Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Models of Government Formation

Bibliographic Data

ID6233074
AuthorsMichael Laver (0000-0001-7515-9831, Department of Political Science, Trinity College, Dublin 2, Ireland;, corresponding author)
Year1998
Volume1
Issue1
Pages1-25
Publication date1998-06-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessNo
TypeARTICLE
VenueAnnual Review of Political Science (BOOK_SERIES)
Journal identifiersISSN: 1094-2939 • E-ISSN: 1545-1577
PublisherAnnual Reviews (PUBLISHER • US)
DOI10.1146/annurev.polisci.1.1.1
OpenAlexW2141152018
LanguageEN
Citations received112
References cited63

This review deals with the making and breaking of governments in “minority legislatures” in which no political party controls a majority of seats. It looks at both a priori and empirical approaches to analyzing government formation, at the application of both cooperative and noncooperative game-theoretic models, and at the impact of both office-seeking and policy-seeking assumptions about the motivations of politicians. Substantive themes covered include the partisan composition of both minority and majority cabinets, the allocation of cabinet portfolios between parties, and the duration of cabinets in minority legislatures. The way forward in this field is identified in terms of the need for more dynamic models that see government formation as a complex system within the broader context of party competition as a whole, and for models that take fundamental account of intraparty politics in their description of the strategic behavior of political parties

Cabinet (room · Competition (biology · Context (archaeology · Democracy · Divided government · Economics · Government (linguistics · Legislature · Multi-party system · Political economy · Political science · Politics · Separation of powers · Electoral Systems and Political Participation · Engineering · Game Theory and Voting Systems · Law · Local Government Finance and Decentralization · Public Administration

  • Governing Europe

    Raw Rhodes, Jack Hayward et al.•Governing Europe•2003

  • Cabinets, Ministers, and Gender

    Claire Annesley, Karen Beckwith et al.•Cabinets, Ministers, and Gender•2019

  • Party Policy in Modern Democracies

    Kenneth Benoit, Michael Laver•Party Policy in Modern Democracies•2006

  • Comparative Executive–Legislative Relations

    Matthew Soberg Shugart•The Oxford Handbook of Political…•2009

  • The Changing European State

    Patrick Le Galès•Governing Europe•2003

  • Contentious Politics in Western Europe and the United States

    Sidney Tarrow•Governing Europe•2003

  • On Studying Governments

    Rudy B Andeweg•Governing Europe•2003

  • Recasting European Welfare States

    Maurizio Ferrera, Anton Hemerijck et al.•Governing Europe•2003

  • What Is New About Governance and Why Does It Matter?

    Roderick A W Rhodes•Governing Europe•2003

  • Comparing Economic Interest Organizations

    C Crouch•Governing Europe•2003

  • Winners and Losers under Proportional Representation

    Open Access•Daniel Bochsler•Government and Opposition•2026

  • Endangered Species Policy in Canada and the US

    Andrea Olive•The American Review of Canadian…•2012

  • Governing in fragmented party systems

    Open Access•Christian Bohlen•Journal of Legislative Studies•2026

  • The quantitative and qualitative allocation of ministerial portfolios to European radical right parties

    Open Access•Tian Yuan Tan•Frontiers in Political Science•2025

  • Party, coalition, premiership

    Michelangelo Vercesi•Contemporary Italian Politics•2013

  • Political Parties, Coalitions and Democracy

    Open Access•Jan‐erik Lane, Alexander M Preker•Open Journal of Political Science•2018

  • Coalition Politics and Inter‐Party Conflict Management

    Open Access•Michelangelo Vercesi•Politics & Policy•2016

  • Party Size, Ideology, and Executive‐Level Representation in Advanced Parliamentary Democracies

    Open Access•Carolyn Forestiere•Politics & Policy•2009

  • Semi-Presidential Systems

    Open Access•Matthew Soberg Shugart•French Politics•2005

  • Strategic convergence, ideological discounting, and pre-electoral coalition formation

    Open Access•Başak Taraktaş, Uzay Çetin•Turkish Studies•2025

  • Party switching and policy disagreement

    Open Access•Hiroki Kubo, Takatomo Matsumoto et al.•Japanese Journal of Political…•2022

  • Fragmentation and performance

    Riccardo Pelizzo•Commonwealth and Comparative…•2010

  • Government Formation and Policy Formulation in the German States

    Thomas Däubler, Marc Debus•Regional & Federal Studies•2009

  • Navigating complexity

    Martin Gro, Jochen Müller et al.•Regional & Federal Studies•2023

  • Government Formation and Public Policy

    Open Access•Michael Laver•PS Political Science & Politics•2000

  • Modelling multiple goals

    Alan Renwick•Europe Asia Studies•2005

  • When Crises Unite. Changing Party Positions on Foreign Policy During Critical Events in Germany

    Open Access•Christina Stremming, Sophie Suda•German Politics•2026

  • Government Formation and Political Discussions in Twitter

    Open Access•Frederic Guerrero-Sole, Hibai Lopez-Gonzalez•Social Science Computer Review•2017

  • Opening the Black Box

    Open Access•Sylvia Gaylord, Lúcio R Rennó et al.•Presidential Studies Quarterly•2015

  • All the President's Men and Women

    Open Access•Carlos Pereira, Frederico Bertholini et al.•Presidential Studies Quarterly•2016

  • Do second-order elections produce second-order governments? How national and regional factors influence the composition of regional governments

    Open Access•Alexander Verdoes•Electoral Studies•2025

  • Pre-electoral commitments and government formation

    Open Access•Marc Debus•Public Choice•2009

  • Crafting consensus

    Open Access•Jan Zápal•Public Choice•2017

  • Alliances électorales entre deux tours de scrutin

    Michel Le Breton, Karine Van Der Straeten•Revue économique•2013

  • Why voters prefer coalitions

    Open Access•Jack Vowles, Jennifer Curtin et al.•Political Science•2011

  • Theory Development in Comparative Social Research

    Open Access•Clemens Kroneberg•KZfSS Kölner Zeitschrift für…•2019

  • Coalition Formation in Legislative Bargaining

    Marco Battaglini•Journal of Political Economy•2021

  • How fractionalisation and polarisation explain the level of government turn-over

    Open Access•Simon Otje•Acta Politica•2020

  • Uncertainty, Complexity, and Gamson’s Law

    Albert Falcó-Gimeno, Indridi Indridason•West European Politics•2013

  • The implications of the European financial crisis and parties’ positions on European integration on the outcomes of government formation processes in Southern Europe

    Nicola Palma, Marc Debus•South European Society & Politics•2023

  • Investiture rules and formation of minority governments in European parliamentary democracies

    Open Access•José Antônio Cheibub, Shane Martins et al.•Party Politics•2021

  • Communist Successor Parties And Coalition Formation In Eastern Europe

    Open Access•James N Druckman, Andrew Roberts•Legislative Studies Quarterly•2007

  • The Political Dynamics of Portfolio Design in European Democracies

    Open Access•Ulrich Sieberer, Thomas M Meyer et al.•British Journal of Political…•2021

  • Power within Parties

    Open Access•M Tavits•American Journal of Political…•2011

  • Who Gets what and how Does it Matter? Importance-Weighted Portfolio Allocation and Coalition Support in Brazil

    Open Access•Marta Batista•Journal of Politics in Latin…•2018

  • Coalition dynamics

    Open Access•Wolfgang C Müller, Hanna Bäck et al.•West European Politics•2024

  • Assembly dissolution powers and incumbency advantages in coalition formation

    Petra Schleiter, Cristina Bucur•West European Politics•2024

  • The power of prime ministers

    Alex Marland, Eoin O''Malley et al.•West European Politics•2025

  • Parliaments and government termination

    Reuven Y Hazan, Bjørn Erik Rasch•West European Politics•2022

  • Adopting restriction

    Open Access•Fabio Ellger, Heinrich Kluver•West European Politics•2025

  • Small parties

    Nicole Bolleyer•West European Politics•2007

  • Parliamentary scrutiny of the EU’s Common Foreign and Security Policy

    Annika Herbel•West European Politics•2017

  • Policy Preferences in Coalition Formation and the Stability of Minority and Surplus Governments

    Anna Bassi, Anna Maria Bassi•The Journal of Politics•2017

  • Italy’s right turn. A spatial analysis of party competition in the 2022 Italian national election

    Paolo Gambacciani, Daniela Giannetti et al.•South European Society & Politics•2025

  • Like Leaves in the Wind? Economic Conditions and Government Survival in Italy (1946–2015)

    Luca Pinto•South European Society & Politics•2018

  • Gendering Gamson's Law

    Open Access•John A Scherpereel, Marie Jeanne Adams et al.•Politics & Gender•2021

  • The Effect of Pre-Electoral Party Coordination on Vote Choice

    Open Access•Carolina Plescia•Political Studies•2017

  • Center Parties, Party Competition, and the Implosion of Party Systems

    Open Access•Christoffer Green-Pedersen•Political Studies•2004

  • New Alliances

    Open Access•Sarah L De Lange•Political Studies•2012

  • Dynamic Approaches to Studying Parliamentary Coalitions

    Open Access•James N Druckman•Political Research Quarterly•2008

  • The Executive Toolbox

    Open Access•Eric D Raile, Carlos Pereira et al.•Political Research Quarterly•2011

  • New Empirical Strategies for the Study of Parliamentary Government Formation

    Open Access•George Glasgow, Garrett Glasgow et al.•Political Analysis•2012

  • Measuring Political Positions from Legislative Speech

    Open Access•Benjamin E Lauderdale, Alexander Herzog•Political Analysis•2016

  • Ruling divided

    Open Access•Zachary David Greene, Zachary Greene et al.•Party Politics•2018

  • Explaining coalition-bargaining outcomes

    Open Access•Katrin Schermann, Laurenz Ennser-Jedenastik•Party Politics•2014

  • Modelling Government Formation in Denmark and Beyond

    Open Access•Asbjørn Skjæveland•Party Politics•2009

  • Be careful what you wish for

    Open Access•Marta Batista, Timothy J Power et al.•Party Politics•2024

  • ThePastof Parliamentary and Legislative Studies

    Open Access•Shane Martins, Michelle M Taylor-Robinson et al.•Parliamentary Affairs•2022

  • Portfolio Allocation or Policy Horizons? Determinants of Coalition Formation in Danish Local Government

    Søren Serritzlew, Jens Blom-Hansen et al.•Local Government Studies•2010

  • The Advantage of Incumbents in Coalitional Bargaining

    Open Access•Jaakko Meriläinen, Janne Tukiainen•Legislative Studies Quarterly•2022

  • When extremes meet

    Open Access•Konstantinos Matakos, Dimitrios Xefteris•Journal of Theoretical Politics•2017

  • Change in parliamentary party systems and policy outcomes

    Open Access•Carol Mershon, Olga Shvetsova•Journal of Theoretical Politics•2014

  • Party Competition and Coalition Formation

    Open Access•Daniela Giannetti, Itai Sened•Journal of Theoretical Politics•2004

  • Who Decides WhatEUIssues Ministers Talk About? Explaining GovernmentalEUPolicy Co‐Ordination inFinland

    Open Access•Anna Hyvärinen, Tapio Raunio•JCMS Journal of Common Market…•2014

  • Faraway, so close

    Open Access•Daniela Giannetti, Andrea Pedrazzani et al.•Italian Political Science…•2022

  • Ideological Fractionalization and the International Conflict Behavior of Parliamentary Democracies1

    Open Access•Joe Clare•International Studies Quarterly•2010

  • Descriptive Representation and Policymaking Authority

    Open Access•Andrew B Whitford, Vicky M Wilkins et al.•Governance•2007

  • Cabinet Composition, Collegiality, and Collectivity

    Open Access•Kenny William Ie•European Political Science Review•2022

  • Theories of coalition formation

    Open Access•Asbjørn Skjæveland, Søren Serritzlew et al.•European Journal of Political…•2007

  • Analyzing Greens in power

    Open Access•Benoît Rihoux, Wolfgang Rüdig•European Journal of Political…•2006

  • The portfolio allocation paradox

    Open Access•Paul Warwick, Paul V Warwick et al.•European Journal of Political…•2006

  • From political novices to strategists

    Open Access•Fredrick Ajwang, Geoffrey Lugano•Democratization•2025

  • Conceptualizing and measuring subnational democracy across Indian states

    Open Access•Imke Harbers, Jos Bartman et al.•Democratization•2019

  • The Economic Turn in Comparative Politics

    Open Access•Margaret Levi•Comparative Political Studies•2000

  • And Yet It Moves

    Open Access•Pablo Fernández-Vázquez•Comparative Political Studies•2014

  • Credibility Versus Competition

    Open Access•Karleen Jones West, Jae-Jae Spoon et al.•Comparative Political Studies•2013

  • Revenge of the Radical Right

    Open Access•Lenka Bustikova•Comparative Political Studies•2014

  • Are Ministerial Gates Closed? Party Politicization and Fractionalization in the Federal Political Bureaucracy (1999-2018)

    Open Access•Felix Garcia Lopez, Thiago Moreira•Brazilian Political Science Review•2024

  • Taking Portfolios Difference Seriously

    Open Access•Marta Batista, Mariana Batista•Brazilian Political Science Review•2017

  • Constitutional Political Economy

    Norman, Schofield Norman•Annual Review of Political Science•2000

  • The Basic Arithmetic of Legislative Decisions

    Open Access•Michael Laver, Kenneth Benoit•American Journal of Political…•2015

  • The Importance of Concurrence

    James N Druckman, Michael F Thies et al.•American Journal of Political…•2002

  • The Logic of Gamson's Law

    Open Access•Royce Carroll, Gary W Cox•American Journal of Political…•2007

  • Divisor Methods for Sequential Portfolio Allocation in Multi‐Party Executive Bodies

    Open Access•Brendan O''Leary, Brian O’leary et al.•American Journal of Political…•2005

  • A Model of Endogenous Government Formation

    Open Access•Anna Bassi, Anna Maria Bassi•American Journal of Political…•2013

  • Contending Models of Portfolio Allocation and Office Payoffs to Party Factions

    Carol Mershon•American Journal of Political…•2001

  • Who “Wins”? Determining the Party of the Prime Minister

    Open Access•George Glasgow, Garrett Glasgow et al.•American Journal of Political…•2011

  • The Formation of Oversized Coalitions in Parliamentary Democracies

    Craig Volden, Clifford J Carrubba•American Journal of Political…•2004

  • Parties Getting Impatient

    Open Access•Albert Falcó-Gimeno•British Journal of Political…•2012

  • Party-System Extremism in Majoritarian and Proportional Electoral Systems

    Open Access•Jay K Dow•British Journal of Political…•2011

  • Coalitions in Parliamentary Government

    L Dodd•Coalitions in Parliamentary…•2015

  • The theory of political coalitions.

    William H Riker•The theory of political coalitions.•1962

  • Game Theory and Economic Modelling

    David M Kreps•Game theory and economic modelling•1990

  • Rationalizing Parliament

    Open Access•John D Huber•Rationalizing Parliament•1996

  • Making and Breaking Governments

    Open Access•Michael Laver, Kenneth A Shepsle•Making and Breaking Governments•1996

  • Ideology, Strategy and Party Change

    Open Access•Ian Budge, David Robertson et al.•Ideology, Strategy and Party Change•1987

  • Instability of Simple Dynamic Games

    Norman Schofield•The Review of Economic Studies•1978

  • Intransitivities in multidimensional voting models and some implications for agenda control

    Open Access•Richard D Mckelvey•Journal of Economic Theory•1976

  • Generalized Symmetry Conditions at a Core Point

    Richard D Mckelvey, Norman Schofield•Econometrica•1987

  • General Conditions for Global Intransitivities in Formal Voting Models

    Richard D Mckelvey•Econometrica•1979

  • An economic theory of democracy

    Anthony Downs•An economic theory of democracy•1985

  • Comparative Democracy

    Gregory M Luebbert•Comparative Democracy•1986

  • Government Survival in Parliamentary Democracies

    Open Access•Paul Warwick•Government Survival in…•1995

  • Existence of a ?structurally stable? equilibrium for a non-collegial voting rule

    Open Access•Norman Schofield•Public Choice•1986

  • Government Coalitions in Western Democracies

    David Childs•International Affairs•1982

  • Coalition government in Western Europe

    David Hine•International Affairs•1984

  • Admission of European Free Trade Association states to the European Community

    Open Access•Madeleine O Hosli•International Organization•1993

  • Government Coalitions in Western Europe

    Open Access•Michael Taylor, Michael Laver•European Journal of Political…•1973

  • Voting strength in the European Parliament

    Open Access•Madeleine O Hosli•European Journal of Political…•1997

  • Bargaining Theory and Portfolio Payoffs in European Coalition Governments 1945–83

    Open Access•Norman Schofield, Michael Laver•British Journal of Political…•1985

  • Aspects of Coalition Payoffs in European Parliamentary Democracies

    Open Access•Eric C Browne, Mark N Franklin•American Political Science Review•1973

  • The Effect of Dominant and Central Parties on Cabinet Composition and Durability

    Open Access•Peter Van Roozendaal•Legislative Studies Quarterly•1992

  • Coalition Politics

    Open Access•Norman Schofield•Journal of Theoretical Politics•1995

  • Cabinets in the Netherlands (1918–1990)

    Open Access•Peter Van Roozendaal•European Journal of Political…•1993

  • Dominant players and minimum size coalitions

    Open Access•A M A Van Deemen•European Journal of Political…•1989

  • Political competitition and multiparty coalition governments

    Open Access•Norman Schofield•European Journal of Political…•1993

  • Toward a theoretical explanation of premature cabinet termination

    Open Access•B Grofman, Peter Van Roozendaal•European Journal of Political…•1994

  • The Durability of Coalition Governments in Parliamentary Democracies

    Open Access•Paul Warwick•Comparative Political Studies•1979

  • An “Events” Approach to the Problem of Cabinet Stability

    Open Access•Eric C Browne, John P Frendreis et al.•Comparative Political Studies•1984

  • Measures of Cabinet Durability

    Open Access•Arend Lijphart•Comparative Political Studies•1984

  • The Process of Cabinet Dissolution

    Eric C Browne, John P Frendreis et al.•American Journal of Political…•1986

  • Constraints on Cabinet Formation in Parliamentary Democracies

    Kaare W Strøm, Kaare Strom et al.•American Journal of Political…•1994

  • A Unified Model of Cabinet Dissolution in Parliamentary Democracies

    Gary King, James E Alt et al.•American Journal of Political…•1990

  • Allocating Coalition Payoffs by Conventional Norm

    Eric C Browne, John P Frendreis•American Journal of Political…•1980

  • Reassessing the Importance of Size and Ideology for the Formation of Governing Coalitions in Parliamentary Democracies

    Mark N Franklin, Thomas T Mackie•American Journal of Political…•1984

  • Events, Equilibria, and Government Survival

    Michael Laver, Kenneth A Shepsle•American Journal of Political…•1998

  • Theory of Games and Economic Behavior

    Robert Leonard, Robert J Leonard•History of Political Economy•2006

  • Coalition Termination and the Strategic Timing of Parliamentary Elections

    Open Access•Arthur Lupia, Kaare W Strøm et al.•American Political Science Review•1995

  • Stable Governments and the Allocation of Policy Portfolios

    Open Access•David Austen-Smith, David Austen‐smith et al.•American Political Science Review•1990

  • Coalitions and Cabinet Government

    Open Access•Michael Laver, Kenneth A Shepsle•American Political Science Review•1990

  • Contending Models of Cabinet Stability

    Open Access•Kaare W Strøm, Kaare Strom et al.•American Political Science Review•1988

  • The Vote of Confidence in Parliamentary Democracies

    Open Access•John D Huber•American Political Science Review•1996

  • Bargaining in Legislatures

    Open Access•David P Baron, John Ferejohn et al.•American Political Science Review•1989

  • Party Goals and Government Performance in Parliamentary Democracies

    Open Access•Kaare W Strøm, Kaare Strom•American Political Science Review•1985

  • Elections, Coalitions, and Legislative Outcomes

    Open Access•David Austen-Smith, David Austen‐smith et al.•American Political Science Review•1988

  • A Spatial Bargaining Theory of Government Formation in Parliamentary Systems

    Open Access•David P Baron•American Political Science Review•1991

  • Party Systems and Government Stability

    Open Access•Michael Taylor, V M Herman et al.•American Political Science Review•1971

  • The Costs of Coalition

    Open Access•Carol Mershon•American Political Science Review•1996

  • A Method for Evaluating the Distribution of Power in a Committee System

    Open Access•L S Shapley, Martin Shubik•American Political Science Review•1954

Unique citing works112
Citations per year4,31
Citation span2000 - 2026 (27)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedYes
Citation typesNeutral: 111

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae