Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Impacts of Early Childhood Education on Medium- and Long-Term Educational Outcomes

Bibliographic Data

ID9732113
AuthorsDana Charles Mccoy (0000-0002-0896-1813, Harvard University, Cambridge, MA, corresponding author), Hirokazu Yoshikawa (0000-0001-5607-8526, New York University, New York, NY), Kathleen M Ziol‐guest (New York University), Kathleen M Ziol-Guest (New York University, New York, NY), Greg J Duncan (0000-0002-9869-6311, University of California, Irvine, CA), Holly S Schindler (University of Washington, Seattle, WA), Katherine Magnuson (0000-0002-1140-1200, University of Wisconsin, Madison, WI), Rui Yang (0000-0002-2036-0156, New York University, New York, NY), Andrew Koepp (0000-0002-6976-8507, Harvard University, Cambridge, MA), Jack P Shonkoff (Harvard University, Cambridge, MA)
Year2017
Volume46
Issue8
Pages474-487
Publication date2017-11-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueEducational Researcher (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0013-189X • E-ISSN: 1935-102X
PublisherAmerican Educational Research Association (AERA) (PUBLISHER)
DOI10.3102/0013189x17737739
PMID30147124
OpenAlexW2771056400
LanguageEN
Citations received91
References cited39

Despite calls to expand early childhood education (ECE) in the United States, questions remain regarding its medium- and long-term impacts on educational outcomes. We use meta-analysis of 22 high-quality experimental and quasi-experimental studies conducted between 1960 and 2016 to find that on average, participation in ECE leads to statistically significant reductions in special education placement ( d = 0.33 SD , 8.1 percentage points) and grade retention ( d = 0.26 SD , 8.3 percentage points) and increases in high school graduation rates ( d = 0.24 SD , 11.4 percentage points). These results support ECE's utility for reducing education-related expenditures and promoting child well-being

Academic achievement · Developmental psychology · Early childhood · Early childhood education · Economics · Grade retention · Graduation (instrument · Mathematics education · Medium term · Physics · Sociology · Term (time · Demography · Early Childhood Education and Development · Family and Disability Support Research · Mathematics · Parental Involvement in Education · Psychology

  • Do children benefit from universal early childhood education and care? A meta-analysis of evidence from natural experiments

    Open Access•Thomas Van Huizen, Janneke Plantenga•Economics of Education Review•2018

  • Persistence and Fade-Out of Educational-Intervention Effects

    Open Access•Drew H Bailey, Greg J Duncan et al.•Psychological Science in the…•2020

  • Place-based Social Determinants of Health Associated with Multiple Early Childhood Educational Outcomes

    Open Access•Christopher Cambron, Alysse Melville Loomis et al.•Early Childhood Education Journal•2026

  • Associations Between Classroom Quality, Child Self-Regulation, and Psychological Adjustment in Early Childhood ́

    Open Access•Vera Coelho, Helena Azevedo et al.•Early Childhood Education Journal•2026

  • How to Support “Little Engineers

    Open Access•Dana DeMaster, Tricia A Zucker et al.•Early Childhood Education Journal•2026

  • Special Education Outcomes for Students Attending a State-Funded Pre-K Program

    Open Access•Easton Stone Dawson, E Manasvi Dawson et al.•Educational Evaluation and Policy…•2026

  • The Effects of Public Pre-K for 3-Year-Olds on Early Elementary Public School Enrollment

    Open Access•Breno Braga, Justin B Doromal et al.•Educational Evaluation and Policy…•2026

  • Early opportunities and fourth-grade success

    Open Access•Andrew Pendola, Ismael G Muñoz et al.•Education Policy Analysis Archives•2022

  • The educational effects of children's museums on cognitive development

    Open Access•Fei Tan, Xin Gong et al.•International Journal of…•2021

  • Supporting Young Children Exposed to Potentially Traumatic Events

    Open Access•Caroline P Martin, Jaclyn Russo et al.•Policy Insights from the…•2021

  • Back to Basics

    Open Access•Emily Hanno, Stephanie M Jones et al.•Policy Insights from the…•2021

  • Children's activities, parental concerns, and child care service utilization in the early stages of the Covid-19 pandemic

    Open Access•Jasmine Zhang, Jackson A Smith et al.•Frontiers in Public Health•2023

  • Mini-Review on Capacity-Building for Data-Driven Early Childhood Systems

    Open Access•Alanagh Raikes, Rebecca Sayre et al.•Frontiers in Public Health•2021

  • Mathematics Teachers’ Pedagogical Content Knowledge in Strengthening Conceptual Understanding in Students with Learning Disabilities

    Open Access•Friggita Johnson, Finita G Roy•Education Sciences•2026

  • Kindergarten through Grade 3 Outcomes Associated with Participation in High-Quality Early Care and Education

    Open Access•Diane Horm, Shinyoung Jeon et al.•Education Sciences•2022

  • How Teaching Practices Relate to Early Mathematics Competencies

    Open Access•Yixiao Dong, Douglas H Clements et al.•Education Sciences•2025

  • Research and Pedagogies for Early Math

    Open Access•Douglas H Clements, Renee Lizcano et al.•Education Sciences•2023

  • Reimagining early childhood education and school readiness through the perspectives of historically marginalized families living in a rural community

    Open Access•Liz Nigro, Allison Rae Ward-Seidel•Contemporary Issues in Early…•2024

  • Does thrive by three , a quality-building intervention in childcare centres, strengthen children’s language skills

    Open Access•Ratib Lekhal, May-Britt Drugli et al.•European Early Childhood…•2024

  • Do Early Care and Education Programs Improve When Enrolled in Quality Rating and Improvement Systems? Longitudinal Evidence from One System

    Celia J Gomez, Anamarie Whitaker et al.•Early Education and Development•2023

  • Maternal education and early childhood development

    Open Access•Mohammad Al-Masaeid, Mohammad Almomani et al.•Health Education•2026

  • More than just a home

    Open Access•Mohammad Al-Masaeid, Mohammad Almomani et al.•Health Education•2026

  • Do early childhood education, stimulation, and caregiver distress associate with child development outcomes differentially by gender? A household survey in Pakistan

    Open Access•Emily Franchett, Amer Hasan et al.•Early Childhood Research Quarterly•2026

  • Promoting Motor Skill Development and Social-Emotional Learning among Preschoolers in Physical Education

    Meghan Phillips, Emi Tsuda et al.•Journal of Physical Education…•2023

  • Where can childcare expansion increase maternal labor supply? A comparison of quasi-experimental estimates from seven countries

    Open Access•Ágnes Szabó-Morvai, Anna Lovasz•Empirical Economics•2024

  • Effects of professional development in family daycare

    Open Access•Louise Beuchert, Jens Dietrichson et al.•Economics of Education Review•2026

  • ‘Piecing things together as best we can’

    Jennifer Marino, Jonathan Marino et al.•Journal of Education Policy•2026

  • Psychometric Properties of Measures to Assess Pre‐School Children's Literacy and Mathematics Developmental Skills

    Open Access•Chuang Wang, Qiao Liu et al.•European Journal of Education•2026

  • Use of Quasi-Experimental Research Designs in Education Research

    Open Access•Maithreyi Gopalan, Kelly Ochs Rosinger et al.•Review of Research in Education•2020

  • The benefits of prekindergarten programs

    Open Access•Anna Shapiro•Phi Delta Kappan•2021

  • Early Childhood Education Interventions for Racially Minoritized Children

    Open Access•Iheoma U Iruka, Jenille Morgan et al.•Journal of Education•2025

  • Immigrant Children and Families

    Christine M Mcwayne, Gigliana Melzi•The Educational Forum•2024

  • Medium-term protective effects of quality early childhood education during the Covid-19 pandemic in Ghana

    Open Access•Sharon Wolf, Elisabetta Aurino et al.•Child Development•2022

  • Global estimates of the implications of Covid-19-related preprimary school closures for children’s instructional access, development, learning, and economic wellbeing

    Open Access•Dana Charles Mccoy, Jorge Cuartas et al.•Child Development•2021

  • Adult outcomes of sustained high-quality early child care and education

    Open Access•Andres S Bustamante, Eric Dearing et al.•Child Development•2022

  • The Grade-Level and Cumulative Outcomes of Absenteeism

    Open Access•Arya Ansari, Michael A Gottfried•Child Development•2021

  • Does early childhood education help to improve high school outcomes? Results from Tulsa

    Open Access•Sara Amadon, Lance B Coleman et al.•Child Development•2022

  • The Effects of Enrolling in Oversubscribed Prekindergarten Programs Through Third Grade

    Open Access•Christina Weiland, Rebecca Unterman et al.•Child Development•2020

  • Society to cell

    Open Access•Kim L Schmidt, Sarah M Merrill et al.•Developmental Review•2021

  • The Early Childhood Care and Education Landscape in Ascending Neighborhoods

    Open Access•Agustina Laurito, Jennifer Candipan et al.•Urban Affairs Review•2026

  • Associations between a preschool tuition credit and children’s school success outcomes

    Open Access•Vi Nhuan Le, Vi-Nhuan Le et al.•Early Childhood Research Quarterly•2025

  • Long-term associations between early childhood education and academic achievement in two low- and middle-income countries

    Open Access•Laura Betancur, Elizabeth Votruba‐drzal et al.•International Journal of…•2025

  • Exploring the role of ecological systems and intersectionality in shaping the academic performance of Chinese adolescents

    Open Access•Xu Kang, Xixi Kang et al.•Children and Youth Services Review•2025

  • Promoting Equity in Access to Quality Early Childhood Education in China

    Open Access•Nirmala Rao, Yi Yang et al.•Children•2023

  • An Educational Game to Teach Children about Air Quality Using Augmented Reality and Tangible Interaction with Sensors

    Open Access•João Fernandes, João Filipe Fernandes et al.•International Journal of…•2023

  • Academic Achievement in Spanish Secondary School Students

    Open Access•Elena Escolano-Pérez, Marta Bestué•International Journal of…•2021

  • Long-term effects of integrated student support

    Courtney Pollack, Jordan L Lawson et al.•Applied Developmental Science•2024

  • Classroom composition and quality in early childhood education

    Open Access•Ana Lúcia Aguiar, Cecília Aguiar•Children and Youth Services Review•2020

  • Early Education and Adult Health

    Open Access•Nishank Varshney, Judy A Temple et al.•Journal of Benefit-Cost Analysis•2022

  • Unlevel Playing Field

    Open Access•Deniz Karaoğlan, Meltem Dayıoğlu et al.•Child Indicators Research•2024

  • I know we need to be regulated, but I don't think this is the right way”

    Open Access•Arif Mahmud, Åsa Melander•Journal of Early Childhood Research•2025

  • California’s push for universal pre-K

    Open Access•Abigail Slovick, Bruce Fuller et al.•Journal of Early Childhood Research•2023

  • Heading for burnout

    Open Access•Carla Solvason, Samantha Sutton‐Tsang et al.•Journal of Early Childhood Research•2025

  • Tracing the evolution of preschool’s impact on education over a century

    Open Access•H Cebolla-Boado, Dulce Manzano•European Societies•2025

  • Age of entry into early childhood education and care, literacy and reduction of educational inequality in Nordic countries

    Open Access•Markus Laaninen, Nevena Kulic et al.•European Societies•2024

  • Adding family math to the equation

    Open Access•Jane M Young, Kristen Reed et al.•Early Childhood Research Quarterly•2022

  • Effects of New Jersey's Abbott preschool program on children's achievement, grade retention, and special education through tenth grade

    Open Access•W Steven Barnett, Kwanghee Jung•Early Childhood Research Quarterly•2021

  • Do Prekindergarten benchmarks affect fourth-grade academic outcomes

    Open Access•Zhiling Meng Shea•Early Childhood Research Quarterly•2021

  • Impact of the Chicago universal pre-kindergarten expansion

    Open Access•Kathryn Gonzalez, Terri J Sabol et al.•Early Childhood Research Quarterly•2024

  • Maternal and non-maternal care in infancy and later child cognitive, language and motor development in Chile

    Open Access•Marigen Narea, Claudio O Toppelberg et al.•Early Childhood Research Quarterly•2019

  • Advice networks in early childhood education

    Open Access•Travis Cramer, Elise Cappella et al.•Early Childhood Research Quarterly•2023

  • The impacts of Abecedarian and Head Start on educational attainment

    Open Access•Remy Pages, Drew H Bailey et al.•Early Childhood Research Quarterly•2023

  • Benefits of pre-kindergarten for children in Baltimore, MD

    Open Access•Brenda Jones Harden, Bonnie E Brett et al.•Early Childhood Research Quarterly•2023

  • Increasing access in the ECE enrollment process

    Open Access•Lindsay Bell Weixler, Jon Valant et al.•Early Childhood Research Quarterly•2024

  • From preschool to politics

    Open Access•Karin E Kitchens, William T Gormley et al.•Early Childhood Research Quarterly•2022

  • Universal preschool and cognitive skills – the role of school starting age as a moderating factor

    Open Access•Ágnes Szabó-Morvai, Daniel Horn et al.•Early Childhood Research Quarterly•2023

  • Long-term effects of China’s One Village One Preschool program on elementary academic achievement

    Open Access•Si Chen, Chen Zhao et al.•Early Childhood Research Quarterly•2019

  • Commentary

    Open Access•Arya Ansari, Kelly M Purtell•Early Childhood Research Quarterly•2018

  • Elucidating linkages of executive functioning to school readiness skill gains

    Open Access•Khara L P Turnbull, Jamie Decoster et al.•Early Childhood Research Quarterly•2024

  • Compulsory kindergarten education and early teenage literacy in the Philippines

    Open Access•Michael R M Abrigo, Kris Francisco et al.•International Journal of…•2024

  • Do increases in national-level preschool enrollment increase student achievement? Evidence from international assessments

    Open Access•Rolf Strietholt, Nina Hogrebe et al.•International Journal of…•2020

  • Early childhood education and care in South America — a new curricular wave

    Jenifer Guevara, Alejandra Cardini•Journal of Education Policy•2023

  • Building a unified system for universal Pre-K

    Open Access•Jeanne L Reid, Samantha A Melvin et al.•Children and Youth Services Review•2019

  • Dosage Effects in the Child-Parent Center PreK-to-3rd Grade Program

    Open Access•Suh‐Ruu Ou, Irma Arteaga et al.•Children and Youth Services Review•2019

  • Factors affecting multi-stakeholders perspectives towards inclusive early childhood education (Iece) in Kazakhstan

    Open Access•Filiz Polat, Mehmet Karakus et al.•Children and Youth Services Review•2023

  • Effects of attending preschool on adolescents’ reading literacy

    Open Access•Ling Li, Xu Chen et al.•Children and Youth Services Review•2020

  • Evaluating implementation strategies in a community model to facilitate early identification and treatment of developmental and social-emotional problems in young children in out-of-home placement

    Open Access•Lauren Brookman-Frazee, Lauren Brookman‐Frazee et al.•Children and Youth Services Review•2018

  • Educational growth trajectories in adulthood

    Open Access•Suh‐Ruu Ou, Sangok Yoo et al.•Developmental Psychology•2021

  • Year 3 follow-up of the ‘Quality Preschool for Ghana’ interventions on child development

    Sharon Wolf•Developmental Psychology•2019

  • Preschool and kindergarten impacts of the Midwest Expansion of the Child–Parent Centers in the Saint Paul Public Schools

    Open Access•Arthur J Reynolds, Brandt A Richardson et al.•Developmental Psychology•2021

  • Can Early Childhood Education Cultivate More Engaged Citizens in Midlife? Findings From Urban Youth of Color

    Open Access•Suh‐Ruu Ou, Sangok Yoo et al.•Education and Urban Society•2026

  • Impacts of the Preschool Safe Program on Marginalized Girls in Northern Nigeria

    Open Access•Sharon Wolf, Johanna Bernard et al.•Child Development•2025

  • Racial Inequities in Educational Opportunity

    Open Access•R L Coley, Naoka Carey et al.•Race and Social Problems•2024

  • Segregating Gotham’s Youngest

    Open Access•Douglas D Ready, Jeanne L Reid•American Educational Research…•2023

  • A Nationwide Multidimensional Examination of Early Care and Education Access

    Gerilyn Slicker, Alex Faucheux et al.•Early Education and Development•2025

  • Childcare Center Attendance During the Covid-19 Pandemic

    Open Access•Marigen Narea, Pamela Soto-Ramírez et al.•Child Development•2025

  • Who Cares if Parents have Unpredictable Work Schedules

    Open Access•K Harknett, Daniel Schneider et al.•Social Problems•2022

  • Help and Solidarity Interactions in Interactive Groups

    Open Access•Andrea Khalfaoui, Rocío García-Carrión et al.•Social Sciences•2020

  • O efeito do ingresso na Educação Infantil sobre o desempenho escolar de estudantes no Brasil

    Open Access•Hellen Cristina Araujo Penha, Danilo Soares Monte-Mor et al.•Estudos Avançados•2025

  • Education policy reform and the impact of free preschool education on boys' and girls' reading competence

    Open Access•María Ladrón De Guevara Rodríguez, L A Lopez-Agudo et al.•International Social Science…•2024

  • Examining Certification Requirements in Early Math and Literacy

    Open Access•Tanya S Wright, Amy Noelle Parks et al.•Journal of Teacher Education•2021

  • From Neurons to Neighborhoods

    Deborah Phillips, Jack P Shonkoff•From neurons to neighborhoods•2000

  • Introduction to Meta‐Analysis

    Open Access•Michael Borenstein, Larry V Hedges et al.•Introduction to Meta-Analysis•2009

  • The Handbook of Research Synthesis and Meta-Analysis

    Harris M Cooper, Jeff C Valentine et al.•Handbook of Research Synthesis…•2019

  • Persistence and Fadeout in the Impacts of Child and Adolescent Interventions

    Drew H Bailey, Drew Bailey et al.•Journal of Research on…•2017

  • The rate of return to the HighScope Perry Preschool Program

    Open Access•James J Heckman, Seong Hyeok Moon et al.•Journal of Public Economics•2010

  • A Propensity Score Matching Analysis of the Effects of Special Education Services

    Open Access•Paul L Morgan, Michelle L Frisco et al.•The Journal of Special Education•2010

  • Meta-Analysis of the Effects of Early Education Interventions on Cognitive and Social Development

    Open Access•Gregory Camilli, Sadako Vargas et al.•Teachers College Record The Voice…•2010

  • Comparative benefit–cost analysis of the Abecedarian program and its policy implications

    Open Access•W Steven Barnett, Leonard N Masse•Economics of Education Review•2007

  • The High/Scope Perry Preschool Program

    Clive R Belfield, Clive Belfield et al.•The Journal of Human Resources•2006

  • School-Based Early Childhood Education and Age-28 Well-Being

    Open Access•Arthur J Reynolds, Judy A Temple et al.•Science•2011

  • Lasting Effects of Early Education

    Irving Lazar, Richard B Darlington et al.•Monographs of the Society for…•1982

  • Does Head Start Improve Children's Life Chances? Evidence from a Regression Discontinuity Design

    Jens Ludwig, Douglas L Miller•The Quarterly Journal of Economics•2007

  • From 3 to 20

    Open Access•Francis H Palmer•Developmental Review•1983

  • Persistent Effects of Early Childhood Education on High-Risk Children and Their Mothers

    Craig T Ramey, Frances A Campbell et al.•Applied Developmental Science•2000

  • Long-Term Effects of Early Childhood Programs on Cognitive and School Outcomes

    W Steven Barnett•The Future of Children•1995

  • Long-Term Effects of Early Childhood Programs on Social Outcomes and Delinquency

    Hirokazu Yoshikawa•The Future of Children•1995

  • Do the effects of early childhood education programs differ by gender? A meta-analysis

    Open Access•Katherine Magnuson, Robert Kelchen et al.•Early Childhood Research Quarterly•2016

  • One year of preschool intervention or two

    Open Access•Arthur J Reynolds•Early Childhood Research Quarterly•1995

  • Early childhood care and education

    Open Access•William T Gormley, William T Gormley Jr•Journal of Policy Analysis and…•2007

  • Social Programs That Work

    Open Access•Paul Light, Paul C Light•Journal of Policy Analysis and…•1999

  • Preschool education, educational attainment, and crime prevention

    Open Access•Arthur J Reynolds, Judy A Temple et al.•Children and Youth Services Review•2010

  • The effects of Tulsa’s CAP Head Start program on middle-school academic outcomes and progress

    Deborah Phillips, Deborah A Phillips et al.•Developmental Psychology•2016

  • Adult outcomes as a function of an early childhood educational program

    Frances A Campbell, Elizabeth P Pungello et al.•Developmental Psychology•2012

  • Developmental Cascades

    Ann S Masten, Glenn I Roisman et al.•Developmental Psychology•2005

  • Race, Class, and Disproportionality

    Open Access•Carla O’connor, Sonia DeLuca Fernandez•Educational Researcher•2006

  • Patterns and Trends in Grade Retention Rates in the United States, 1995–2010

    Open Access•J R Warren, Emily P Hoffman et al.•Educational Researcher•2014

  • Organizational Factors and Educational Outcome

    Open Access•Ellen Handler•Education and Urban Society•1972

  • Understanding the Mechanisms Through Which an Influential Early Childhood Program Boosted Adult Outcomes

    James J Heckman, James Heckman et al.•American Economic Review•2013

  • Early Childhood Education

    Frances A Campbell, Craig T Ramey et al.•Applied Developmental Science•2002

  • Early Childhood Education Programs

    Open Access•Janet Currie, Janet M Currie•The Journal of Economic…•2001

Unique citing works91
Citations per year11,38
Citation span2018 - 2026 (9)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 91

Tools

Open DOISci-HubOpen Access
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae