Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Structural predictors of choice

Testing a multilevel rational choice theory of crime

Bibliographic Data

ID9680946
AuthorsKyle J Thomas (0000-0002-7670-9097, University of Colorado Boulder, corresponding author), Eric P Baumer (0000-0003-1495-6962, Pennsylvania State University), Thomas A Loughran (Pennsylvania State University)
Year2022
Volume60
Issue4
Pages606-636
Publication date2022-11-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueCriminology (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0011-1384 • E-ISSN: 1745-9125
PublisherWiley (PUBLISHER • GB)
DOI10.1111/1745-9125.12314
OpenAlexW4283816826
LanguageEN
Citations received28
References cited98

Extant research has provided support for the micro‐level predictions of rational choice models of crime. Yet, a central feature of the rational choice perspective in the broader social sciences—that it is multilevel in focus, situating individuals within broader community social structures—has been neglected within criminology. In this article, we discuss and test a model that links community structural characteristics to several individual expectations and preferences relevant to crime. Using data from the Pathways to Desistance study, we find that objective levels of neighborhood concentrated disadvantage influence individuals’ perceptions of, and preferences for, the risks, costs, and rewards associated with offending indirectly by affecting perceived disorder and perceived opportunities for legitimate avenues of success within one's neighborhood. The implications of a multilevel rational choice model of offending are discussed

Criminal behavior · Criminology · Disadvantage · Extant taxon · Multilevel model · Perception · Perspective (graphical · Rational choice theory (criminology · Sociology · Test (biology · Computer Science · Crime Patterns and Interventions · Psychology · Social Psychology · Substance Abuse Treatment and Outcomes · Wildlife Conservation and Criminology Analyses

  • Revisiting the tautology problem in rational choice theory

    Open Access•Kevin F Steinmetz, Travis C Pratt•European Journal of Criminology•2024

  • Moving to Crime Opportunity

    Open Access•P Jeffrey Brantingham, Christophe Vandeviver•Journal of Quantitative Criminology•2025

  • Neighborhood Context Shapes Effects of Physical Disorder and Spatial Knowledge on Burglars’ Location Choice

    Open Access•L Cai, Yanji Zhang et al.•Journal of Quantitative Criminology•2026

  • Focal Visual Attention in Crime Decision Making

    Open Access•Max Knabe, Timothy C Barnum et al.•Journal of Quantitative Criminology•2026

  • Neighborhood Disadvantage, Social Groups, and Adolescent Violence

    Kyle J Thomas, Jennifer O’Neill et al.•Justice Quarterly•2025

  • If the Cops Won’t, Maybe a Gang Will

    Open Access•Robert H Geibler, Jun Wu et al.•Criminal Justice and Behavior•2025

  • Are Group Settings Intoxicating? Groups, Alcohol, and the Situational Dynamics of Violence

    Open Access•Brendan Lantz, Sarah R Wouters•Criminal Justice and Behavior•2025

  • Rational choice models of crime decision‐making

    Open Access•Shaina Herman, Timothy C Barnum et al.•Criminology•2026

  • Unpacking Unexplored Psychological Factors in Alcohol and Substance Use in Gang Members

    Open Access•Justin Jabar Joseph•Crime & Delinquency•2026

  • Relative Labor Market Utility Perceptions and Offending

    Open Access•Chae M Jaynes•Crime & Delinquency•2025

  • Constrained Choice? The Role of Co-Offenders and Structural Context in the Decision to Escalate Interpersonal Violence

    Open Access•M R Wenger, Brendan Lantz et al.•Crime & Delinquency•2025

  • Illegal Earnings, Opportunity Structures and the Timing of Life Transitions

    Open Access•Holly Nguyen, Brandy Parker et al.•Crime & Delinquency•2025

  • Effect of Early Interactions With the Police on Intertemporal Choice

    Open Access•Jessica R Deitzer, Willem E Frankenhuis et al.•Crime & Delinquency•2025

  • Decision Making in the Real World

    Open Access•Carole Gibbs, Jennifer E Cobbina-Dungy et al.•Crime & Delinquency•2024

  • When the World Falls Apart

    Open Access•Ekaterina V Botchkovar, Matthew Kafafian et al.•Crime & Delinquency•2025

  • Examining Firearm Offenses

    Open Access•Jaclyn M Cwick, Joshua H Williams•Crime & Delinquency•2025

  • Choice, Social Structure, and Crime

    Open Access•Timothy C Barnum, Jean-Louis Van Gelder et al.•Crime & Delinquency•2025

  • Moral Salience, Situational Moral Evaluations, and Criminal Choice

    Open Access•Shaina Herman, Greg Pogarsky•Crime & Delinquency•2025

  • Does crime (n)ever skip a beat? Analyzing crime heartbeats in a European city

    Open Access•Robin Khalfa, Thom Snaphaan et al.•Time & Society•2025

  • History, Linked Lives, Timing, and Agency

    Open Access•David C Pyrooz, John Leverso et al.•Annual Review of Criminology•2023

  • Do meteorological and environmental factors influence theft crimes? A study on the risk of theft crimes in HN City

    Open Access•Xiaomin Jiang, Zinan Xu et al.•International journal of law,…•2026

  • To engage or not to’

    Twine H Bananuka, David Mugarra•International Journal of Lifelong…•2023

  • Crime reporting in Russia

    Open Access•Aryna Dzmitryieva, Kirill Titaev•International Journal of…•2025

  • How people choose between criminal opportunities

    Open Access•Andrew T Krajewski, Justin T Pickett et al.•Criminology•2025

  • Recency and decay effects in sanction risk updating

    Open Access•Kyle J Thomas, Greg Pogarsky•Criminology•2026

  • When does a provocation demand a violent response? A randomized scenario study of the code of the street

    Open Access•Clemens Kroneberg, André Ernst et al.•Theory and Society•2026

  • The American Dream

    Open Access•Petter Gottschalk•Deviant Behavior•2024

  • Perceptions of Potential White-Collar Criminals in Romania

    Open Access•Andreea-Luciana Urzică, Petter Gottschalk•Deviant Behavior•2024

  • Drugs, crime, and social isolation

    Adele Harrell, George E Peterson•Drugs, crime, and social isolation•1992

  • Social sources of delinquency

    Ruth Rosner Kornhauser•Social sources of delinquency•1978

  • Armed Robbers in Action

    Richard T Wright, Scott H Decker•Armed Robbers in Action•2011

  • Rational Choice Sociology

    Michael Hechter•Rational Choice Sociology•2019

  • Great American City

    Robert J Sampson, William Julius Wilson•Great American City•2012

  • The Current State of Differential Association Theory

    Open Access•Ross L Matsueda•Crime & Delinquency•1988

  • Criminal Deterrence

    AARON CHALFIN, Justin McCrary•Journal of Economic Literature•2017

  • Seductions of Crime

    Steven B Katz, J Katz•The Journal of Criminal Law and…•1989

  • Social Disorganization and Stake in Conformity

    Jackson Toby•The Journal of Criminal Law…•1957

  • Individual Perceptions of the Criminal Justice System

    Lance Lochner•American Economic Review•2007

  • An Economic Analysis of a Drug-Selling Gang's Finances

    Steven D Levitt, Sudhir Alladi Venkatesh•The Quarterly Journal of Economics•2000

  • A Mathematical Theory of Communication

    Claude E Shannon•Bell System Technical Journal•1948

  • Demographic and Economic Change in Developed Countries

    National Bureau of Economic National Bureau of Economic Research•Demographic and Economic Change…•1967

  • Hierarchical linear models

    Anthony S Bryk, Stephen W Raudenbush•Hierarchical linear models•2002

  • Distinction

    Pierre Bourdieu, Tony Bennett-undifferentiated•Distinction•1984

  • Principles of Criminology

    David F Luckenbill, Donald R Cressey et al.•Principles of Criminology•1992

  • The Truly Disadvantaged

    William Julius Wilson•Truly Disadvantaged•2012

  • Estimating Latent Preferences for Crime

    Kyle J Thomas, Jennifer O’Neill et al.•Justice Quarterly•2023

  • Examining the Effect of Residential Mobility on Crime Through the Mechanism of Perceived Informal Social Costs

    Open Access•Matthew C Kijowski, Theodore Wilson•Crime & Delinquency•2022

  • The Encyclopedia of Criminology and Criminal Justice

    Open Access•Jay S Albanese•Encyclopedia of Criminology and…•2014

  • The Handbook of Criminological Theory

    Open Access•Alex R Piquero•Handbook of Criminological Theory•2015

  • A Reconceptualization of General and Specific Deterrence

    Open Access•Mark C Stafford, Mark Warr•Journal of Research in Crime and…•1993

  • Juvenile Delinquency and Urban Areas

    Clifford R Shaw, Henry D Mckay•Harvard Law Review•1943

  • Market Wages and Youth Crime

    Jeff Grogger•Journal of Labor Economics•1998

  • A social neuroscience perspective on adolescent risk-taking

    Open Access•Laurence Steinberg•Developmental Review•2008

  • Cumulative Disadvantage in the American Criminal Justice System

    Megan C Kurlychek, Brian D Johnson•Annual Review of Criminology•2019

  • Elaborating the Individual Difference Component in Deterrence Theory

    Alex R Piquero, Raymond Paternoster et al.•Annual Review of Law and Social…•2011

  • Neighborhood Disadvantage and Biological Aging

    Open Access•Man-Kit Lei, R L Simons et al.•The Journals of Gerontology…•2017

  • Neighbourhood context and unsolved murders

    N Petersen•Policing & Society•2015

  • Burglars on the Job, Streetlife and Residential Break-ins

    Open Access•Dermot P J Walsh, Dermot Walsh•International Journal of the…•1995

  • Crime and Work

    Jeffrey Fagan, Richard B Freeman•Crime and Justice•1999

  • Social Anatomy of Racial and Ethnic Disparities in Violence

    Robert J Sampson, Jeffrey D Morenoff et al.•American Journal of Public Health•2005

  • The effects of devaluation and solvability on crime clearance

    Open Access•Paige E Vaughn•Journal of Criminal Justice•2020

  • Deterrence

    Open Access•Graeme R Newman, Graeme Newman•Journal of Criminal Justice•1973

  • Lower Class Culture as a Generating Milieu of Gang Delinquency

    Open Access•Walter B Miller•Journal of Social Issues•1958

  • Participation in Illegitimate Activities

    Isaac Ehrlich•Journal of Political Economy•1973

  • Crime and Punishment

    Gary S Becker•Journal of Political Economy•1968

  • Neighborhood Structural Characteristics, Individual‐level Attitudes, and Youths' Crime Reporting Intentions

    Open Access•Lee Ann Slocum, Terrance J Taylor et al.•Criminology•2010

  • Neighborhood Disadvantage and Police Notification by Victims of Violence

    Open Access•Eric P Baumer•Criminology•2002

  • Toward a Bifurcated Theory of Emotional Deterrence

    Open Access•Justin T Pickett, Sean Patrick Roche et al.•Criminology•2018

  • The Missing Link in General Deterrence Research

    Open Access•Gary Kleck, BRION SEVER et al.•Criminology•2005

  • Testing a Bayesian Learning Theory of Deterrence Among Serious Juvenile Offenders

    Open Access•SHAMENA ANWAR, Thomas A Loughran•Criminology•2011

  • A Dual‐systems Approach for Understanding Differential Susceptibility to Processes of Peer Influence

    Open Access•Kyle J Thomas, Jean Marie Mcgloin•Criminology•2013

  • Can Rational Choice Be Considered a General Theory of Crime? Evidence From Individual‐level Panel Data

    Open Access•Thomas A Loughran, Ray Paternoster et al.•Criminology•2016

  • Moving Choice to Center Stage in Criminological Research and Theory

    Open Access•Daniel S Nagin•Criminology•2007

  • Residential Change as a Turning Point in the Life Course of Crime

    Open Access•David S Kirk•Criminology•2012

  • Not Just “For the Thrill of It”

    Open Access•B Mccarthy•Criminology•1995

  • Toward an Analytical Criminology

    Open Access•Ross L Matsueda•Criminology•2017

  • Perceived arrest risk, psychic rewards, and offense specialization

    Open Access•Kyle J Thomas, Thomas A Loughran et al.•Criminology•2020

  • Learning to Be Bad

    Open Access•R L Simons, Callie H Burt•Criminology•2011

  • Testing a rational choice model of “desistance

    Open Access•Kyle J Thomas, M Vogel•Criminology•2019

  • Bourdieu, rational action and the time‐space strategy of gentrification

    Open Access•Gary Bridge•Transactions of the Institute of…•2001

  • Carjacking, Streetlife and Offender Motivation

    Byron A Jacobs•The British Journal of Criminology•2003

  • Social Disorganization and Theories of Crime and Delinquency

    Open Access•Robert J Bursik•Criminology•1988

  • Social Structure and Anomie

    Robert K Merton•American Sociological Review•1938

  • Destiny and Drift

    J Hagan•American Sociological Review•1991

  • Crime, Deterrence, and Rational Choice

    Irving Piliavin, Rosemary Gartner et al.•American Sociological Review•1986

  • Enduring Individual Differences and Rational Choice Theories of Crime

    Open Access•Daniel S Nagin, Raymond Paternoster•Law & Society Review•1993

  • Social Learning and Deviant Behavior

    Ronald L Akers, Marvin D Krohn et al.•American Sociological Review•1979

  • Deterring Delinquents

    Open Access•Ross L Matsueda, Derek A Kreager et al.•American Sociological Review•2006

  • Violence, Older Peers, and the Socialization of Adolescent Boys in Disadvantaged Neighborhoods

    Open Access•David J Harding•American Sociological Review•2009

  • Conscience, Significant Others, and Rational Choice

    Open Access•Harold G Grasmick, Robert J Bursik•Law & Society Review•1990

  • Decisions to Participate in and Desist from Four Types of Common Delinquency

    Open Access•Raymond Paternoster•Law & Society Review•1989

  • Legal Cynicism and (Subcultural?) Tolerance of Deviance

    Open Access•Robert J Sampson, Dawn Jeglum Bartusch•Law & Society Review•1998

  • Deterrence

    Open Access•Michael R Geerken, Walter R Gove•Law & Society Review•1975

  • The Impact of Social Structure on Economic Outcomes

    Open Access•Mark Granovetter•The Journal of Economic…•2005

  • Do Better Wages Reduce Crime? A Research Note

    Open Access•Samuel L Myers•American Journal of Economics and…•1984

  • Neighborhood Disadvantage, Disorder, and Health

    Catherine E Ro, CATHERINE E ROSS et al.•Journal of Health and Social…•2001

  • Gangstas, Thugs, and Hustlas

    Charis E Kubrin•Social Problems•2005

  • Delinquency, Situational Inducements, and Commitment to Conformity

    Scott Briar, Irving Piliavin•Social Problems•1965

  • Interpreting Community Effects on Youth Educational Attainment

    Open Access•J South, Scott J South et al.•Youth & Society•2003

  • New Economics of Sociological Criminology

    B Mccarthy•Annual Review of Sociology•2002

  • Sociological Rational Choice Theory

    Michael Hechter, Kanazawa et al.•Annual Review of Sociology•1997

  • Decision-Making Processes in Social Contexts

    Elizabeth Bruch, Fred Feinberg et al.•Annual Review of Sociology•2017

  • Escaping Distressed Neighborhoods

    J South, Scott J South et al.•American Journal of Sociology•1997

  • Systematic Social Observation of Public Spaces

    Robert J Sampson, Stephen W Raudenbush•American Journal of Sociology•1999

  • Constraints and choices in mothers' employment careers

    Open Access•Susan Mcrae, Susan B Mcrae•British Journal of Sociology•2003

Unique citing works28
Citations per year9,33
Citation span2023 - 2026 (4)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 28

Tools

Open DOI
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae