Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

The Highs and Lows of Emotional Labor

Detectives' Encounters With Criminals and Victims

Bibliographic Data

ID2366290
AuthorsBarbara Stenro, Barbara Stenross (Indiana University Bloomington, corresponding author), Sherryl Kleinman (0000-0002-9676-857X)
Year1989
Volume17
Issue4
Pages435-452
Publication date1989-01-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueJournal of Contemporary Ethnography (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0891-2416 • E-ISSN: 1552-5414
PublisherSAGE Publications Inc (PUBLISHER)
DOI10.1177/089124189017004003
OpenAlexW2145253090
LanguageEN
Citations received77
References cited26

Sociologists have conceived of emotional labor as alienating. In-depth interviews with general investigative detectives revealed that even within the same occupation workers may find some emotional labor alienating, but other emotional labor bearable or even enjoyable. The detectives we studied disliked their encounters with victims, but enjoyed their encounters with criminals. The detectives discounted criminals' emotional displays as inauthentic, redefined their emotional labor as relevant to catching criminals, and turned the encounters into a game. They could not, however, transform their uncomfortable encounters with victims into a positive experience

Criminology · Emotional labor · Emotional Labor in Professions · Employment and Welfare Studies · Policing Practices and Perceptions · Psychology · Social Psychology

  • Emotional Geographies of Teaching

    Open Access•Anna Hargreaves, Andy Hargreaves•Teachers College Record The Voice…•2001

  • Emotion Norms, Emotion Work, and Social Order

    Open Access•P A Thoits•Feelings and Emotions•2004

  • Seeking Emotional Labor

    Open Access•Sherianne Shuler, Beverly Davenport Sypher•Management Communication Quarterly•2000

  • Dialectic, contradiction, or double bind? Analyzing and theorizing employee reactions to organizational tension

    Sarah J Tracy•Journal of Applied Communication…•2004

  • Becoming a Character for Commerce

    Open Access•Sarah J Tracy•Management Communication Quarterly•2000

  • The Dynamic Role of Emotional Intelligence on the Relationship Between Emotional Labor and Job Satisfaction

    Open Access•Xiaojun Lu, Hyun Jung Lee et al.•Public Personnel Management•2021

  • Capturing knowledge of police investigations

    Geoff Dean, Ivar Andre Fahsing et al.•Police Practice and Research•2008

  • From Custody to Support

    Elif Canalan, Elif Gökçearslan Çifci•Women & Criminal Justice•2025

  • Organizational Approaches to Shame

    Open Access•Daniel D Martin•Sociological Quarterly•2000

  • Gathering emotion

    K Megan Hopper, John Huxford et al.•Journal of Media Practice•2015

  • Emotional and Physiological Processes and Positive Intervention Strategies

    Open Access•Pamela L Perrewe, Daniel C Ganster•Emotional and physiological…•2003

  • Emotional Bureaucracies

    Open Access•Mark Graham•Ethos•2002

  • The Consequences of Emotional Labor

    Open Access•Karen Pugliesi•Motivation and Emotion•1999

  • Emotional labor

    Open Access•Theresa M Glomb, Michael J Tews•Journal of Vocational Behavior•2003

  • Emotional Labor and Burnout

    Open Access•Céleste M Brotheridge, Alicia A Grandey•Journal of Vocational Behavior•2002

  • Win some, lose some

    Open Access•Patricia Simpson, Delphine Lenoir•Women in Management Review•2003

  • Organizational Approaches to Shame

    Open Access•Daniel D Martin•Sociological Quarterly•1999

  • Status Shield

    Open Access•Kenneth H Kolb, Kenneth Kolb•The Blackwell Encyclopedia of…•2017

  • Status Shield

    Open Access•Kenneth H Kolb, Kenneth Kolb•The Blackwell Encyclopedia of…•2010

  • The pugilistic point of view

    Open Access•Lo C J D Wacquant, Lo�c J D Wacquant•Theory and Society•1995

  • Circus aerialism and emotional labour

    Kevin Walby, Dorsey Spencer et al.•Emotions and Society•2020

  • Political economies of emotion

    Mary Holmes, Nathan Manning et al.•Emotions and Society•2020

  • Emotional Subcultures

    Open Access•Kenneth H Kolb•Sociology Compass•2014

  • Old Paths and New Directions

    Open Access•Emily Meanwell, J D Wolfe et al.•Sociology Compass•2008

  • Emotion Management

    Open Access•Alison J Bianchi, Alexander Ruch et al.•Sociology Compass•2016

  • Emotional Labor During Disaster Coverage

    Gretchen Dworznik•Journalism Practice•2020

  • I’ve seen this on CSI’

    Open Access•Laura Huey•Crime Media Culture An…•2010

  • Policing the masculine frontier

    Open Access•Michael Aiello•Crime Media Culture An…•2013

  • Mixed emotions

    Open Access•Anna Hargreaves, Andy Hargreaves•Teaching and Teacher Education•2000

  • Examining Men’s Status Shield and Status Bonus

    Open Access•Marci D Cottingham, Rebecca J Erickson et al.•Sex Roles•2014

  • Consequences of Work-Related Emotions

    Open Access•Chih-Wei Hsieh, Chih‐wei Hsieh et al.•The American Review of Public…•2011

  • Emotional Capital and Professional Socialization

    Spencer E Cahill•Social Psychology Quarterly•1999

  • Passion Work

    Open Access•R Tyson Smith•Social Psychology Quarterly•2008

  • Emotional Labor, Burnout, and Inauthenticity

    Rebecca J Erickson, Christian Ritter•Social Psychology Quarterly•2001

  • The Management of Emotions in the Criminal Justice System

    Sarah Goodrum, Mark C Stafford•Sociological Focus•2003

  • The American Academy of Political and Social Science

    Open Access•Janelle S Wong•The Annals of the American…•1916

  • Emotional Labor Beyond the Frontlines

    Mayola Miranda, Marcia L Godwin•Administrative Theory & Praxis•2018

  • It might have been incompetent, but it wasn't racist’

    Janet Foster•Policing & Society•2008

  • Doing death work

    Dean A Dabney•Policing & Society•2019

  • Judging Genocide

    Open Access•Hollie Nyseth Nzitatira, Evelyn Gertz et al.•Law & Social Inquiry•2023

  • Bridging the Gap Between Prosecutors' Cases and Victims' Biographies in the Criminal Justice System Through Shared Emotions

    Open Access•Sarah Goodrum•Law & Social Inquiry•2013

  • Victims’ Rights, Victims’ Expectations, and Law Enforcement Workers’ Constraints in Cases of Murder

    Open Access•Sarah Goodrum•Law & Social Inquiry•2007

  • The mythologisation of key workers

    Open Access•Camilla R De Camargo, Lilith A Whiley•International Journal of…•2020

  • Police and tragic events

    Open Access•Mark R Pogrebin, Eric D Poole•Journal of Criminal Justice•1991

  • Emotions in uniform

    Open Access•Renae Maree Hayward, Michelle R Tuckey•Human Relations•2011

  • Police Force or Police Service? Gender and Emotional Labor

    Open Access•SUSAN E MARTIN, S E MARTIN et al.•The Annals of the American…•1999

  • Emotional Labor in Academia

    Marcia L Bellas•The Annals of the American…•1999

  • Emotional Demands at Work

    Open Access•Ronnie J Steinberg, Deborah M Figart•The Annals of the American…•1999

  • Emotional Labor Since

    Ronnie J Steinberg, Deborah M Figart•The Annals of the American…•1999

  • Are All Cases Treated Equal

    SHILA RENÉ HAWK, Dean A Dabney•The British Journal of Criminology•2014

  • Making work matter

    Open Access•Janet M Heinsler, Sherryl Kleinman et al.•Qualitative Sociology•1990

  • Helping Women and Protecting the Self

    Open Access•Michelle Wolkomir, Jennifer Power et al.•Qualitative Sociology•2007

  • Strangers in the sheets

    Open Access•I Ladegaard•Socio-Economic Review•2021

  • Learning to Feel

    Open Access•Julian M Groves•The Sociological Review•1995

  • Claiming Competence

    Open Access•Kenneth H Kolb•Symbolic Interaction•2011

  • When the Management of Grief Becomes Everyday Life

    Open Access•Sarah Goodrum•Symbolic Interaction•2008

  • When Emotion Work is Doomed to Fail

    Open Access•Martha Copp•Symbolic Interaction•1998

  • Adventure as Character Work

    Open Access•Lori Holyfield, Gary Alan Fine•Symbolic Interaction•1997

  • Privileging Fieldwork Over Interviews

    Open Access•Sherryl Kleinman, Barbara Stenro et al.•Symbolic Interaction•1994

  • Reconsidering retaliation

    Open Access•Robert Garot•Ethnography•2009

  • The Gendering of Emotional Flexibility

    Open Access•Zaibu Tufail, Francesca Polletta•Gender & Society•2015

  • Alienating and Liberating Emotions at Work

    Open Access•Martin B Tolich, Martin Tolich•Journal of Contemporary Ethnography•1993

  • Pulling Back the Curtain

    Open Access•Emily R Cabani, Emily Cabani et al.•Journal of Contemporary Ethnography•2018

  • Interactions in Expert Service Work

    Open Access•Molly George•Journal of Contemporary Ethnography•2008

  • Not Just a Paper Doll

    Open Access•A Mears, William Finlay•Journal of Contemporary Ethnography•2005

  • You're Not a Stone

    Open Access•Robert Garot•Journal of Contemporary Ethnography•2004

  • Helping Without Caring

    Open Access•Francesca Polletta, Zaibu Tufail•Work and Occupations•2016

  • Client Contact and Emotional Labor

    Open Access•Kathryn J Lively•Work and Occupations•2002

  • Workers and their Customers and Clients

    Open Access•Holly J Mccammon, L J Griffin•Work and Occupations•2000

  • Emotion Work' as a Participant Resource

    Open Access•H Frith, C Kitzinger•Sociology•1998

  • Animal Shelter Emotion Management

    Open Access•N Taylor•Sociology•2010

  • Activists and Emotional Reflexivity

    Open Access•Debra King, Debra S King•Sociology•2006

  • Dirty Work and Intimacy

    Open Access•Kelly Marie Ward•Journal of Health and Social…•2021

  • On the Macrofoundations of Microsociology

    Open Access•Gary Alan Fine•Sociological Quarterly•1991

  • Sociological Realms of Emotional Experience

    Kathryn J Lively, D R Heise•American Journal of Sociology•2004

  • A Content Analysis of the Stigma of Multilevel Marketing Participants on Reddit

    Jessica Pearce, Jessica S Pearce et al.•Deviant Behavior•2023

  • Tense Relationships between Homicide Co-Victims and Detectives in the Wake of Murder

    Mark D Reed, Dean A Dabney et al.•Deviant Behavior•2020

  • Men and women of the corporation

    Rosabeth Moss Kanter•Men and women of the corporation•1977

  • The Discovery of Grounded Theory

    Barney G Glaser, Anselm L Strauss•Discovery of Grounded Theory•2017

  • The Managed Heart

    Arlie Russell Hochschild•Managed Heart•2012

  • The Police

    David J Bordua•The Police•1969

  • Strategic Interaction

    Erving Goffman•Strategic Interaction•1970

  • The Discovery of Grounded Theory

    Barney G Glaser, Anselm L Strauss•Discovery of Grounded Theory•2017

  • The Managed Heart

    Arlie Russell Hochschild•Managed Heart•2003

  • Client Typologies

    Open Access•Lewis A Mennerick•Sociology of Work and Occupations•1974

  • The potential for reform of criminal justice

    Open Access•Herbert Jacob•Journal of Criminal Justice•1975

  • Equals before God, Seminarians as Humanistic Professionals

    Open Access•Raymond F Currie, Sherryl Kleinman•The Canadian Journal of Sociology•1985

  • The effectiveness of policing

    Open Access•Paul Ruschmann, MaryB Veldkamp•Journal of Criminal Justice•1981

  • Managing Emotions in Medical School

    Allen C Smith, Sherryl Kleinman•Social Psychology Quarterly•1989

  • Equals before God

    Barbara G Wheeler, Sherryl Kleinman•Review of Religious Research•1987

  • Sociological Work

    Fanny Ginor, Howard Saul Becker•Sociological Work•2017

  • The Development of Rapport through the Negotiation of Gender in Field Work among Police

    Jennifer Hunt, Jennifer C Hunt•Human Organization•1984

  • Case Routinization in Investigative Police Work

    William B Waegel•Social Problems•1981

  • What Abortion Counselors Want from Their Clients

    Carole Joffe•Social Problems•1978

  • Normal Crimes

    David Sudnow•Social Problems•1965

  • The Professionalization of Medical Students

    Open Access•J Eugene Haas, Jack Haas et al.•Symbolic Interaction•1977

  • Status and Status Strain in the Professions

    Andrew Abbott•American Journal of Sociology•1981

Unique citing works77
Citations per year0,7
Citation span1916 - 2025 (110)
Citation velocityrecent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 77

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae