Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Exploring personhood and identity marking

Paintings of lions and felines in San rock art sites from the southern Maloti-Drakensberg and northeastern Stormberg, South Africa

Bibliographic Data

ID6041772
AuthorsDawn Green (0000-0001-9190-327X, Department of Archaeology, University of Cape Town, Private Bag X3, Rondebosch, 7701, South Africa, corresponding author)
Year2023
Volume58
Issue3
Pages434-476
Publication date2023-07-03
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessNo
TypeARTICLE
VenueAzania Archaeological Research in Africa (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0067-270X • E-ISSN: 1945-5534
PublisherInforma UK Limited (PUBLISHER • GB)
DOI10.1080/0067270x.2023.2231793
OpenAlexW4384825824
LanguageEN
Citations received3
References cited97

With the influence of the ‘new’ ontologies of animisms and performative materialisms, research has shown that people, animals and things are relational and have agency. In southern San ethnography, behaving with understanding was essential for maintaining reciprocal, beneficial relationships between human and animal persons for the good of these communities. People identified with certain animals to facilitate these negotiations. This paper also considers how certain people may have identified through specific animals. San rock paintings of lion and other felines and their painted contexts provide an opportunity to investigate these multiplex relationships and identities. Felines are relatively commonly depicted in sites from the southern Maloti-Drakensberg and adjacent northeastern Stormberg Mountains. Predominantly, lions and felines are depicted walking or standing and are painted with male and female eland, female rhebok and hartebeest. Felines are also depicted with men and women in clothing, postures and equipment that have been associated with ritual specialists and their use of potency. These painted contexts of felines bring focus to their roles as efficient hunters and protectors and the establishment of reciprocal relations with antelope. The similar roles and skillsets of ritual specialists and their leonine transformations are highlighted with both their dividual and individual selves. In addition, the paper considers the affective range of wild and tame behaviours and notions of ǃko᷉ɑ-se and related ǃnɑnnɑ sse practices. Depictions of felines may be exemplars of powerful ritual specialists accentuating their skill and status, an interpretation that has important implications for realising a multiplex understanding of San personhood and identity marking

Aesthetics · Archaeology · Art · Clothing · Ethnography · Ethnology · Geography · Identity (music) · Performative utterance · Personhood · Sociology · Anthropological Studies and Insights · Anthropology · Archaeology and Rock Art Studies · Geographies of human-animal interactions

  • Identity Through Iteration

    Open Access•Andrew Skinner•Genealogy•2025

  • Place, Landscape, and Recursivity

    Open Access•J Parkington, Joe Alfers et al.•de arte•2024

  • Marshill Rockshelter (Eastern Cape, South Africa)

    Paloma De La Peña, Mari Carmen Arriaza et al.•Azania Archaeological Research in…•2026

  • People of the Eland

    Patricia Vinnicombe•People of the Eland•1976

  • The Kung San

    Richard B Lee•The Kung San•1979

  • Statistics for archaeologists

    Robert D Drennan•Statistics for archaeologists•1996

  • Quantifying archaeology

    Stephen Shennan•Quantifying archaeology•1988

  • Boiling energy

    Richard Katz•Boiling energy•1982

  • The Mammals of the Southern African Sub-region

    Open Access•J D Skinner, Christian T Chimimba•Mammals of the Southern African…•2005

  • Thinking from Things

    A Wylie•Thinking from Things•2002

  • Soul Hunters

    Rane Willerslev•Soul Hunters•2007

  • Nisa

    Marjorie Shostak•Nisa•1981

  • Notes Toward a Performative Theory of Assembly

    Judith Butler•Notes Toward a Performative…•2015

  • Past and Present in Hunter Gatherer Studies

    Carmel Schrire•Past and Present in Hunter…•2016

  • Sexual Subjects

    Barbara L Vo, Barbara L Voss•The archaeology of plural and…•2005

  • Hunters and Herders of Southern Africa

    Open Access•Alan Barnard•Hunters and Herders of Southern…•1992

  • Eland, Rhebuck and Cranes

    Aron Mazel, A D Mazel•Goodwin Series•1983

  • Posthumanist Performativity

    K Barad•Signs: Journal of Women in…•2003

  • High and mighty

    Challi, Sam Challis•Time and Mind•2019

  • Fluidities of personhood in the idioms of the Maloti-Drakensberg, past and present, and their use in incorporating contextual ethnographies in southern African rock art research

    Andrew Skinner, Challi et al.•Time and Mind•2022

  • Beyond Nature and Culture

    Philippe Descola, Janet Lloyd et al.•Beyond Nature and Culture•2013

  • Gender Trouble

    Judith Butler•Gender Trouble•2011

  • More-than-human gender performativity

    Anne-Sofie Dichman•Distinktion Journal of Social…•2023

  • The ‘bullets to water’ belief complex

    Brent Sinclair-Thomson, Challi•Journal of Conflict Archaeology•2017

  • Indigenous images of a colonial exotic

    Sven Ouzman•Hunter Gatherer Research•2003

  • Exploding Individuals

    Open Access•Rebekah Sinclair•Hypatia•2020

  • Southern African San Rock Painting as Social Intervention

    Open Access•J David Lewis-Williams, J D Lewis‐Williams et al.•African Archaeological Review•2004

  • Digital Technology in Research and Documentation of Hunter-Gatherer Rock Art in South Africa

    Open Access•Jeremy C Hollmann•African Archaeological Review•2018

  • Different people’ coming together

    M Mcgranaghan•Critical Arts•2014

  • The root and tip of the || kwanna

    Neil Rusch•Critical Arts•2016

  • Images of Power

    Edward B Eastwood, J D Lewis-Williams et al.•The South African Archaeological…•1999

  • Our Gendered Past

    J Parkington, L Wadley•The South African Archaeological…•1999

  • Modelling the Production and Consumption of Rock Art

    J D Lewis-Williams, J D Lewis‐Williams•The South African Archaeological…•1995

  • Therianthropes in San Rock Art

    Pieter Jolly•The South African Archaeological…•2002

  • Documentation, Analysis and Interpretation

    J D Lewis-Williams, J D Lewis‐Williams et al.•The South African Archaeological…•1990

  • Quanto

    J D Lewis-Williams, J D Lewis‐Williams•The South African Archaeological…•1998

  • Big Pictures

    Jeremy C Hollmann•The South African Archaeological…•2001

  • The Syntax and Function of the Giant's Castle Rock-Paintings

    J D Lewis-Williams, J D Lewis‐Williams•The South African Archaeological…•1972

  • The Empiricist Impasse in Southern African Rock Art Studies

    J D Lewis-Williams, J D Lewis‐Williams•The South African Archaeological…•1984

  • The Oxford Encyclopedia of African Historiography

    Thomas Spear•Oxford Encyclopedia of African…•2019

  • Introduction to Rock Art Research

    D S Whitley, David Whitley•Introduction to Rock Art Research•2016

  • Theoretical Perspectives in Rock Art Research

    Inés Domingo, Claire Smith et al.•The South African Archaeological…•2002

  • Successfully Dating Rock Art in Southern Africa Using Improved Sampling Methods and New Characterization and Pretreatment Protocols

    Open Access•A Bonneau, R A Staff et al.•Radiocarbon•2017

  • He Who is a Devourer of Things’

    M Mcgranaghan•Folklore•2014

  • Animals, Animists, and Academics

    Open Access•Graham Harvey•Zygon®•2006

  • Superpositioning in a Sample of Rock-Paintings from the Barkly East District

    J D Lewis‐william, J D Lewis-Williams et al.•The South African Archaeological…•1974

  • We Have Never Been Modern

    T Hugh Crawford, Tony Crawford•Configurations•1994

  • The mantis, the eland and the meerkats

    David Lewis‐william, David Lewis‐Williams•African Studies•1997

  • The Economic and Social Context of Southern San Rock Art [and Comments and Reply]

    J D Lewis‐william, J D Lewis-Williams et al.•Current Anthropology•1982

  • The Archaeology of Personhood

    Chris Fowler, C M Fowler•Archaeology of Personhood•2004

  • Bodies that matter

    Judith Butler•Bodies that matter•1993

  • They are all dead that I could ask

    Open Access•Rachel King, Adelphine Bonneau et al.•Cambridge Archaeological Journal•2022

  • Reconfiguring Hunting Magic

    Open Access•M Mcgranaghan, Challi et al.•Cambridge Archaeological Journal•2016

  • From Illustration to Social Intervention

    Open Access•J D Lewis-Williams, J D Lewis‐Williams•Cambridge Archaeological Journal•2013

  • Rock art and performance in the Stormberg, South Africa

    D M Witelson•Azania Archaeological Research in…•2022

  • Cloaks and torsos

    J Parkington, Andrew Paterson•Azania Archaeological Research in…•2021

  • San rock paintings of women in the southern Maloti-Drakensberg and eastern Stormberg, Eastern Cape Province, South Africa

    Dawn Green•Azania Archaeological Research in…•2022

  • A comparative analysis of rock art in southern Africa

    Ndukuyakhe Ndlovu•Azania Archaeological Research in…•2013

  • Myth and meaning

    Ian Watts, Ian P Watts•Azania Archaeological Research in…•2016

  • Foragers on the Frontiers

    M Mcgranaghan•Azania Archaeological Research in…•2012

  • Relational Personhood Revisited

    Open Access•Chris Fowler•Cambridge Archaeological Journal•2016

  • Revelations of religious reality

    Thomas A Dowson•World Archaeology•1988

  • Like people in prehistory

    Thomas A Dowson•World Archaeology•1998

  • Reading art, writing history

    Thomas A Dowson•World Archaeology•1994

  • Getting Real

    K Barad•differences•1998

  • What Is New Materialism

    Christopher N Gamble, Joshua S Hanan et al.•Angelaki•2019

  • The southern San and the trance dance

    Open Access•J David Lewis-Williams, J D Lewis‐Williams et al.•Antiquity•2012

  • The earliest directly dated rock paintings from southern Africa

    Open Access•Adelphine Bonneau, David Pearce et al.•Antiquity•2017

  • Agency, art and altered consciousness

    Open Access•J D Lewis-Williams, J D Lewis‐Williams•Antiquity•1997

  • A history in paint and stone from Rose Cottage Cave, South Africa

    Sven Ouzman, L Wadley•Antiquity•1997

  • Art and Influence, Presence and Navigation in Southern African Forager Landscapes

    Open Access•Challi, Andrew Skinner•Religions•2021

  • Therefore their parts resemble humans, for they feel that they are people

    Mathias Guenther•Hunter Gatherer Research•2015

  • Simians, Cyborgs, and Women

    Donna Haraway•Simians, Cyborgs, and Women•2013

  • Situated Knowledges

    Donna Haraway•Feminist Studies•1988

  • The Perception of the Environment

    T Ingold•The Perception of the Environment•2002

  • Reentry into First Creation

    Bradford Keeney, Hillary Keeney•Journal of Anthropological Research•2013

  • Cosmological Deixis and Amerindian Perspectivism

    Eduardo Batalha Viveiros De Castro•Journal of the Royal Anthropologica…•1998

  • Eland Hunting Rituals among Northern and Southern San Groups

    Open Access•J D Lewis‐william, J D Lewis-Williams et al.•Africa•1978

  • The Medicine Dance of the !Kung Bushmen

    Open Access•Lorna Marshall•Africa•1969

  • Healing Makes Our Hearts Happy

    Open Access•Barry P Michrina, Barry Michrina•Anthropology of Consciousness•1998

  • The New Materialisms and Indigenous Theories of Non-Human Agency

    Open Access•Jerry Lee Rosiek, Jimmy Snyder et al.•Qualitative Inquiry•2020

  • Sexuality Studies in Archaeology

    Barbara L Vo•Annual Review of Anthropology•2008

  • The Impact of Contact and Colonization on Indigenous Worldviews, Rock Art, and the History of Southern Africa

    Challi, Sam Challi et al.•Current Anthropology•2022

  • One world anthropology

    Open Access•T Ingold•Hau Journal of Ethnographic Theory•2018

  • "Animism" Revisited

    Nurit Bird‐david•Current Anthropology•1999

  • My place is the Bitterpits

    Janette Deacon•African Studies•1986

  • So-called 'infibulation' in African rock art

    A R Willcox•African Studies•1978

  • Three nineteenth-century Southern African San myths

    Open Access•J D Lewis‐william, J David Lewis-Williams et al.•Africa•2018

  • Birds and Khoesān

    Open Access•Chris Low•Africa•2011

  • Entangled

    Open Access•Ian Hodder•Entangled•2012

Unique citing works3
Citations per year1,5
Citation span2024 - 2026 (3)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 3

Tools

Open DOI
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae