Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Time for action

Science education for an alternative future

Bibliographic Data

ID23330744
AuthorsDerek Hodson (University of Toronto, corresponding author)
Year2003
Volume25
Issue6
Pages645-670
Publication date2003-06-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessNo
TypeARTICLE
VenueInternational Journal of Science Education, Part B (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 2154-8455 • E-ISSN: 2154-8463
PublisherInforma UK Limited (PUBLISHER • GB)
DOI10.1080/09500690305021
OpenAlexW2132751821
LanguageEN
Citations received119
References cited47

Following a brief historical survey of the popular 'slogans' that have influenced science education during the past quarter century and a review of current international debate on scientific literacy and science pedagogy, the author takes the view that while much of value has been achieved, there is still considerable cause for concern and that it is time for action in two senses. First, it is time to take action on the school science curriculum because it no longer meets the needs, interests and aspirations of young citizens. Second, it is time for a science curriculum oriented toward sociopolitical action. The author argues that if current social and environmental problems are to be solved, we need a generation of scientifically and politically literate citizens who are not content with the role of 'armchair critic'. A particular concern in North America is the link between science education, economic globalization, increasing production and unlimited expansion - a link that threatens the freedom of individuals, the spiritual well-being of particular societies and the very future of the planet. The author's response is to advocate a politicized, issues-based curriculum focused on seven areas of concern (human health; food and agriculture; land, water and mineral resources; energy resources and consumption; industry; information transfer and transportation; ethics and social responsibility) and addressed at four levels of sophistication, culminating in preparation for sociopolitical action. The curriculum proposal outlined in the article is intended to produce activists: people who will fight for what is right, good and just; people who will work to re-fashion society along more socially-just lines; people who will work vigorously in the best interests of the biosphere. At the heart of this curriculum is a commitment to pursue a fundamental realignment of the values underpinning Western industrialized society. Achieving that goal is a formidable task - one that will not be achieved by conventional approaches to curriculum development and teacher education. The author's solution is action research linked to community involvement.

Action (physics) · Curriculum · Engineering ethics · Environmental ethics · Pedagogy · Political science · Public relations · Science education · Scientific Literacy · Social science · Social science education · Sociology · Sophistication · Diverse Educational Innovations Studies · Education and Critical Thinking Development · Engineering · Science Education and Pedagogy

  • Competencia científica en Educación Primaria

    Open Access•Mónica Santamaría-Domínguez, Amparo Jiménez Vivas et al.•Education in the Knowledge…•2023

  • Back to the Future? Aims and Ends for Future-Oriented Science Education Policy – The New Zealand Context

    Open Access•J Gilbert•Knowledge Cultures•2017

  • Cacoepy (bad pronunciation or mispronunciation) of scientific terms and their effect on learning of secondary level science students

    Open Access•Syed Shujaat Ali, Tayyab Kamal et al.•Journal of South Asian Studies•2022

  • Problemas socio-científicos

    Open Access•Kathryn Paige, Graham Hardy•Revista Internacional de…•2015

  • Contributos educativos de exposições interativas on-line sobre imunidade como prática de ativismo coletivo em contexto de pandemia

    Open Access•Adriana Agostinho, P Reis•UNIPLURIVERSIDAD•2021

  • A formação docente para educação profissional por meio de um curso de extensão com tecnologias emergentes e escolarização aberta

    Open Access•Alexandra Okada, Cláudia Eliane Da Matta•Revista Diálogo Educacional•2021

  • Teacher training for professional education through a course of extension on emerging Technologies with open schooling

    Open Access•Alexandra Okada, Cláudia Eliane Da Matta•Revista Diálogo Educacional•2021

  • Being your own role model for improving self‐efficacy

    Larry Bencze, Lisa Upton•Canadian Journal of Science…•2006

  • Why we should prioritize learning about science

    Derek Hodson•Canadian Journal of Science…•2006

  • Débat sur une question sociocientifique

    Open Access•Catherine Barrué•Swiss Journal of Educational…•2017

  • Aprender a comunicar ciencia aumenta la motivación del alumnado. "La Jornada Científica", una propuesta didáctica en ESO

    Open Access•Adrián Gollerizo-Fernández, María Clemente-Gallardo•Revista Electrónica Educare•2019

  • Becoming a sustainability chef

    Kate Moss Gamblin•Environmental Education Research•2013

  • Vierte „Tagung der Fachdidaktik“ 2019 Interdisziplinäre fachdidaktische Diskurse zur Bildung für nachhaltige Entwicklung

    Suzanne Kapelari•Vierte „Tagung der Fachdidaktik“…•2020

  • Climate Education

    Camilla Schreiner, Ellen Karoline Henriksen et al.•Studies in Science Education•2005

  • Reconsidering Different Visions of Scientific Literacy and Science Education Based on the Concept of Bildung

    Open Access•Jesper Sjöström, Ingo Eilks•Cognition, Metacognition, and…•2018

  • Energy literacy of secondary students in New York State (USA)

    Open Access•Jan E DeWaters, Susan E Powers•Energy Policy•2011

  • Situated learning in science education

    Troy D Sadler•Studies in Science Education•2009

  • What Do Students Gain by Engaging in Socioscientific Inquiry?

    Open Access•Troy D Sadler, Sasha A Barab et al.•Research in Science Education•2007

  • Méthodologies scientifiques et techniques pour approcher le vivant

    Open Access•Marie-Claude Bernard, Michèle Dell’Angelo et al.•SHS Web of Conferences•2015

  • L'enseignement de controverses socioscientifiques

    Open Access•Virginie Albe•Éducation & didactique•2009

  • Exploring the scientific technological citizenship of high school students participating in a board game-based climate change education program

    Open Access•Wooyong Park, Chan-Jong Kim•Discover Education•2026

  • The Waldorf observation-based approach can expand pedagogical toolkit for science teachers

    Open Access•Nir Eliav, Gilad Goldschmidt•Discover Education•2026

  • Local radio and SMS campaigns for environmental awareness, forest fire crisis management, and educational intervention in Kabylie, Algeria

    Open Access•Redouane Touati•Frontiers in Education•2026

  • The philanthropic model of scientific knowledge dissemination

    Open Access•Guillermo Alexander Quezada Castro, María Del Pilar Quezada Castro et al.•The Education and science journal•2026

  • Future-Oriented Science Education

    Open Access•Sibel Erduran, Jessica Chan et al.•International Journal of Science…•2026

  • Merging Science Education and Public Health Perspectives in Curriculum Development and Implementation to Support Relevant Science Instruction

    Open Access•Idit Adler, Consuelo Juliette Morales et al.•International Journal of Science…•2026

  • Integrating socioscientific argumentation into action-oriented instruction for the development of action competence

    Open Access•Shih-Yeh Chen•Environmental Education Research•2026

  • Globalization and Science Education

    Open Access•Larry Bencze, J LAWRENCE BENCZE et al.•COSMOS•2013

  • Science and representation

    Open Access•Rita Barakat•SN Social Sciences•2022

  • Environmental socio-scientific issues as contexts in developing scientific literacy in science education

    Open Access•Vishal Kumar, Sanjiv Kumar Choudhary et al.•Social Sciences & Humanities Open•2024

  • A stratospheric mission – design of a conceptual framework to bring weather balloons and STEM into the classroom

    Open Access•Cornelia Connolly, Patrick Johnson et al.•Frontiers in Education•2023

  • Rethinking Quality Science Education for Climate Action

    Open Access•Susanne Kubisch, Hanna Krimm et al.•Frontiers in Education•2022

  • Eco-Solutioning

    Open Access•Nancy Butler Songer, Guillermo D Ibarrola Recalde•Frontiers in Education•2021

  • ChemoKnowings as Part of 21st Century Bildung and Subject Didaktik

    Open Access•Merve Yavuzkaya, Paul Clucas et al.•Frontiers in Education•2022

  • Scientific Literacies for Change Making

    Open Access•Giulia Tasquier, Erik Knain et al.•Frontiers in Education•2022

  • Promoting Students’ Scientific Habits of Mind and Chemical Literacy Using the Context of Socio-Scientific Issues on the Inquiry Learning

    Open Access•Antuni Wiyarsi, Anti Kolonial Prodjosantoso et al.•Frontiers in Education•2021

  • Exploring Primary Preservice Teachers’ Agency and Systems Thinking in the Context of the Covid-19 Pandemic

    Open Access•Araitz Uskola, Blanca Puig•Frontiers in Education•2022

  • Exploring Chemistry Professors’ Methods of Highlighting the Relevancy of Chemistry

    Open Access•Anna George, Christian Zowada et al.•Education Sciences•2021

  • Boosting adults scientific literacy with experiential learning practices

    Open Access•Eduardo Dopico, Alba Ardura et al.•European Journal for Research on…•2021

  • Powerful Re-/Connections

    Open Access•Lindsay E Cunningham, Yuen Sze Michelle Tan•Canadian Journal of Science…•2026

  • Introducing preservice primary teachers to socioscientific activism through the analysis and discussion of videos

    Daniel Cebrián Robles, Enrique España-Ramos et al.•International Journal of Science…•2021

  • Experimental evidence of disparities in biology teachers’ responses to student writing

    Quentin C Sedlacek•International Journal of Science…•2021

  • ‘Integration of scientific practices into daily living contexts

    Verónica Muñoz-Campos, Antonio-Joaquín Franco-Mariscal et al.•International Journal of Science…•2020

  • A model conceptualising trans-disciplinarity within school science education based on a systematic literature review

    Open Access•TBM Chowdhury, Jack Holbrook et al.•International Journal of Science…•2024

  • Evaluation of interdisciplinary science teaching practices in the context of socioscientific issues

    Serpil Kara•International Journal of Science…•2025

  • Promoting preservice teachers’ global citizenship and contextualised NOS views through role-play activities integrated into place-based SSI instruction on climate issues

    Banu Avsar Erumit, Bahadir Namdar et al.•International Journal of Science…•2024

  • Pre-service science teachers’ visions on education for sustainable development – tensions, underlying beliefs, and experiences

    Open Access•Peter Duifhuis, Gerald van Dijk et al.•International Journal of Science…•2025

  • Worldwide predictors of science literacy in lower-secondary students

    Open Access•João Marôco, Heidi Harju-Luukkainen et al.•International Journal of Science…•2026

  • Learning democratic participation? Meaning-making in discussion of socioscientific issues in science education

    Open Access•Katarina Ottander, Shirley Simon•International Journal of Science…•2021

  • Scientific Literacy and Social Transformation

    Open Access•Liliana Valladares, Nicolás Maurandi Abadía•Science & Education•2021

  • Not Only Why but Also How to Trust Science

    Open Access•Nathan Willig Lima, Matheus Monteiro Nascimento•Science & Education•2022

  • Measuring Pupils’ Attitudes Towards Socioscientific Issues

    Open Access•Lida T Klaver, Juliette H Walma van der Molen•Science & Education•2021

  • Vaccination Information Sources and Decision-Making Among Higher-Secondary Students in India During the Covid-19 Pandemic

    Open Access•Anupama Souri Das, Sandhya Koushika et al.•Science & Education•2026

  • The Fateful Classroom

    Open Access•Florian Böttcher, Anke Meisert•Science & Education•2026

  • Epistemic and Political Confrontations Around the Public Policies to Fight Covid-19 Pandemic

    Open Access•Cristiano B Moura, Matheus Monteiro Nascimento et al.•Science & Education•2021

  • Traces of Bildung in Upper Secondary Science Education

    Open Access•Paul Clucas, Jesper Sjöström•Science & Education•2025

  • Agency and Transformative Potential of Technology in Students’ Images of the Future

    Open Access•Tapio Rasa, Jari Lavonen et al.•Science & Education•2024

  • Bangladeshi Science Teachers’ Perceived Importance and Perceived Current Practices in Promoting Science Education Through a Context-Based, Socio-scientific Framework

    Open Access•TBM Chowdhury, Jack Holbrook et al.•Science & Education•2022

  • Analysing the Nature of Science in the Brazilian Common Core Curriculum

    Open Access•Sara Souza Pimenta, Beyza Okan et al.•Science & Education•2026

  • Co-design of a Teaching–Learning Sequence to Address Covid‐19 as a Socio‐scientific Issue in an Infodemic Context

    Open Access•Lucrecia Estigarribia, Julieta Karina Torrico Chalabe et al.•Science & Education•2022

  • Multivariate Analysis of Beliefs in Pseudoscience and Superstitions Among Pre-service Teachers in Spain

    Open Access•Remo Fernández‐Carro, José Eduardo Vílchez et al.•Science & Education•2023

  • Education for sustainable development in the senior Earth and Environmental Science syllabus in Queensland, Australia

    Open Access•Louisa Tomas, Reece Mills et al.•Australian Journal of Environmental…•2020

  • When Farmers Teach and Teachers Farm

    Open Access•Vishal Kumar, Sanjiv Kumar Choudhary et al.•Australian Journal of Environmental…•2026

  • Exploring different visions of scientific literacy in Irish primary science education

    Open Access•Nicola Broderick•Irish Educational Studies•2025

  • Education and the Future

    Open Access•Tapio Rasa•European Journal of Education•2025

  • Learning to become ignorant

    Open Access•Michael Tan, Teck Seng Koh•Science Education•2023

  • Recognition and operationalization of Future‐Scaffolding Skills

    Open Access•Olivia Levrini, Giulia Tasquier et al.•Science Education•2021

  • Invoking the political in socioscientific issues

    Open Access•Aswathy Raveendran•Science Education•2021

  • The potential of “civic science education”

    Open Access•Brett L M Levy, Alandeom W Oliveira et al.•Science Education•2021

  • Transformative experience in an informal science learning program about climate change

    Open Access•Megan K Littrell, Anne Gold et al.•Journal of Research in Science…•2022

  • Impact of STEAM activities on climate literacy and creative problem solving skills

    Open Access•Yagmur Asilturk, Pelin Yildirim et al.•The Journal of Educational Research•2026

  • Futurising science education

    Open Access•Tapio Rasa, Elina Palmgren et al.•Instructional Science•2022

  • Trade-Offs in Using Mobile Tools to Promote Scientific Action with Socioscientific Issues

    Open Access•Susan A Yoon, Jooeun Shim et al.•TechTrends•2019

  • Activismo Colectivo Basado en la Indagación

    Open Access•Alba Ramos Solano, Carolina Martín Gámez et al.•Revista Internacional de…•2024

  • Enhancing Scientific Literacy in Thailand

    Open Access•Chokchai Yuenyong•Global Studies of Childhood•2013

  • Evolution education in policy and practice

    David E Long•Ethnography & Education•2012

  • Knowledge formalization for Earth Science informed decision-making

    Open Access•P Mazzetti, Stefano Nativi et al.•Environmental Science & Policy•2022

  • We did see the lapwing’ – practising environmental citizenship in upper-secondary science education

    Elisabeth Iversen, Gudrun Jonsdottir•Environmental Education Research•2018

  • Establishing enabling conditions to develop critical thinking skills

    Dina Zoe Belluigi, Georgina Cundill•Environmental Education Research•2015

  • Petro-pedagogy

    Open Access•Emily Eaton, Emily M Eaton et al.•Environmental Education Research•2019

  • Alfabetización científica

    Berta Marco-Stiefel•Culture and Education•2004

  • Facilitating transformative science education through futures thinking

    Open Access•Antti Laherto, Tapio Rasa•On the Horizon The International…•2022

  • Reproducing Values

    Open Access•Aswathy Raveendran, Sugra Chunawala•Indian Journal of Gender Studies•2015

  • From argumentation to real-world action

    Shih-Yeh Chen, Shiang‐yao Liu et al.•International Journal of Science…•2024

  • Fit to teach evolution? Pre- and in-service teachers’ knowledge and acceptance of evolution

    Open Access•Judith Lanka, Pitt Hild et al.•International Journal of Science…•2024

  • Analysis of activities included in Saudi Arabian chemistry textbooks for the inclusion of argumentation-driven inquiry skills

    Open Access•Abdulwali H Aldahmash, Sozan H Omar•Studies In Educational Evaluation•2021

  • Práticas sociais de estudantes de medicina na universidade pública

    Open Access•Glória Walkyria De Fátima Rocha, Vera Helena Ferraz De Siqueira•Trabalho Educação e Saúde•2009

  • Frameworks Supporting Socially Responsible Science Education

    Open Access•Travis T Fuchs, Yuen Sze Michelle Tan•Canadian Journal of Science…•2022

  • Private Profit, Science, and Science Education

    Larry Bencze•Canadian Journal of Science…•2008

  • Projet Peer

    Rodelyn Stoeber•Canadian Journal of Science…•2012

  • Science Education as a Call to Action

    Derek Hodson•Canadian Journal of Science…•2010

  • Introduction to the Special Issue on Activism

    Stewart Alsop, Larry Bencze•Canadian Journal of Science…•2010

  • Mutual Misunderstanding

    Sarah Elizabeth Barrett•Canadian Journal of Science…•2008

  • Relegated to the Margins? The Place of STSE Themes in Québec Secondary Cycle One Science Textbooks

    David I Waddington, Amanda Imbriglio•Canadian Journal of Science…•2011

  • The Seventh Current

    Astrid Steele•Canadian Journal of Science…•2014

  • More Than Particle Theory”

    Erin Sperling, Larry Bencze•Canadian Journal of Science…•2010

  • A Time for Change

    Erminia Pedretti, Katherine Bellomo•Canadian Journal of Science…•2013

  • Student Teachers as Advocates for Student-Led Research-Informed Socioscientific Activism

    Larry Bencze, Erin Sperling•Canadian Journal of Science…•2012

  • Newsround

    Larry Bencze•Canadian Journal of Science…•2007

  • Alliances for Global Ecojustice In/Through STEM Education

    Open Access•Larry Bencze, Chantal Pouliot•Canadian Journal of Science…•2025

  • Electrifying America

    David E Nye•Electrifying America•1990

  • Official Knowledge

    M W Apple•Official Knowledge•2014

  • Scientific literacy for citizenship

    Open Access•Stein Dankert Kolstø•Science Education•2001

  • How literacy in its fundamental sense is central to scientific literacy

    Open Access•Stephen P Norris, Linda M Phillips•Science Education•2003

  • Small is Beautiful

    E F Schumacher•Small is Beautiful•1993

  • Scientific literacy as collective praxis

    Open Access•Wolff-Michael Roth, Stuart Lee•Public Understanding of Science•2002

  • From Nature and Madness

    Paul Shepard, P F Shepard•Learning to Listen to the Land•2013

  • Education for Citizenship and the Teaching of Democracy in Schools

    Open Access•Phil Turner•Teaching Public Administration•1999

  • Reconceptualizing environmental education

    Justin Dillon, Kelly Teamey•Canadian Journal of Science…•2002

  • Subverting corporatism in school science

    Larry Bencze•Canadian Journal of Science…•2001

  • Time to change drivers for scientific literacy

    Peter J Fensham•Canadian Journal of Science…•2002

  • Literacy and Scientific Literacy

    Peter W Hewson•Canadian Journal of Science…•2002

  • Scientific literacy

    Nancy Law•Canadian Journal of Science…•2002

  • Whalewatching as critical science education

    Constance Russell, Derek Hodson•Canadian Journal of Science…•2002

  • Taking science education beyond schooling

    Wolff-Michael Roth•Canadian Journal of Science…•2002

  • Seeking Directions for Change

    Derek Hodson•Curriculum Studies•1994

  • Seeing Curriculum in a New Light

    David Gordon•Curriculum Inquiry•1986

  • Making the Future Work

    William Diebold, John Diebold•Foreign Affairs•1984

  • Creating the Conditions for Scientific Literacy

    M Eisenhart, Elizabeth Finkel et al.•American Educational Research…•1996

  • Reconceptualizing Environmental Education

    Peter Blaze Corcoran, Eric W Sievers et al.•The Journal of Environmental…•1994

  • School science curriculum reforms in Malaysia

    Molly N N Lee•International Journal of Science…•1992

  • What Kind of Inquiry Can Best Help Us Create a Good World

    Open Access•Neville Maxwell, Nicholas Maxwell•Science Technology & Human Values•1992

Unique citing works119
Citations per year5,41
Citation span2004 - 2026 (23)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedYes
Citation typesNeutral: 107

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae