fertility Drain or Fertility Gain? Emigration and Fertility During the Great Recession in Italy

    Open Access•Massimo Anelli, Nicoletta Balbo•Demography•2021

  • Cross-Sectional Average Length of Life Childless

    Open Access•Ryohei Mogi, Jessica Nisén et al.•Demography•2021

  • Economic complexity and fertility

    Open Access•Niccolà Innocenti, Niccolò Innocenti et al.•Regional Studies•2021

  • Generalised morality and contemporary fertility dynamics across European regions

    A Aassve, Pierluigi Conzo et al.•Regional Studies•2024

  • Health status and fertility intentions among migrants

    Open Access•Giammarco Alderotti, Eleonora Trappolini•International Migration•2021

  • A reflection on economic uncertainty and fertility in Europe

    Open Access•D Vignoli, Raffaele Guetto et al.•Genus•2020

  • Varying responses to the introduction of earnings-related benefits

    Open Access•Sanan Abdullayev, A Puur•Journal of Population Research•2024

  • Will the Covid-19 pandemic affect population ageing in Australia

    Open Access•Tom Wilson, J Temple et al.•Journal of Population Research•2021

  • Empirical analysis of the differences in the drivers of fertility between CEE countries and the rest of the EU

    Open Access•András Olivér Németh, Petra Németh et al.•Journal of Population Research•2025

  • What drives period fertility rates during post-recession spells

    Open Access•Georgios Mavropoulos•Journal of Population Research•2024

  • The political economy of post-reproduction society

    Open Access•Paul Cammack•New Political Economy•2025

  • Understanding Dynamic Drivers of Fertility

    S Z Kalantari-Banadaki, Adel Azar et al.•Forum for Social Economics•2025

  • Age-Specific Income Trends in Europe

    Open Access•Bernhard Hammer, Sonja Spitzer et al.•Social Indicators Research•2021

  • Sprawl or Segregation? Local Fertility as a Proxy of Socio-spatial Disparities Under Sequential Economic Downturns

    Open Access•Giuseppe Ricciardo Lamonica, Gloria Polinesi et al.•Social Indicators Research•2022

  • Partners’ Educational Characteristics and Fertility

    Open Access•Alessandra Trimarchi, Jan Van Bavel•European Journal of Population /…•2020

  • The Great Recession and Fertility in Europe

    Open Access•Anna Matysiak, Tomáš Sobotka et al.•European Journal of Population /…•2021

  • Beyond the crisis

    Open Access•Dulce Pimentel, María Cristina Sousa Gomes et al.•Espace populations sociétés•2022

  • Natives’ and immigrants’ fertility intentions in Europe

    Open Access•Giammarco Alderotti, Thaís García-Pereiro et al.•Espace populations sociétés•2022

  • A tale of a shrinking City? Exploring the complex interplay of socio-demographic dynamics in the recent development of Attica, Greece

    Open Access•Sabato Vinci, Ioannis Vardopoulos et al.•Cities•2023

  • Family Life Courses, Uncertain Futures, and the Changing World of Work

    Open Access•Anna Matysiak, D Vignoli•European Journal of Population /…•2024

  • Industrial Robots and Regional Fertility in European Countries

    Open Access•Anna Matysiak, D Bellani et al.•European Journal of Population /…•2023

  • The Demographic Causes of European Sub-National Population Declines

    Open Access•Niall Newsham, Francisco Rowe•European Journal of Population /…•2025

  • Beyond the Economic Gaze

    Open Access•Chiara Ludovica Comolli, Gerda Neyer et al.•European Journal of Population /…•2021

  • Fertility Declines Near the End of the Covid-19 Pandemic

    Open Access•Martin Bujard, Gunnar Andersson•European Journal of Population /…•2024

  • Uncertainty and Fertility in Ukraine on the Eve of Russia’s Full-Scale Invasion

    Open Access•B Perelli-Harris, T P Gerber et al.•European Journal of Population /…•2024

  • Narratives of the Future Affect Fertility

    Open Access•D Vignoli, Alessandra Minello et al.•European Journal of Population /…•2022

  • Economic Cycles and Entry into Parenthood

    Open Access•Karel Neels, Leen Marynissen et al.•European Journal of Population /…•2024

  • Employment Protection Legislation, Labour Market Dualism, and Fertility in Europe

    Open Access•Elena Bastianelli, Raffaele Guetto et al.•European Journal of Population /…•2023

  • Second Birth Fertility in Germany

    Open Access•Michaela Kreyenfeld, Dirk Konietzka et al.•European Journal of Population /…•2023

  • Urban–Rural Disparities in the Transition to Parenthood During Times of Uncertainty

    Open Access•Nicholas Campisi, Hill Kulu et al.•European Journal of Population /…•2024

  • The Fracking Boom, Labor Structure, and Adolescent Fertility

    Open Access•Andrew Owens•Population Research and Policy…•2022

  • Brexit and Fertility Implications in the UK and Europe

    Open Access•Georgios Mavropoulos•Population Research and Policy…•2024

  • Population Dynamics and Policies in Europe

    Open Access•Vytenis Juozas Deimantas, Ebru Sanliturk et al.•Population Research and Policy…•2024

  • Self-assessed Physical and Mental Health and Fertility Expectations of Men and Women Across the Life Course

    Open Access•Ester Lazzari, Éva Beaujouan•Demography•2025

  • Microsimulation of Household and Marital Transitions Leading to Childlessness Among Dutch Women Born Between 1971 and 2000

    Open Access•Michaël Boissonneault, Joop De Beer•Demography•2022

  • Fertility and Media Narratives of the Economy

    Open Access•Raffaele Guetto, Maria Francesca Morabito et al.•Demography•2023

  • Why has South Korea’s fertility rate dropped below Japan’s? An exploratory study of youth labor market challenges and family formation

    Sinn Won Han, Fumiya Uchikoshi•Chinese Sociological Review•2026

  • Theory and explanation in demography

    Open Access•Elspeth Graham•Population Studies•2021

  • Attitudinal and behavioural indices of the second demographic transition

    Open Access•Zuzanna Brzozowska•Demographic Research•2021

  • A rope always snaps at its thinnest point

    Open Access•Wenqian Xu, Chunyan Kong et al.•Ageing and Society•2026

  • Fine for Adam & Eve but not Adam & Steve? Homonegativity bias, parasocial contact, and public support for surrogacy

    Open Access•Stuart J Turnbull-Dugarte•Journal of European Public Policy•2024

  • Introduction to the Special Collection on The new roles of women and men and implications for families and societies

    Open Access•L S Olah, Rudolf Richter et al.•Demographic Research•2023

  • Disentangling the Swedish fertility decline of the 2010s

    Open Access•Ohlsson-Wijk, Sofi Ohlsson-Wijk et al.•Demographic Research•2022

  • Special times? How Covid-specific concerns disrupted fertility desires in the United States during the Covid-19 pandemic

    Open Access•Yining Yang, Grace Kao•Demographic Research•2025

  • Cash transfers and fertility

    Open Access•Anna Bokun•Demographic Research•2024

  • Aplazando la llegada del primer hijo? Un estudio cualitativo sobre las percepciones en torno al retraso de la fecundidad

    Open Access•Viviana González Hincapié, María Teresa López López•Papers Revista de Sociologia•2021

  • Uncertainty and Narratives of the Future

    Open Access•D Vignoli, Giacomo Bazzani et al.•Analyzing Contemporary Fertility•2020

  • Multilevel Models for Longitudinal Data

    Open Access•Fiona Steele•Journal of the Royal Statistical…•2008

  • Short- and long-term effects of unemployment on fertility

    Open Access•Janet Currie, Janet M Currie et al.•Proceedings of the National…•2014

  • Vanishing Children

    Alicia Adserà, Alı́cia Adserà•American Economic Review•2005

  • Birth and Fortune

    Richard A Easterlin•Birth and Fortune:The Impact of…•1980

  • Society at a Glance 2016

    OECD OECD•Society at a Glance 2016•2016

  • Globalization, Uncertainty and Youth in Society

    H P Blossfeld, Hans‐peter Blossfeld et al.•Glazunov•2006

  • Children of the Great Recession

    Open Access•Libbie Sonnier‐Netto, Anisa Zvonkovic•Journal of Family Theory & Review•2017

  • The geography of the economic crisis in Europe

    Riccardo Crescenzi, Davide Luca et al.•Cambridge Journal of Regions…•2016

  • The effects of information and communication technologies on residential mobility and migration

    Open Access•Thomas J Cooke, Ian Shuttleworth•Population Space and Place•2017

  • Why are marriage and family formation increasingly disconnected across Europe? A multilevel perspective on existing theories

    Open Access•Trude Lappegård, Sebastian Klüsener et al.•Population Space and Place•2017

  • The precariat

    Martin Allen, Martin G Allen et al.•International Studies in…•2011

  • Changing fertility rates in developed countries. The impact of labor market institutions

    Open Access•Al cia Adser, Al�cia Adser�•Journal of Population Economics•2004

  • Fertility Behaviour under Income Uncertainty

    Open Access•Priya Ranjan•European Journal of Population /…•1999

  • A Cross-National Perspective on Unemployment and First Births

    Open Access•Christian Schmitt•European Journal of Population /…•2012

  • Where Are the Babies? Labor Market Conditions and Fertility in Europe

    Open Access•Alicia Adserà, Alı́cia Adserà•European Journal of Population /…•2011

  • The Great Recession and Fertility in Europe

    Open Access•Anna Matysiak, Tomáš Sobotka et al.•European Journal of Population /…•2021

  • Does Leaving Home Make You Poor? Evidence from 13 European Countries

    Open Access•A Aassve, María A Davia et al.•European Journal of Population /…•2007

  • Spatial Aspects of the Rise of Nonmarital Fertility Across Europe Since 1960

    Open Access•Sebastian Klüsener, B Perelli-Harris et al.•European Journal of Population /…•2013

  • Is a Positive Relationship Between Fertility and Economic Development Emerging at the Sub-National Regional Level? Theoretical Considerations and Evidence from Europe

    Open Access•Jonathan Fox, Jonathan F Fox et al.•European Journal of Population /…•2019

  • Socioeconomic Variation in the Effect of Economic Conditions on Marriage and Nonmarital Fertility in the United States

    Open Access•Daniel Schneider, O P Hastings•Demography•2015

  • Unemployment, Nonstandard Employment, and Fertility

    Open Access•James M Raymo, Akihisa Shibata•Demography•2017

  • A Theory of the Value of Children

    Open Access•Debra Friedman, Michael Hechter et al.•Demography•1994

  • Job Displacement and First Birth Over the Business Cycle

    Open Access•Barbara Hofmann, Michaela Kreyenfeld et al.•Demography•2017

  • Beyond the Great Recession

    Open Access•Nathan Seltzer•Demography•2019

  • Economic Uncertainty and Fertility

    Open Access•Michaela Kreyenfeld•KZfSS Kölner Zeitschrift für…•2015

  • The Emergence of Lowest‐Low Fertility in Europe During the 1990s

    Open Access•Hans‐peter Kohler, Francesco C Billari et al.•Population and Development Review•2002

  • Resume of the Indianapolis Study of Social and Psychological Factors Affecting Fertility

    Clyde V Kiser, P K Whelpton•Population Studies•1953

  • Economic Uncertainty and Family Dynamics in Europe

    Open Access•Michaela Kreyenfeld, Gunnar Andersson et al.•Demographic Research•2012

  • Certainty of meeting fertility intentions declines in Europe during the 'Great Recession

    Open Access•Maria Rita Testa, Maria Testa et al.•Demographic Research•2014

  • Fertility Reactions to the "Great Recession" in Europe

    Open Access•J R Goldstein, Michaela Kreyenfeld et al.•Demographic Research•2013

  • The fertility response to the Great Recession in Europe and the United States

    Open Access•Chiara Ludovica Comolli•Demographic Research•2017

  • The Effects of the Great Recession on Family Structure and Fertility

    Open Access•Andrew J Cherlin, Andrew Cherlin et al.•The Annals of the American…•2013

  • Will US Fertility Remain Low? A New Economic Interpretation

    William Butz, William P Butz et al.•Population and Development Review•1979

  • Economic Recession and Fertility in the Developed World

    Open Access•Tomáš Sobotka, Vegard Skirbekk et al.•Population and Development Review•2011

  • Persistent joblessness and fertility intentions

    Open Access•A Busetta, Daria Mendola et al.•Demographic Research•2019

  • Uncertain lives

    Open Access•D Vignoli, Valentina Tocchioni et al.•Demographic Research•2016

  • The relationship between unemployment and fertility in Italy

    Open Access•Alberto Cazzola, Lucia Pasquini et al.•Demographic Research•2016

  • Unstable work histories and fertility in France

    Open Access•Daniel Ciganda•Demographic Research•2015

  • Whose job instability affects the likelihood of becoming a parent in Italy? A tale of two partners

    Open Access•D Vignoli, Sven Drefahl et al.•Demographic Research•2012

  • Not a very Neet solution

    Open Access•Andy Furlong•Work Employment and Society•2006

  • The Great Recession, Fertility, and Uncertainty

    Open Access•Daniel Schneider•Journal of Marriage and the Family•2015

  • Uncertainties in Female Employment Careers and the Postponement of Parenthood in Germany

    Michaela Kreyenfeld•European Sociological Review•2010

Unique citing works108
Citations per year15,43
Citation span2019 - 2026 (8)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedYes
Citation typesNeutral: 105

Tools

Open DOIOpen Access
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae