Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Distinction Bias

Misprediction and Mischoice Due to Joint Evaluation

Bibliographic Data

ID6203372
AuthorsChristopher K Hsee (0000-0002-8391-7847, University of Chicago), Jiao Zhang (0000-0002-6466-6384), Jianyu Zhang (0000-0002-5213-7063, University of Chicago)
Year2004
Volume86
Issue5
Pages680-695
Publication date2004-01-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessNo
TypeARTICLE
VenueJournal of Personality and Social Psychology (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0022-3514 • E-ISSN: 1939-1315
PublisherAmerican Psychological Association (APA) (PUBLISHER)
DOI10.1037/0022-3514.86.5.680
PMID15161394
OpenAlexW2139560547
LanguageEN
Citations received48
References cited77

This research identifies a new source of failure to make accurate affective predictions or to make experientially optimal choices. When people make predictions or choices, they are often in the joint evaluation (JE) mode; when people actually experience an event, they are often in the single evaluation (SE) mode. The "utility function" of an attribute can vary systematically between SE and JE. When people in JE make predictions or choices for events to be experienced in SE, they often resort to their JE preferences rather than their SE preferences and overpredict the difference that different values of an attribute (e.g., different salaries) will make to their happiness in SE. This overprediction is referred to as the distinction bias. The present research also specifies when the distinction bias occurs and when it does not. This research contributes to literatures on experienced utility, affective forecasting, and happiness

Econometrics · Economics · Event (particle physics) · Function (biology) · Happiness · Joint (building) · Mode (computer interface) · Positive economics · Behavioral Health and Interventions · Computer Science · Decision-Making and Behavioral Economics · Forecasting Techniques and Applications · Psychology · Social Psychology

  • Well-Being for Public Policy

    Ed Diener, Richard E Lucas et al.•Well-being for public policy•2009

  • Mindful Judgment and Decision Making

    Elke U Weber, E Johnson•Annual Review of Psychology•2009

  • General Evaluability Theory

    Open Access•Christopher K Hsee, Jiao Zhang•Perspectives on Psychological…•2010

  • The Relationship Between Size of Living Space and Subjective Well-Being

    Open Access•Chris Foye•Journal of Happiness Studies•2017

  • Experimental methods

    Open Access•Gary Charne, Gary Charness et al.•Journal of Economic Behavior &…•2012

  • Preference Reversals Between Joint and Separate Evaluations With Multiple Alternatives and Context Effects

    Open Access•Yin-Hui Cheng, Yin‐Hui Cheng et al.•Psychological Reports•2017

  • Motivational processes

    Open Access•Nikos L D Chatzisarantis, Sviatlana Kamarova et al.•SN Social Sciences•2024

  • Role of Threat and Coping Appraisal in Protection Motivation for Adoption of Preventive Behavior During Covid-19 Pandemic

    Open Access•Arista Lahiri, Sweety Suman Jha et al.•Frontiers in Public Health•2021

  • Transformative Experiences, Cognitive Modelling and Affective Forecasting

    Open Access•Marvin Mathony, Michael Messerli•Erkenntnis•2024

  • Whose Words Hurt? Contextual Determinants of Offensive Speech

    Open Access•Manuel Almagro, Ivar R Hannikainen et al.•Personality and Social Psychology…•2022

  • Outcome effects, moral luck and the hindsight bias

    Open Access•Markus Kneer, Izabela Skoczeń•Cognition•2023

  • Do claims about certainty make estimates less certain

    Open Access•Karl Halvor Teigen, Marie Juanchich•Cognition•2024

  • Are ‘nudges’ getting a fair shot? Joint versus separate evaluation

    Open Access•Shai Davidai, Eldar Shafir•Behavioural Public Policy•2018

  • Weighing Open Science Against Research Participation Burden in Informed Consent

    Open Access•Renata Iskander, Patrick Bodilly Kane et al.•Journal of Empirical Research on…•2025

  • Pleasure in decision‐making situations

    Marie‐Claude Bonniot‐Cabanac, Michel Cabanac•Journal of Risk Research•2009

  • Overpredicting and Underprofiting in Pricing Decisions

    Open Access•Luxi Shen, Christopher K Hsee et al.•Journal of Behavioral Decision…•2011

  • The role of negative features in joint and separate evaluation

    Open Access•Martijn C Willemsen, Gideon Keren•Journal of Behavioral Decision…•2004

  • Evaluating Effort

    Open Access•Timothy L Dunn, Derek J Koehler et al.•Journal of Behavioral Decision…•2017

  • Preference for quicker offers

    Open Access•Chao Lei, Pengcheng Zhang et al.•Journal of Behavioral Decision…•2023

  • The susceptibility of mental accounting principles to evaluation mode effects

    Open Access•Subimal Chatterjee, Timothy B Heath et al.•Journal of Behavioral Decision…•2008

  • The autonomy‐validity dilemma in mechanical prediction procedures

    Open Access•Marvin Neumann, A Susan M Niessen et al.•Journal of Behavioral Decision…•2021

  • The effect of time on pleasure with chosen outcomes

    Open Access•Ilana Ritov•Journal of Behavioral Decision…•2006

  • Evaluation nudge

    Open Access•Huimin Tan, Xingyang Lv et al.•Tourism Management•2017

  • Considering the Situation

    Emily Balcetis, David Dunning•Self and Identity•2011

  • Building and Testing Theories

    Ying-Yi Hong, Melody Manchi Chao et al.•Acta Psychologica Sinica•2010

  • The generality of the emotion effect on magnitude sensitivity

    Open Access•Min Gong, Jonathan Baron•Journal of Economic Psychology•2011

  • Preference reversals in evaluations of cash versus non-cash incentives

    Open Access•Victoria A Shaffer, Hal R Arkes•Journal of Economic Psychology•2009

  • Disentangling motivational and experiential aspects of “utility” – A neuroeconomics perspective

    Open Access•Ulrich Witt, Martin Binder•Journal of Economic Psychology•2013

  • Consuming Regardless of Preference

    Open Access•Heeyoung Yoon, Tom Meyvis et al.•Journal of Consumer Research•2024

  • Price it High if it is Varied

    Open Access•Xia Wei, Shubin Yu et al.•Travel Research Bulletin•2025

  • How the evaluability bias shapes transformative decisions

    Open Access•Yoonseo Zoh, Lisa A Paul et al.•Synthese•2024

  • Misprediction of affective outcomes due to different evaluation modes

    Open Access•Farid Anvari, Jerome Olsen et al.•Journal of Experimental Social…•2020

  • Probability as a psychological distance

    Open Access•Antony Todorov, Alexander Todorov et al.•Journal of Experimental Social…•2006

  • To build efficacy, eat the frog first

    Open Access•Rachel Habbert, Jonathan Schroeder•Journal of Experimental Social…•2020

  • Quantity versus uncertainty

    Open Access•Jaime L Kurtz, Timothy D Wilson et al.•Journal of Experimental Social…•2006

  • Consuming experience

    Open Access•Carey K Morewedge, Daniel T Gilbert et al.•Journal of Experimental Social…•2010

  • Effects of achievement goals on perceptions of competence in conditions of unfavourable social comparisons

    Open Access•Sviatlana Kamarova, Nikos L D Chatzisarantis et al.•British Journal of Educational…•2017

  • Past and future regret and missed opportunities

    Open Access•Luisa Papé, Luis Fructuoso Martinez•Psicologia Reflexão e Crítica•2017

  • Advancing Our Understanding of Culture Mixing

    Open Access•Jia Hao, Dongmei Li et al.•Journal of Cross-Cultural…•2016

  • Perceptions of Culture in Multicultural Space

    Open Access•Chi-Yue Chiu, Chi‐yue Chiu et al.•Journal of Cross-Cultural…•2009

  • Obligatory Publicity Increases Charitable Acts

    Open Access•Adelle X Yang, Adelle Yang et al.•Journal of Consumer Research•2022

  • Overindividuation in Gift Giving

    Mary Steffel, Robyn A Le Boeuf•Journal of Consumer Research•2014

  • Magnitude, Time, and Risk Differ Similarly between Joint and Single Evaluations

    Christopher K Hsee, Jiao Zhang et al.•Journal of Consumer Research•2013

  • The Effect of Attribute Alignability on Service Evaluation

    Jin Sun, Hean Tat Keh et al.•Journal of Consumer Research•2012

  • The Zero-Comparison Effect

    Mauricio M Palmeira, Mauricio Palmeira•Journal of Consumer Research•2011

  • When Mental Simulation Hinders Behavior

    Debora Viana Thompson, Rebecca W Hamilton et al.•Journal of Consumer Research•2009

  • Specification Seeking

    Christopher K Hsee, Yang et al.•Journal of Consumer Research•2009

  • Is There a Substitute for Direct Experience? Comparing Consumers' Preferences after Direct and Indirect Product Experiences

    Rebecca W Hamilton, Debora Viana Thompson•Journal of Consumer Research•2007

  • Happiness and Economics

    Bruno S Frey, Alois Stutzer•Happiness and Economics•2002

  • The Evolving Concept of Subjective Well-Being

    Ed Diener, Christie Napa Scollon et al.•Assessing Well-Being•2009

  • Music, Pandas, and Muggers

    Christopher K Hsee, Yuval Rottenstreich•Journal of Experimental…•2004

  • Economic Preferences or Attitude Expressions?

    Open Access•Daniel Kahneman, Ilana Ritov et al.•Journal of Risk and Uncertainty•1999

  • Integrating The Diverse Definitions of Happiness

    Open Access•Chu Kim-Prieto, Chu Kim‐prieto et al.•Journal of Happiness Studies•2005

  • A fundamental prediction error

    Christopher K Hsee, Elke U Weber•Journal of Experimental…•1997

  • The simulation heuristic

    Open Access•Daniel Kahneman, Amos Tversky•Judgment under uncertainty•1982

  • Internal Consistency of Choice

    Amartya Sen•Econometrica•1993

  • The Evaluability Hypothesis

    Open Access•Christopher K Hsee•Organizational Behavior and Human…•1996

  • Fairness and the Assumptions of Economics

    Daniel Kahneman, Jack L Knetsch et al.•The Journal of Business•1986

  • Contingent weighting in judgment and choice.

    Amos Tversky, Shmuel Sattath et al.•Psychological Review•1988

  • Does Living in California Make People Happy? A Focusing Illusion in Judgments of Life Satisfaction

    Open Access•David Schkade, David A Schkade et al.•Psychological Science•1998

  • Predicting Hunger

    Open Access•Daniel Read, Barbara van Leeuwen•Organizational Behavior and Human…•1998

  • Intransitivity of preferences.

    Amos Tversky•Psychological Review•1969

  • Out of Control

    Open Access•G Loewenstein•Organizational Behavior and Human…•1996

  • Back to Bentham? Explorations of Experienced Utility

    Daniel Kahneman, Peter P Wakker et al.•The Quarterly Journal of Economics•1997

  • Judgment under Uncertainty

    Amos Tversky, Daniel Kahneman•Utility, Probability, and Human…•1975

  • Prospect Theory

    Daniel Kahneman, Amos Tversky•Econometrica•1979

  • Positive psychology

    Martin E P Seligman, Mihaly Csikszentmihalyi•American Psychologist•2000

  • Does Economic Growth Improve the Human Lot? Some Empirical Evidence

    Open Access•Richard A Easterlin•Nations and households in…•1974

  • On Happiness and Human Potentials

    Richard M Ryan, Edward L Deci•Annual Review of Psychology•2001

  • Positive psychology

    Martin E P Seligman, Mihaly Csikszentmihalyi•American Psychologist•2000

  • Preference reversals between joint and separate evaluations of options

    Chrisopher K Hsee, G Loewenstein et al.•Psychological Bulletin•1999

  • Lay rationalism and inconsistency between predicted experience and decision

    Open Access•Christopher K Hsee, Jiao Zhang et al.•Journal of Behavioral Decision…•2003

  • Predicting a changing taste

    Open Access•Daniel Kahneman, Jackie Snell•Journal of Behavioral Decision…•1992

  • Less is better

    Open Access•Christopher K Hsee•Journal of Behavioral Decision…•1998

  • The role of negative features in joint and separate evaluation

    Open Access•Martijn C Willemsen, Gideon Keren•Journal of Behavioral Decision…•2004

  • Globalisierung ohne Weltregierung

    Open Access•Bruno S Frey•Analyse & Kritik•2003

  • Strategy and Choice

    Harrison C White, Richard J Zeckhauser•Contemporary Sociology A Journal…•1992

  • Predictably Incoherent Judgments

    Cass R Sunstein, Daniel Kahneman et al.•Stanford Law Review•2002

  • Income and Happiness

    Open Access•Richard A Easterlin•The Economic Journal•2001

  • Happiness, Economy and Institutions

    Open Access•Bruno S Frey, Alois Stutzer•The Economic Journal•2000

  • The Frame of Reference as a Public Good

    Open Access•Robert H Frank•The Economic Journal•1997

  • Cancellation and Focus

    Open Access•David A Houston, Steven J Sherman•Journal of Experimental Social…•1995

  • The disruptive effects of explaining attitudes

    Open Access•Timothy D Wilson, Dolores Kraft et al.•Journal of Experimental Social…•1989

  • Subjective well-being

    Ed Diener•American Psychologist•2000

  • On the self-erasing nature of errors of prediction

    Steven J Sherman•Journal of Personality and Social…•1980

  • Thinking too much

    Timothy D Wilson, Jonathan W Schooler•Journal of Personality and Social…•1991

  • Focalism

    Timothy D Wilson, Thalia Wheatley et al.•Journal of Personality and Social…•2000

  • Multiple explanation

    Edward R Hirt, Keith D Markman•Journal of Personality and Social…•1995

  • Immune neglect

    Daniel T Gilbert, Elizabeth C Pinel et al.•Journal of Personality and Social…•1998

  • Lottery winners and accident victims

    Philip Brickman, Dan Coates et al.•Journal of Personality and Social…•1978

  • Subjective well-being

    Ed Diener, Eunkook M Suh et al.•Psychological Bulletin•1999

  • Counterfactual thinking

    Neal J Roese•Psychological Bulletin•1997

  • Medium Maximization

    Christopher K Hsee, Fang Yu et al.•Journal of Consumer Research•2003

  • The Time Course and Impact of Consumers' Erroneous Beliefs about Hedonic Contrast Effects

    Nathan Novemsky, Rebecca K Ratner•Journal of Consumer Research•2003

  • The Role of Explanations and Need for Uniqueness in Consumer Decision Making

    Itamar Simonson, Stephen M Nowli et al.•Journal of Consumer Research•2000

  • Comparison Effects on Preference Construction

    Ravi Dhar, Stephen M Nowli et al.•Journal of Consumer Research•1999

  • Choosing Less-Preferred Experiences For the Sake of Variety

    Rebecca K Ratner, Barbara E Kahn et al.•Journal of Consumer Research•1999

  • Will Products Look More Attractive When Presented Separately Or Together

    Christopher K Hsee, France Leclerc•Journal of Consumer Research•1998

  • Life events and psychological well-being

    Open Access•Mclanahan, Sara S Mclanahan et al.•Social Science Research•1984

Unique citing works48
Citations per year2,18
Citation span2004 - 2025 (22)
Citation velocityrecent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 48

Tools

Open DOISci-HubOpen Access
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae