Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Unprincipled Virtue

An Inquiry Into Moral Agency

Bibliographic Data

ID23398175
AuthorsNomy Arpaly (Rice University, corresponding author)
Year2002
Pages203
Publication date2002-12-19
Open AccessNo
TypeBOOK
VenueUnprincipled virtue (SOURCE_BOOK)
PublisherOxford University PressNew York (PUBLISHER)
DOI10.1093/0195152042.001.0001
OpenAlexW4240610838
Open LibraryOL15554673M
ISBN9780195152043
LanguageEN
Citations received78
References cited54

This book presents a positive theory of moral worth. Chapter 1 examines the complexities of moral life that appear to differ from the paradigmatic cases of moral psychology. Chapter 2 argues against the common assumption that akrasia is always irrational, or at least, always less rational than the corresponding self-controlled action. The theory is presented in Chapter 3 — that people are praiseworthy for acts of good will and blameworthy for acts of ill will or absence of good will, and the amount of praise or blame they deserve varies with the depth of their motivation or extent of their indifference. Chapter 4 and 5 defend this theory against potential objections to the effect that there is something wrong with its failure to invoke autonomy, and clarifies the theory’s implications about some issues in moral responsibility often associated with autonomy (i.e., responsibility of kleptomaniacs, drug addicts, makers of Freudian slips, and persons driven to murder by hypnotists).

Action (physics) · Autonomy · Blame · Epistemology · Irrational number · Moral responsibility · Political science · Praise · Virtue · Free Will and Agency · Law · Mathematics · Philosophical Ethics and Theory · Philosophy · Psychology · Psychology of Moral and Emotional Judgment · Social Psychology · Ethics · Psychology and philosophy

  • Moral Worth and Consciousness

    Open Access•John W Robison, John Robison•Ergo an Open Access Journal of…•2020

  • Normative metaphysics for accountants

    Open Access•Barry Maguire, Justin Snedegar•Philosophical Studies•2020

  • Value Incommensurability

    Anders Herlitz, Henrik Andersson•Value Incommensurability•2021

  • The Challenges of Divine Determinism

    Open Access•Peter Furlong•Challenges of Divine Determinism•2019

  • Moral Diversity and Moral Responsibility

    Open Access•Brian Kogelmann, Robert H Wallace•Journal of the American…•2018

  • Against willing servitude

    Open Access•Adam Bales•The Philosophical Quarterly•2025

  • Qualities of will and ambivalent moral worth

    Open Access•Leonie Eichhorn•The Philosophical Quarterly•2024

  • In defence of fictional examples

    Open Access•Alex Fisher•The Philosophical Quarterly•2025

  • To be or Not to be Authentic. In Defence of Authenticity as an Ethical Ideal

    Open Access•Kenneth Bauer•Ethical Theory and Moral Practice•2017

  • Extreme Cognitive Assistance and Open Futures

    Open Access•Nathaniel Sharadin•Journal of Ethics and Social…•2026

  • Accountability without Equality in Social Relations with Thinking Animals

    Open Access•Jon Garthoff•Critica•2026

  • Evidentialism and the Problem of Basic Competence

    Open Access•Timothy R Kearl•Ergo an Open Access Journal of…•2023

  • The Object of Moral Understanding

    Open Access•Samuel Dishaw•Ergo an Open Access Journal of…•2024

  • Biased Emotions

    Open Access•Kris Goffin•Review of Philosophy and Psychology•2023

  • Explanation and Agency

    Open Access•Fleur Jongepier, Esther Keymolen•Ethics and Information Technology•2022

  • Flawed Heroes and Historical Moral Culpability

    Open Access•Sacha Golob•Ethical Theory and Moral Practice•2025

  • Moral Appraisal for Everyone

    Open Access•Claire Field•Ethical Theory and Moral Practice•2021

  • How Did She Get So Good? On Virtue and Skill

    Open Access•Bana Bashour•Ethical Theory and Moral Practice•2021

  • Patronizing Praise

    Open Access•Sofia Jeppsson, Daphne Brandenburg•The Journal of Ethics•2022

  • An Intuitive, Abductive Argument for a Right against Mental Interference

    Open Access•Thomas Douglas•The Journal of Ethics•2025

  • Mania, urgency, and the structure of agency

    Open Access•Elliot Porter•Philosophical Psychology•2025

  • Being Sympathetic to Bad‐History Wrongdoers

    Open Access•Craig K Agule•Pacific philosophical quarterly•2021

  • The Disappearing Agent and the Phenomenology of Agency

    Open Access•Jingbo Hu•Erkenntnis•2025

  • A Plea for Exemptions

    Open Access•Timothy R Kearl•Erkenntnis•2024

  • Teaching drunk

    Open Access•Max F Kramer•Philosophy•2021

  • The Purity of Agent-Regret

    Open Access•Jake Wojtowicz•Philosophy•2022

  • “Grasping” Morality

    Open Access•Zoë A Johnson King•Philosophical Studies•2024

  • Epistemic Blame and the New Evil Demon Problem

    Open Access•Cristina Ballarini•Philosophical Studies•2022

  • A justification for excuses

    Open Access•Clayton Littlejohn•Philosophical Studies•2022

  • Moral worth, right reasons and counterfactual motives

    Open Access•Laura Fearnley•Philosophical Studies•2022

  • Stubborn social emotions and their harms

    Open Access•Kaitlyn Creasy•Philosophical Studies•2026

  • Manipulation, machine induction, and bypassing

    Open Access•Gabriel De Marco•Philosophical Studies•2023

  • At least you tried

    Open Access•Claire Field•Philosophical Studies•2022

  • The fundamental reason for reasons fundamentalism

    Open Access•Mark Schroeder•Philosophical Studies•2021

  • Respect and the reality of apparent reasons

    Open Access•Kurt Sylvan, Kurt L Sylvan•Philosophical Studies•2021

  • What we know when we act

    Open Access•Timothy R Kearl•Philosophical Studies•2023

  • Nonconsensual neurocorrectives, bypassing, and free action

    Open Access•Gabriel De Marco•Philosophical Studies•2022

  • Responsibility for testimonial injustice

    Open Access•Adam Piovarchy•Philosophical Studies•2021

  • Internalism without cartesianism privilege

    Open Access•Darren Bradley•Inquiry•2026

  • Why are emotions epistemically indispensable

    Open Access•Julien Deonna, Fabrice Teroni•Inquiry•2025

  • Oppressive Double Binds

    Sukaina Hirji•Ethics•2021

  • Feeling responsible

    Open Access•Richard Stupart•Media War & Conflict•2021

  • Consequentialism and Moral Worth

    Open Access•Nathaniel Sharadin•Utilitas•2018

  • How Progressive are Multidimensional Accounts of Autonomy? Transnational Feminist-Friendly Amendments and a Critical Intersectional Relational Autonomy

    Open Access•Herjeet Marway•Hypatia•2024

  • Making Room for Children's Autonomy

    Open Access•Patrick R Frierson, Patrick Frierson•Journal of Philosophy of Education•2015

  • Geography and ethics III

    Open Access•Elder Olson•Progress in Human Geography•2017

  • Moralidade positiva e moralidade crítica

    Open Access•Marcelo De Araujo•Veritas (Porto Alegre)•2015

  • Moral zombies

    Open Access•Carissa Véliz•AI & Society•2021

  • When work becomes a game

    Open Access•Tae Wan Kim•Ethics and Information Technology•2025

  • Borderline personality disorder and moral responsibility

    Open Access•Agnès Baehni•Medicine Health Care and Philosophy•2025

  • Gratitude's Fitting Growth

    Open Access•Daniel Telech•Journal of Ethics and Social…•2026

  • Elusive Reasons and the Motivational Constraint

    Open Access•Benjamin Cohen Rossi, Benjamin Rossi•Journal of Ethics and Social…•2021

  • The Trouble with Formal Views of Autonomy

    Open Access•Jonathan Knutzen•Journal of Ethics and Social…•2020

  • Inclusive Blameworthiness and the Wrongfulness of Causing Harm

    Open Access•Evan Tiffany•Journal of Ethics and Social…•2023

  • Culpable Ignorance and Mental Disorders

    Open Access•Dylan McChesney, Matthieu Doucet et al.•Journal of Ethics and Social…•2019

  • The Moral Virtue of Social Consciousness

    Open Access•Anna Brinkerhoff•Journal of Ethics and Social…•2024

  • Hypocrisy and Moral Authority

    Open Access•Jessica Isserow, Colin Klein•Journal of Ethics and Social…•2017

  • Defending the Epistemic Condition on Moral Responsibility

    Open Access•Martin Montminy•Journal of Ethics and Social…•2021

  • Moral Worth in Gettier Cases

    Open Access•Neil Sinhababu•Journal of Ethics and Social…•2024

  • Letting Animals Off the Hook

    Open Access•Nicolas Delon•Journal of Ethics and Social…•2024

  • You Just Didn't Care Enough

    Open Access•Mattias Gunnemyr, Caroline Torpe Touborg•Journal of Ethics and Social…•2023

  • Blaming for Unreasonableness

    Open Access•Alisabeth Ayars•Journal of Ethics and Social…•2021

  • Law and Violence

    Open Access•Alexander Guerrero•Journal of Ethics and Social…•2022

  • A Third Method of Ethics

    Open Access•Roger Crisp•Philosophy and Phenomenological…•2012

  • The Moral Worth of Intentional Actions

    Open Access•Laura Tomlinson•Philosophy and Phenomenological…•2019

  • Agency, Teleological Control and Robust Causation

    Open Access•Marius Usher•Philosophy and Phenomenological…•2018

  • Stop Making Sense? On a Puzzle about Rationality

    Open Access•Clayton Littlejohn•Philosophy and Phenomenological…•2015

  • What's Aristotelian about neo‐Aristotelian Virtue Ethics

    Open Access•Sukaina Hirji•Philosophy and Phenomenological…•2018

  • Doubts about Duty as a Secondary Motive

    Open Access•Jessica Isserow•Philosophy and Phenomenological…•2021

  • One Desire Too Many 1

    Open Access•Nathan Robert Howard•Philosophy and Phenomenological…•2019

  • Ought-contextualism and reasoning

    Open Access•Darren Bradley•Synthese•2021

  • Knowledge, inquiry and dogmatism

    Open Access•Jessica Brown•Synthese•2025

  • Epistemic normativity and the justification-excuse distinction

    Open Access•Cameron Boult•Synthese•2017

  • Epistemic instrumentalism and the problem of epistemic blame

    Open Access•Michelle M Dyke•Synthese•2024

  • Moral deference and morally worthy attitudes

    Open Access•Max Lewis•Philosophical Studies•2025

  • Normative Reasons, Epistemic Autonomy, and Accountability to God

    Open Access•Brandon Rickabaugh•Religions•2023

  • Varieties of Aesthetic Autonomy

    Open Access•Irene Martínez Marín•Philosophy Compass•2024

  • Charisma and Moral Reasoning

    Open Access•Jessica Flanigan•Religions•2013

  • The Practice of Moral Judgment

    Barbara Herman•The Practice of Moral Judgment•1996

  • Liberation from Self

    Open Access•Bernard Berofsky•Liberation from self•1995

  • Responsibility and Control

    Open Access•John Martin Fischer, Mark Ravizza•Responsibility and Control•1998

  • What Happens When Someone Acts?

    J David Velleman•Mind•1992

  • Alternate Possibilities and Moral Responsibility

    Harry G Frankfurt•The Journal of Philosophy•1969

  • Groundwork of the Metaphysics of Morals

    Immanuel Kant, Christine Korsgaard et al.•Kant•2012

  • XIV—Moral Philosophy Meets Social Psychology

    Gilbert Harman•Proceedings of the Aristotelian…•1999

  • Freedom of the Will and the Concept of a Person

    Harry G Frankfurt•The Journal of Philosophy•1971

  • Telling more than we can know

    Richard E Nisbett, Timothy D Wilson•Psychological Review•1977

  • Perspectives on Moral Responsibility

    John Martin Fischer, Mark Ravizza•Perspectives on Moral Responsibilit…•1994

  • The Importance of What We Care About

    Open Access•Harry G Frankfurt•Importance of What We Care About•1988

  • Alienation, Consequentialism, and the Demands of Morality (1984)

    Open Access•Peter Railton•Facts, Values, and Norms•2003

  • The Theory and Practice of Autonomy

    Open Access•Gerald Dworkin•Theory and Practice of Autonomy•1988

  • Culture, Responsibility, and Affected Ignorance

    Michele M Moody-Adams, Michele Moody‐Adams•Ethics•1994

  • Moral Saints

    Susan Wolf, Susan M Wolf•The Journal of Philosophy•1982

  • Faces of Intention

    Open Access•Michael E Bratman•Faces of Intention•1999

  • Free Agency

    Gary Watson•The Journal of Philosophy•1975

  • Moral Luck

    Open Access•Bernard Williams•Moral Luck•1981

  • Virtue and Reason

    John Mcdowell, Sherwood J B Sugden•The Monist•1979

  • The Sources of Normativity

    Open Access•Christine M Korsgaard, Onora O’neill et al.•Sources of Normativity•1996

  • Mental Reality

    Galen Strawson•Mental Reality•1994

  • Essays on Actions and Events

    Donald Davidson, Donald Herbert Davidson•Essays on actions and events•2001

  • Involuntary Sins

    Robert Merrihew Adams•The Philosophical Review•1985

  • Motivated Irrationality

    Jonathan Pressler, David Pears•The Philosophical Review•1986

  • Culpable Ignorance

    Holly Smith, Holly M Smith•The Philosophical Review•1983

  • Skepticism about Weakness of Will

    Gary Watson•The Philosophical Review•1977

  • Moral Cognitivism and Motivation

    Sigrún Svavarsdóttir•The Philosophical Review•1999

  • The Moralistic Fallacy

    Justin D’arms, R D Jacobson et al.•Philosophy and Phenomenological…•2000

  • The Ethics of Belief

    Richard Feldman•Philosophy and Phenomenological…•2000

  • Knowing more about what we can tell

    Open Access•Peter A White•British Journal of Psychology•1988

Unique citing works78
Citations per year5,57
Citation span2012 - 2026 (15)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 77

Tools

Open DOILibgen
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae