Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Undermining Resistance

Mobilization, Repression, and the Enforcement of Political Order

Bibliographic Data

ID6284898
AuthorsChristopher M Sullivan (0000-0003-1755-6040, Louisiana State University, Baton Rouge, LA, USA, corresponding author)
Year2016
Volume60
Issue7
Pages1163-1190
Publication date2016-10-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueJournal of Conflict Resolution (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0022-0027 • E-ISSN: 1552-8766
PublisherSAGE Publications Inc (PUBLISHER)
DOI10.1177/0022002714567951
OpenAlexW1977563459
LanguageEN
Citations received75
References cited100

This study examines attempts by authorities to undermine overt collective challenges, such as protests, riots, or armed attacks, by targeting activities that precede and/or support such behavior. After providing a theory of how repression and resistance develop, the study analyzes unique data drawn from the confidential records of the Guatemalan National Police to assess the use of repression during the years between 1975 and 1985. Empirical tests demonstrate that (1) government forces anticipate challenger development by identifying the mobilization activities nascent challengers rely on to initiate and sustain overt collective challenges and (2) the use of repression designed to undermine such efforts is specifically targeted against radical (i.e., highly transformative) claims making. Implications are drawn for how we understand and study political order and conflict

Armed conflict · Business · Confidentiality · Criminology · Empirical research · Government (linguistics · Mobilization · Order (exchange · Political economy · Political repression · Political science · Politics · Psychological repression · Public relations · Resistance (ecology · Sociology · Transformative learning · Crime, Illicit Activities, and Governance · Law · Political Conflict and Governance · Politics and Society in Latin America

  • Global Migration and Illiberalism in Russia, Eurasia, and Eastern Europe

    Open Access•Anna-Liisa Heusala, Kaarina Aitamurto et al.•Global Migration and Illiberalism…•2024

  • Reforming to Survive

    Magnus Bergli Rasmussen, Carl Henrik Knutsen•Reforming to Survive•2023

  • Repertoires of Repression

    Open Access•Prabhat Jawla•Digest of Middle East Studies•2026

  • Introducing the Turkey Protest, Repression, and Pro-Government Rally Dataset (TPRPGRD)

    Anıl Kahvecioğlu, Tijen Demirel-Pegg et al.•Journal of Southeast European and…•2023

  • How Insurgency Begins

    Open Access•Janet I Lewis•How Insurgency Begins•2020

  • Loose bricks in the wall

    Open Access•Olga Tcaci•Public Choice•2026

  • Opportunistic Repression

    Donald Grasse, Melissa Pavlik et al.•International Security•2021

  • How time horizons of autocrats impact health expenditure

    Open Access•Huang-Ting Yan, Yu-Chun Lin•BMC Public Health•2020

  • Digital manipulation and mass mobilization over the long run

    Open Access•José Ángel Alcántara‐lizárraga, Alexandra Jima-González•Frontiers in Political Science•2024

  • Social causation and protest mobilization

    Alexei Anisin•Territory Politics Governance•2017

  • Does repression work

    Victor Asal, Joseph M Brown•Dynamics of Asymmetric Conflict•2020

  • Separating Dirty War From Dirty Peace

    Open Access•Joakim Kreutz•European Political Science•2015

  • Ethnicity and Strategic Repression of Protest during the 2011 Syrian Uprising

    Open Access•Konstantin Ash, Kevin Mazur•Perspectives on Politics•2025

  • Crackdowns and coalitions

    Hannah Chesterton•Global Change Peace & Security•2023

  • Repressive agent defections

    Open Access•Kimberly R Frugé•Conflict Management and Peace…•2019

  • Failed coups, political survival, and civil liberties restrictions in nondemocratic regimes

    Laçin Idil Öztığ, Murat Donduran•The Social Science Journal•2020

  • Beyond the media’s radar

    Eitan Y Alimi, Gregory M Maney et al.•International Interactions•2019

  • Storm autocracies”

    Open Access•Muhammad Habibur Rahman, Nejat Anbarci et al.•Journal of Development Economics•2022

  • A Farewell to Arms

    Open Access•Felipe Coy•Journal of Development Economics•2024

  • The impact of China’s high-tech repression on Uyghurs

    Laçin Idil Öztığ, Abdurresit Celil Karluk•Central Asian Survey•2024

  • Whom to Repress

    Open Access•Kris De Jaegher•Journal of Conflict Resolution•2024

  • How Loyalty Trials Shape Allegiance to Political Order

    Open Access•Mirko Reul, Ravi Bhavnani•Journal of Conflict Resolution•2023

  • A Techno-Docility Approach to the Repression and Surveillance of Uyghurs

    Reyhan Topal•Asian Survey•2024

  • Counterterrorism and Preventive Repression

    Sheena Chestnut Greiten, Sheena Chestnut Greitens et al.•International Security•2020

  • Oil discoveries, civil war, and preventive state repression

    Open Access•Peter Carey, Peter D Carey et al.•Journal of Peace Research•2022

  • The Nicaragua Protest Crisis in 2018–2019

    Open Access•Graig R Klein, Jose Cuesta et al.•Journal of Politics in Latin…•2021

  • Message or Messenger? Source and Labeling Effects in Authoritarian Response to Protest

    Open Access•Daniel Arnon, Pearce Edwards et al.•Comparative Political Studies•2023

  • Political Competition and Authoritarian Repression

    Open Access•Pearce Edwards•World Politics•2022

  • Political Repression and the Destruction of Dissident Organizations

    Open Access•Christopher M Sullivan•World Politics•2016

  • The Differential Effects of “Democratic” Institutions on Dissent in Dictatorships

    Ae Sil Woo, Courtenay R Conrad•The Journal of Politics•2019

  • Preventing Dissent

    Ioannis Choulis, Abel Escribà-Folch et al.•The Journal of Politics•2024

  • Mobilization, Repression and Policy Concessions in Authoritarian Regimes

    Open Access•Nadine Sika•Political Studies•2024

  • Human Rights Violations and Post-election Protest

    Open Access•Sam R Bell, Svitlana Chernykh•Political Research Quarterly•2019

  • Subnational State Capacity and the Repression of Protest

    Open Access•Heather Sullivan•Political Research Quarterly•2021

  • The Rebel Alliance Strikes Back

    Christopher M Sullivan, Christian Davenport•Mobilization An International…•2017

  • Focal Points, Dissident Calendars, and Preemptive Repression

    Open Access•Rory Truex•Journal of Conflict Resolution•2019

  • Policing and Political Violence

    Open Access•Kristine Eck, Courtenay R Conrad et al.•Journal of Conflict Resolution•2021

  • Secret Police Organizations and State Repression

    Open Access•Marius Mehrl, Ioannis Choulis•Journal of Conflict Resolution•2024

  • Preemptive Repression

    Open Access•Kris De Jaegher, Britta Hoyer•Journal of Conflict Resolution•2019

  • Civilian Victimization and Ethnic Civil War

    Open Access•Lars-Erik Cederman, Simon Hug et al.•Journal of Conflict Resolution•2020

  • The Logic of Transitional Justice and State Repression

    Open Access•Risa Kitagawa, Sam R Bell•Journal of Conflict Resolution•2022

  • Moving the Needle

    Open Access•Jillienne Haglund, Courtney Hillebrecht•International Studies Quarterly•2024

  • Does Non-violent Repression Have Stronger Dampening Effects than State Violence? Insight from an Emotion-Based Model of Non-violent Dissent

    Open Access•Stephanie Dornschneider-Elkink, Bruce Edmonds•Government and Opposition•2024

  • Information capacity and social order

    Open Access•Huirong Chen, Sheena Chestnut Greiten•Governance•2022

  • Action repertoires in contentious episodes

    Open Access•Abel Bojar, Hanspeter Kriesi•European Journal of Political…•2021

  • The dictator’s legionnaires

    Open Access•Marius Mehrl, Abel Escribà‐folch•Democratization•2024

  • When elites concede

    Heather Sullivan•Democratization•2024

  • State Repression and Opposition Survival in Pinochet’s Chile

    Open Access•Consuelo Amat•Comparative Political Studies•2024

  • The Price of Collaboration

    Open Access•Barbara Maria Piotrowska•Comparative Political Studies•2020

  • Lost in Aggregation

    Open Access•Scott J Cook, Nils B Weidmann•American Journal of Political…•2019

  • Policing the Organizational Threat in Morocco

    Open Access•Ceil Berman, Chantal E Berman•American Journal of Political…•2021

  • Targeting the Motivated? Ethnicity and the Pre‐emptive Use of Government Repression

    Open Access•Janina Beiser‐mcgrath, Janina Beiser-Mcgrath•Swiss Political Science Review•2019

  • Civil war as a social process

    Open Access•Anastasia Shesterinina•European Journal of International…•2022

  • Big data-mediated repression

    Laçin Idil Öztığ•Contemporary Politics•2023

  • Protecting the capital? On African geographies of protest escalation and repression

    Open Access•Jessica Steinberg•Political Geography•2018

  • From snapshots to panoramas

    Open Access•Kai M Thaler, Antonia H Juelich et al.•Conflict Security and Development•2024

  • For better or worse

    Open Access•Sara Kahn-Nisser•Journal of Peace Research•2021

  • Uneven accountability in the wake of political violence

    Open Access•M Hassan, Thomas O''Mealia•Journal of Peace Research•2018

  • The diversity of repression

    Open Access•Benjamin E Bagozzi, Daniel Berliner et al.•Journal of Peace Research•2021

  • The physics of dissent and the effects of movement momentum

    Open Access•Erica Chenoweth, Margherita Belgioioso•Nature Human Behaviour•2019

  • Repressing for reputation

    Open Access•Amanda A Licht, Susan Hannah Allen•Journal of Peace Research•2018

  • Do they know something we don't? Diffusion of repression in authoritarian regimes

    Open Access•Roman-Gabriel Olar•Journal of Peace Research•2019

  • The socialization of civilians and militia members

    Open Access•Regina Bateson•Journal of Peace Research•2017

  • Resistance is mobile

    Open Access•Christopher M Sullivan, Christian Davenport•Journal of Peace Research•2018

  • New findings from conflict archives

    Open Access•Laia Bacell I Ventura, Laia Balcells et al.•Journal of Peace Research•2018

  • Repression, backlash, and the duration of protests in Africa

    Open Access•Jacob S Lewis, Burl Ives•Journal of Peace Research•2025

  • Disappearing dissent? Repression and state consolidation in Mexico

    Open Access•Javier Osorio, Livia I Schubiger et al.•Journal of Peace Research•2018

  • The politics of nonviolent mobilization

    Open Access•Pearce Edwards•Journal of Peace Research•2021

  • Going, going, gone? Varieties of dissent and leader exit

    Open Access•Kristian Skrede Gleditsch, Roman-Gabriel Olar et al.•Journal of Peace Research•2023

  • Measuring the landscape of civil war

    Open Access•Rex W Douglas, Rex W Douglass et al.•Journal of Peace Research•2018

  • How Protesters and the State Learn From One Another

    Open Access•Olga Zelinska•American Behavioral Scientist•2020

  • Why Botter

    Open Access•Denis Stukal, Sergey Sanovich et al.•American Political Science Review•2022

  • Preventing and Responding to Dissent

    Open Access•Emily Hencken Ritter, Courtenay R Conrad•American Political Science Review•2016

  • Trial by Fire

    Open Access•C Hummel•Latin American Politics and Society•2022

  • The Effects of Selective and Indiscriminate Repression on the 2013 Gezi Park Nonviolent Resistance Campaign

    Open Access•Tijen Demirel-Pegg, Karen Rasler•Sociological Perspectives•2021

  • Political Order in Changing Societies

    Samuel P Huntington•Political Order in Changing…•1969

  • The strategy of social protest

    William A Gamson•The strategy of social protest•1975

  • Power and Powerlessness

    John Gaventa•Power and Powerlessness•1982

  • Power

    Open Access•Steven Luke, Steven Lukes•Power•2005

  • Political Movements and Violence in Central America

    Open Access•Charles D Brockett•Political Movements and Violence…•2005

  • Undercover

    Gary T Marx•Undercover•1988

  • The Critical Mass in Collective Action

    Open Access•Gerald Marwell, P Oliver•Critical Mass in Collective Action•1993

  • The Politics of the Police

    Robert Reiner•The politics of the police•2010

  • Dynamics of Contention

    Open Access•Doug Mcadam, Sidney Tarrow et al.•Dynamics of Contention•2001

  • Repression And Mobilization

    Christian Davenport, Hank Johnston et al.•Repression And Mobilization•2010

  • Domination and the Arts of Resistance

    Open Access•James C Scott•On Violence•2007

  • How Social Movements Die

    Open Access•Christian Davenport, Christian A Davenport•How Social Movements Die•2014

  • The Guatemalan Military Project

    Jennifer Schirmer, Jennifer G Schirmer•Guatemalan Military Project•1999

  • Media Bias, Perspective, and State Repression

    Open Access•Christian Davenport, Christian A Davenport•Media Bias, Perspective, and…•2009

  • Paper Cadavers

    Kirsten Weld•Paper Cadavers•2020

  • The Ideology of State Terror

    David Pion-Berlin•The Ideology of State Terror•1989

  • The Logic of Political Survival

    Bruce Bueno De Mesquita, Alastair Smith et al.•The logic of political survival•2003

  • Mostly Harmless Econometrics

    Joshua D Angrist, Jorn‐steffen Pischke et al.•Mostly Harmless Econometrics•2009

  • Greed and grievance in civil war

    Paul Collier•Oxford Economic Papers•2004

  • Power in Numbers

    James Denardo•Power in Numbers•1985

  • The Logic of Collective Action

    Mancur Olson•Logic of Collective Action•1965

  • The Logic of Violence in Civil War

    Open Access•Stathis N Kalyva, Stathis N Kalyvas•Logic of Violence in Civil War•2006

  • Power

    Open Access•Steven Luke, Steven Lukes•Power•1974

  • Collective Action and the Civil Rights Movement

    Dennis Chong•Collective Action and the Civil…•1991

  • State Repression and the Domestic Democratic Peace

    Open Access•Christian Davenport, Christian A Davenport•State Repression and the Domestic…•2007

  • Buried Secrets. Truth and Human Rights in Guatemala

    Open Access•Charles R Hale•Journal of Latin American…•2004

  • Terror in the Land of the Holy Spirit

    Christopher L Chiappari•Social Sciences and Missions•2011

  • Population size, concentration, and civil war. A geographically disaggregated analysis

    Open Access•Clionadh Raleigh, Håvard Hegre•Political Geography•2009

  • Blood in the Village

    Open Access•Christopher M Sullivan•Conflict Management and Peace…•2012

  • Spatial and temporal patterns in civil violence

    Open Access•Timothy R Gulden•Politics and the Life Sciences•2002

  • The Use of Repression as a Response to Domestic Dissent

    Open Access•Sonia C Carey•Political Studies•2009

  • Democracy, threats and political repression in developing countries

    Patrick M Regan, Errol A Henderson•Third World Quarterly•2002

  • Sparks and prairie fires

    Open Access•Timur Kuran•Public Choice•1989

  • From Protest to Agenda Building

    J Smith, Joe A Smith et al.•Social Forces•2001

  • The Geography of Ethnic Violence

    Open Access•Steven L Burg•Political Science Quarterly•2004

  • Assessing Stability in the Patterns of Selection Bias in Newspaper Coverage of Protest During the Transition from Communism in Belarus

    James Mccarthy, John Mccarthy et al.•Mobilization An International…•2008

  • Unfinished Conquest

    Open Access•Z Hinojosa, Servando Z Hinojosa•Latin American Anthropology Review•1993

  • Repression of the Human Right to Personal Integrity Revisited

    Steven C Poe, C Neal Tate et al.•International Studies Quarterly•1999

  • Political Processes and Local Newspaper Coverage of Protest Events

    P Oliver, Pamela E Oliver et al.•American Journal of Sociology•2000

  • How Events Enter the Public Sphere

    P Oliver, Pamela E Oliver et al.•American Journal of Sociology•1999

  • Images of Protest

    John D Mccarthy, Clark Mcphail et al.•American Sociological Review•1996

  • All the Rioting That's Fit to Print

    Open Access•Daniel J Myers, Beth Schaefer Caniglia•American Sociological Review•2004

  • Repression Hurts

    Open Access•Ursula E Daxecker, Ursula Daxecker et al.•British Journal of Political…•2012

  • Massacres in the Jungle

    Open Access•Ricardo Falla•Missiology An International Review•1996

  • Ethnicity, the State, and the Duration of Civil War

    Open Access•Julian Wucherpfennig, Nils W Metternich et al.•World Politics•2012

  • Two Persistent Dimensions of Democracy

    Michael Coppedge, Angel E Alvarez et al.•The Journal of Politics•2008

  • The Dynamic Relationship Between Protest and Repression

    Open Access•Sonia C Carey, Sabine C Carey•Political Research Quarterly•2006

  • A Two-Stage Model for a Two-Stage Process

    Kraig Beyerlein, J R Hipp et al.•Mobilization An International…•2006

  • Views to a Kill

    Open Access•Christian Davenport, Patrick Ball•Journal of Conflict Resolution•2002

  • Action-Reaction or Rational Expectations

    Open Access•Will H Moore•Journal of Conflict Resolution•1995

  • The Effect of Political Regime on Civil War

    Open Access•James Raymond Vreeland•Journal of Conflict Resolution•2008

  • The Repression of Dissent

    Open Access•Will H Moore•Journal of Conflict Resolution•2000

  • Policy Disputes, Political Survival, and the Onset and Severity of State Repression

    Open Access•Emily Hencken Ritter•Journal of Conflict Resolution•2014

  • It Takes Two

    Open Access•David E Cunningham, David Cunningham et al.•Journal of Conflict Resolution•2009

  • The Devil You Know but Are Afraid to Face

    Open Access•Konstantinos Drakos, Κωνσταντίνος Δράκος et al.•Journal of Conflict Resolution•2006

  • Recruitment and Allegiance

    Open Access•Scott Gate, Scott Gates•Journal of Conflict Resolution•2002

  • Contagious Rebellion and Preemptive Repression

    Open Access•Nathan Danneman, Emily Hencken Ritter•Journal of Conflict Resolution•2014

  • Protest, Deterrence, and Escalation

    Open Access•Jan Henryk Pierskalla, Jan Pierskalla•Journal of Conflict Resolution•2010

  • Pre-emptive or Arbitrary

    Open Access•Francisco Herreros, Henar Criado•Journal of Conflict Resolution•2009

  • On the Accuracy of Media-based Conflict Event Data

    Open Access•Nils B Weidmann•Journal of Conflict Resolution•2015

  • Draining the Sea

    Benjamin A Valentino, Benjamin Valentino et al.•International Organization•2004

  • Bargaining Failures and Civil War

    Barbara F Walter•Annual Review of Political Science•2009

  • Building Reputation

    Open Access•Barbara F Walter•American Journal of Political…•2006

  • Repression and Dissent

    Will H Moore•American Journal of Political…•1998

  • Fight the Youth

    Open Access•Ragnhild Nordås, Christian Davenport•American Journal of Political…•2013

  • Social Networks and Collective Action

    Open Access•David A Siegel•American Journal of Political…•2009

  • What Stops the Torture

    Open Access•Courtenay R Conrad, Will H Moore•American Journal of Political…•2010

  • Multi-Dimensional Threat Perception and State Repression

    Christian Davenport•American Journal of Political…•1995

  • How Governments Shape the Risk of Civil Violence

    Open Access•Bethany Lacina•American Journal of Political…•2014

  • Leader Survival, Revolutions, and the Nature of Government Finance

    Open Access•Bruce Bueno De Mesquita, Alastair Smith•American Journal of Political…•2010

  • Fixed-Effects Negative Binomial Regression Models

    Open Access•P D Allison, Richard P Waterman•Sociological Methodology•2002

  • Process Matters

    Stephen M Shellman, Stephen Shellman•Security Studies•2006

  • If You Don't Do it, Nobody Else Will

    Pamela Oliver•American Sociological Review•1984

  • Concessions, Repression, and Political Protest in the Iranian Revolution

    Karen Rasler•American Sociological Review•1996

  • Conflict Intensity, Media Sensitivity and the Validity of Newspaper Data

    David Snyder, David V Snyder et al.•American Sociological Review•1977

  • Mobilization and Participation

    Bert Klandermans•American Sociological Review•1984

  • Validating Conflict Data

    M Herbert Danzger•American Sociological Review•1975

  • Repression of Human Rights to Personal Integrity in the 1980s

    Open Access•Steven C Poe, C Neal Tate•American Political Science Review•1994

  • Moving Beyond Deterrence

    Open Access•Laura Dugan, Erica Chenoweth•American Sociological Review•2012

  • Protest under Fire? Explaining the Policing of Protest

    Jennifer Earl, Sarah A Soule et al.•American Sociological Review•2003

  • What Do We Know about Natural Resources and Civil War

    Open Access•Michael L Ro, Michael L Ross•Journal of Peace Research•2004

  • Political opportunity structures, democracy, and civil war

    Open Access•Kristian Skrede Gleditsch, Andrea Ruggeri•Journal of Peace Research•2010

  • The (in)effectiveness of torture for combating insurgency

    Open Access•Christopher M Sullivan•Journal of Peace Research•2014

  • Threat and Repression

    Open Access•Scott Sigmund Gartner, Patrick M Regan•Journal of Peace Research•1996

  • How Censorship in China Allows Government Criticism but Silences Collective Expression

    Open Access•Gary King, Jennifer Pan et al.•American Political Science Review•2013

  • Ethnicity, Insurgency, and Civil War

    James D Fearon, David D Laitin•American Political Science Review•2003

  • Unfinished Conquest

    Kevin Gosner, Victor Perera•Hispanic American Historical Review•1995

  • Political Process and the Development of Black Insurgency, 1930-1970

    Doug Mcadam•Political process and the…•1999

  • The Use of Newspaper Data in the Study of Collective Action

    Jennifer Earl, Andrew Martins et al.•Annual Review of Sociology•2004

  • Validity and Systematicity of Newspaper Data in Event Analysis

    J Barranco, Dominik Wisler•European Sociological Review•1999

  • Threshold Models of Collective Behavior

    Mark Granovetter•American Journal of Sociology•1978

  • Resource Mobilization and Social Movements

    John D Mccarthy, Mayer N Zald•American Journal of Sociology•1977

Unique citing works75
Citations per year6,82
Citation span2015 - 2026 (12)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 75

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae