Uncertainty in the Context of School and Teacher Education in Educational Science Literature—A Systematic Review

Bibliographic Data

ID21380973
AuthorsIngrid Bähr (0000-0002-5857-3042), Britta Lübke (0000-0002-3876-8870), Kerstin Michalik (0000-0003-0258-7688), Teresa Berding, Ioana Chiotoroiu, Melissa Hanke (0000-0001-9652-8958), Telse Iwers, Dagmar Killus (0000-0003-2121-7703), Claus Krieger (0000-0003-2960-5305, corresponding author), Jessica Kruska, Julia Schwanewedel (0009-0005-5321-5093), Sandra Sprenger (0000-0002-9599-8103), Ole Stabick (0000-0002-5728-699X), Constanze Struck (0009-0003-4601-9831, Universität Hamburg), Merve Yilmaz (0000-0001-5682-7136, Gymnasium Bondenwald Hamburg), Merve Nur Yilmaz, Andreas Bonnet (0000-0003-2749-0698), Angelika Paseka (0000-0002-0656-9113, Universität Hamburg)
Year2026
Publication date2026-01-31
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueReview of Educational Research (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0034-6543 • E-ISSN: 1935-1046
PublisherAmerican Educational Research Association (AERA) (PUBLISHER)
DOI10.3102/00346543251404456
OpenAlexW7126375769
LanguageEN
References cited113

Although uncertainty has gained increasing attention in education, to date, existing research on the topic has not been collated. Therefore, this systematic review sought to understand which range of phenomena, terms, and theoretical conceptualizations of uncertainty are found in the education research literature in the context of school and teacher education. A systematic search of publications (2005–2020) in the two most widely used publication languages in the social sciences (English and German) yielded an initial sample of n initial = 3,847 publications. The rigorous application of four inclusion criteria reduced that number to n final = 201. Synthesis revealed four types of uncertainty: disciplinary uncertainty addressed by subject-specific curricular research, individual uncertainty addressed by teacher knowledge research, interactional uncertainty addressed by classroom research, and contextual uncertainty addressed by school research. The review found a fundamental contradiction: While many theoretical publications constitute uncertainty as something to be taken into account and addressed, empirical papers found widespread camouflaging or eradication of uncertainty in educational practices. The presented conceptual scheme and findings will hopefully inspire future work into uncertainty in education

Context (archaeology) · Discipline · Educational research · Inclusion (mineral) · Range (aeronautics) · Teacher education · Work (physics) · Educational Assessment and Improvement · Educational Strategies and Epistemologies · Educational Theory and Curriculum Studies

Tools

Open DOIOpen Access