Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Welfare Conditionality and Blaming the Unemployed

Bibliographic Data

ID11104223
AuthorsMichael Mcgann (0000-0002-2452-6053, University of Melbourne, Victoria, Australia, corresponding author), Phuc Nguyen (0000-0001-7711-2623, La Trobe University, Shepparton, Victoria, Australia), Mark Considine (University of Melbourne, Victoria, Australia)
Year2020
Volume52
Issue3
Pages466-494
Publication date2020-03-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueAdministration & Society (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0095-3997 • E-ISSN: 1552-3039
PublisherSAGE Publications (PUBLISHER • US)
DOI10.1177/0095399719839362
OpenAlexW2926648500
LanguageEN
Citations received26
References cited38

Welfare recipients are increasingly subject to various forms of work-related conditionality that, critics argue, presuppose a “pathological” theory of unemployment that stigmatizes welfare recipients as de-motivated to work. Drawing on surveys of Australian frontline employment services staff, we examine the extent to which caseworkers attribute being on benefits to recipients’ lack of motivation, and whether this problem figuration of unemployment is associated with a “harder edged” approach to activation. We find that it is, although it is diminishing. This reflects how frontline discretion has become more routinized from the application of more intensive forms of performance monitoring and compliance auditing

Audit · Compliance (psychology · Conditionality · Discretion · Economic growth · Economics · Labour economics · Market economy · Political science · Public economics · Sociology · Subject (documents · Unemployment · Welfare · Welfare reform · Work (physics · Accounting · Employment and Welfare Studies · Labor Movements and Unions · Law · Psychology · Social Policy and Reform Studies · Social Psychology

  • Career counselling mid-career laid-off workers

    Charles P Chen, Siraj Waglay•British Journal of Guidance and…•2024

  • Street-level bureaucrats’ attitudes towards clients in discretionary decision-making

    Open Access•Andreea Alecu, Talieh Sadeghi et al.•Public Policy and Administration•2025

  • Welfare Conditionality and Social Identity Effect Mechanisms and the Case of Immigrant Support

    Open Access•Lena von Deylen, Philipp C Wichardt•Social Sciences•2025

  • The politics of piloting. The case of minimum income schemes in European cities

    Open Access•Giorgia Nesti, Matide Cittadini et al.•Review of Policy Research•2024

  • A Hidden Cost

    Open Access•Micheál Collins•Social Policy and Society•2023

  • Checking Activation at the Door

    Open Access•Rose-Marie Stambe, Greg Marston•Social Policy and Society•2022

  • The Age-Negotiated Configuration of Welfare Conditionality

    Open Access•Tat Chor Au‐yeung, TAT CHOR AU-YEUNG et al.•Social Policy and Society•2026

  • A Multi-Dimensional View of Stigma Experienced by Lone Parents in Irish Homeless and Employment Services

    Open Access•Philip Finn, Mary P Murphy et al.•Social Policy and Society•2022

  • Guaranteed Income as Targeted Welfare? Mechanisms and Conditions Linking Income Security, Health, and Crime for Patients in Forensic Psychiatry

    Open Access•Justin Berg, Lieke Oldenhof et al.•Social Policy and Society•2026

  • Searching for “the usual suspects”

    Open Access•Iben Nørup, Betina Skov Jacobsen•Public Administration•2021

  • Unpacking the effects of burdensome state actions on citizens' policy perceptions

    Open Access•Martin Sievert, Jonas Bruder•Public Administration•2023

  • When means‐testing meets work‐testing

    Open Access•Tat Chor Au‐yeung, Hung Wong et al.•International Journal of Social…•2023

  • Quid pro quo? A cross-national analysis of European citizens’ opinions toward the universality and conditionality of a basic income

    Open Access•Marie-Laure Mulayi•Journal of European Social Policy•2025

  • Public service supply chain management

    Open Access•Phuc Nguyen, Michael Mcgann et al.•Australian Journal of Public…•2025

  • Towards digital dole parole

    Open Access•Simone Casey•Australian Journal of Social Issues•2022

  • Towards policies of dignity? The German Participation Opportunities Act as a response to long-term unemployment

    Open Access•Kathrin Englert, Markus Gottwald et al.•Journal of Social Policy•2026

  • "Job seeker" experiences of punitive activation in Job Services Australia

    Open Access•Simone Casey•Australian Journal of Social Issues•2022

  • Australian unemployed workers’ experiences of being parked and creamed by employment providers

    Open Access•David O’Halloran, Louise Farnworth et al.•Australian Journal of Social Issues•2021

  • Australian employment services

    Open Access•David O’Halloran, Louise Farnworth et al.•Australian Journal of Social Issues•2020

  • Not seeing the elephant in the room

    Open Access•Iben Nørup, Betina Skov Jacobsen•Social Policy and Administration•2022

  • Networks, case managers, and the job‐search experiences of unemployed people

    Open Access•Gaby Ramia, Michelle Peterie et al.•Social Policy and Administration•2020

  • Detective Work and Invisible Assessments

    Open Access•Maria G Volckmar‐Eeg, Silje Andresen•Social Policy and Administration•2025

  • Veilederblikket

    Open Access•Silje Andresen, Maria G Volckmar-Eeg et al.•Tidsskrift for samfunnsforskning•2024

  • The Complementarity of Programme Logic and Critical Systems Heuristics

    Open Access•Patrick Mckenna•Systems Research and Behavioral…•2025

  • It's Not a Pattern of Behavior

    Open Access•Garrett L Grainger•Symbolic Interaction•2021

  • You had to be the Detective

    Open Access•Jamie Redman, Del Roy Fletcher et al.•Journal of Social Policy•2024

  • Getting Welfare to Work

    Mark Considine, Jenny M Lewis et al.•Getting Welfare to Work•2015

  • Workfare

    Open Access•Daniel Attas, Avner De‐shalit•Journal of Applied Philosophy•2004

  • Work and the Welfare State

    Vicki Lens, Michael Adler et al.•Work and the Welfare State•2013

  • What's Wrong with Workfare?

    Open Access•Stuart White•Journal of Applied Philosophy•2004

  • Employment services in an age of e-government

    Greg Marston•Information Communication & Society•2006

  • Disciplining the Poor

    Joe So, Joe Soss et al.•Disciplining the Poor•2011

  • On ‘Activation Workers' Perceptions’

    Open Access•Greg Marston•Journal of Social Policy•2013

  • Welfare reform, increased conditionality and discretion

    Aimee Grant•Journal of Poverty and Social…•2013

  • Welfare-to-Work Reform, Power and Inequality

    Adam Whitworth, Eleanor Carter et al.•Journal of Contemporary European…•2014

  • Rethinking Social Policy and Society

    Open Access•Christopher Deeming•Social Policy and Society•2015

  • Social Citizenship and Workfare in the US and Western Europe

    Open Access•Joel F Handler•Journal of European Social Policy•2003

  • The Rudd Government's Employment Services Agenda

    Open Access•Gaby Ramia, Terry Carney•Australian Journal of Public…•2010

  • Motivating the Unemployed? Attitudes at the Front Line

    Catherine Mcdonald, Greg Marston•Australian Social Work•2008

  • Australian Workers’ Narratives about Emergency Relief and Employment Service Clients

    Kylie Agllias, Amanda Howard et al.•Australian Social Work•2015

  • Workfare as welfare

    Open Access•Catherine Mcdonald, Greg Marston•Critical Social Policy•2005

  • Policies and discourses of poverty during a time of recession and austerity

    Open Access•Christina Pantazis•Critical Social Policy•2016

  • Feeling motivated yet? Long‐term unemployed people's perspectives on the implementation of workfare in Australia

    Open Access•Greg Marston, Catherine Mcdonald•Australian Journal of Social Issues•2008

  • Mutuality, Mead & McClure

    Open Access•Terry Carney, Gaby Ramia•Australian Journal of Social Issues•2002

  • Neoliberal subjectivities and the behavioural focus on income management

    Open Access•Elise Klein•Australian Journal of Social Issues•2016

  • Implementing public employment policy

    Open Access•Thomas Bredgaard, Flemming Larsen et al.•International Journal of…•2007

  • Welfare State Regimes and Caseworkers’ Problem Explanation

    Open Access•Marie Østergaard Møller, Helena Olofsdotter Stensöta•Administration & Society•2019

  • From Street‐Level to System‐Level Bureaucracies

    Open Access•Mark Bovens, Stavros Zouridis•Public Administration Review•2002

  • Personalization and Street‐level Practice in Activation

    Open Access•Vanesa Fuertes, Colin Lindsay•Public Administration•2015

  • Moving Beyond Discretion and Outcomes

    J R Sandfort, Jodi Sandfort•Journal of Public Administration…•2000

  • The Organization of Discipline

    Joe So, J SOSS et al.•Journal of Public Administration…•2011

  • State Agent or Citizen Agent

    Steven Maynard‐moody, Maynard-Moody et al.•Journal of Public Administration…•2000

  • Policy Work

    Evelyn Z Brodkin•Journal of Public Administration…•2011

  • New public management and welfare-to-work in Australia

    Mark Considine, Simon O’sullivan et al.•Australian Journal of Political…•2014

  • Automating Inequality

    Hannah Lebovits•Public Integrity•2019

  • Who's to Blame? The Identity Talk of Welfare-To-Work Program Managers

    Open Access•Elizabeth Seale, Alison R Buck et al.•Sociological Perspectives•2012

  • Evidence from the 'Frontline'? An Ethnographic Problematisation of Welfare-to-Work Administrator Opinions

    Open Access•John David Jordan•Work Employment and Society•2018

  • Markets, Networks and the New Welfare State

    Open Access•Mark Considine•Journal of Social Policy•1999

  • Activation Workers' Perceptions of Their Long-term Unemployed Clients' Attitudes towards Employment

    Open Access•Andrew Dunn•Journal of Social Policy•2013

  • Activation Work

    Open Access•Rik Van Berkel, Paul Van Der Aa•Journal of Social Policy•2012

  • Welfare-to-work, Agency and Personal Responsibility

    Open Access•Sharon Wright•Journal of Social Policy•2012

  • Quasi-Markets and Service Delivery Flexibility Following a Decade of Employment Assistance Reform in Australia

    Open Access•Mark Considine, Jerry M Lewis et al.•Journal of Social Policy•2011

Unique citing works26
Citations per year4,33
Citation span2020 - 2026 (7)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 26

Tools

Open DOISci-HubOpen Access
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae