Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Redefining Translation Competence in an Electronic Age. In Defence of a Minimalist Approach

Bibliographic Data

ID4344844
AuthorsAnthony Pym (0000-0002-9440-0886, Universitat Rovira i Virgili, Tarragona, Spain, corresponding author)
Year2004
Volume48
Issue4
Pages481-497
Publication date2004-08-06
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessYes
TypeARTICLE
VenueMeta Journal des traducteurs (JOURNAL)
Journal identifiersISSN: 0026-0452 • E-ISSN: 1492-1421
PublisherConsortium Erudit (PUBLISHER • CA)
DOI10.7202/008533ar
OpenAlexW2109308875
LanguageEN
Citations received69
References cited14

Since the 1970s the notion of "translation competence" has been viewed as at least 1) a mode of bilingualism, open to linguistic analysis, 2) a question of market demands, given to extreme historical and social change, 3) a multicomponent competence, involving sets of skills that are linguistic, cultural, technological and professional, and 4) a "supercompetence" that would somehow stand above the rest. The general trend among theorists has been to expand the multicomponent model so as to bring new skills and proficiencies into the field of translator training. This trend may be expected to continue with the increasing use of electronic tools. Here it is argued, however, that the multicomponential expansions of competence are partly grounded in institutional interests and are conceptually flawed in that they will always be one or two steps behind market demands. On the other hand, a simple minimalist concept of translation competence, based on the production then elimination of alternatives, can help orient translator training in times of rapid technological and professional change

Competence (human resources) · Epistemology · Linguistic competence · Linguistics · Sociology · Computer Science · Interpreting and Communication in Healthcare · Philosophy · Psychology · Second Language Learning and Teaching · Social Psychology · Translation Studies and Practices

  • Tradurre evoluzionismi. Due libri di Dan Sperber e Patrick Tort in italiano

    Open Access•Fabio Regattin•Lingue Culture Mediazioni -…•2020

  • A Reconsideration of Translation Quality and Standards

    Open Access•Rosemary Mitchell-Schuitevoerder•Journal of Siberian Federal…•2015

  • Intuicja tłumacza w kontekście badań przekładoznawczych

    Open Access•Maria Piotrowska•Między Oryginałem a Przekładem•1970

  • Measuring translation difficulty

    Sanjun Sun•Across Languages and Cultures•2015

  • Decision-making and alternative translation solutions in the literary translation process

    Claudine Borg•Across Languages and Cultures•2017

  • De l’usage raisonné des ressources documentaires numériques pour le développement de la sous- compétence instrumentale dans la didactique de la traduction spécialisée

    Open Access•Silvia Domenica Zollo•Traduction et Langues•2022

  • Applying translation theory in teaching

    María Calzada Pérez•Perspectives•2004

  • Future Translators' Concerns Regarding Professional Competences

    Open Access•Cristina Plaza Lara•Íkala Revista de Lenguaje y Cultura•2023

  • Subcompetência instrumental e elaboração de material de referência

    Open Access•Márcia Moura Da Silva•Revista de Estudos da Linguagem•2024

  • La práctica de la traducción no profesional y la enseñanza de español como lengua de herencia

    Leonarda García Jiménez, Laura Gasca Jiménez•Hispania•2019

  • Competence, Translation, and Interpreting

    Open Access•Xueni Zhang, Binghan Zheng•Encyclopedia of Applied Linguistics•2026

  • On Postediting of Machine Translation and Workflow for Undergraduate Translation Program in China

    Open Access•Zhengang Yang, Hema Rosheny Mustafa et al.•Human Behavior and Emerging…•2022

  • Strategically Informed Machine Translation Post-Editing

    Open Access•Zhiying Li•Language Teaching Research•2026

  • Integrating subtitling training into a general translation programme to enhance students’ translation competence in Hong Kong

    Open Access•Wenjing Li, Xiaolu Wang•Babel Revue internationale de la…•2026

  • The role of registerial expertise in texture re-creation in medical translation

    Open Access•Yan Yue, Jing Fang•Language, Context and Text. The…•2024

  • A Case Study on Improving MTI Students’ Translation Competence in Project-Based Teaching

    Open Access•Lin Xiao, Xun Li•International Journal of English…•2023

  • A Tradução Como Prática Crítica

    Jonathan Evans•TRADUÇÃO EM REVISTA•2021

  • The Pedagogy of Corpus-aided English-Chinese Translation from a Critical & Creative Perspective

    Open Access•Qingliang Meng•Theory and Practice in Language…•2021

  • A Qualitative Teacher-Student Oriented Approach to Translation Teaching

    Open Access•Ali Almanna, Hashim Lazim et al.•The Buckingham Journal of…•2020

  • Audio description and the translation of film language into words

    Open Access•Floriane Bardini•Ilha do Desterro A Journal of…•2020

  • Comparison of EMT Translator Competences to Those Demanded in the Market

    Open Access•Serap Durmuş•Mevzu – Sosyal Bilimler Dergisi•2023

  • Competence Development Strategies after Covid-19

    Open Access•Sandra Ribeiro, Célia Tavares et al.•Education Sciences•2023

  • Retracted

    Open Access•Michael Carl•Translation Spaces•2025

  • La competencia terminológica en la traducción especializada

    Open Access•Javiera Vergara Toro, Sabela Fernández-Silva•Mutatis Mutandis Revista…•2021

  • Propuesta consensuada (Delphi) de prácticas docentes para la adquisición de la competencia traductora

    Open Access•Nuria Brufau Alvira•Mutatis Mutandis Revista…•2024

  • Is the use of multiple-choice items and a holistically-scored paragraph translation task fair? Examining a large-scale translation subtest

    Open Access•Zhiqiang Yang, Yang Zhi-qiang et al.•Asia Pacific Education Review•2025

  • Finding synergies in Cognitive Translation and Interpreting Studies via task design

    Open Access•Álvaro Marín García•Target International Journal of…•2025

  • Kształcenie kompetencji translatorycznej rozważania teoretyczne i metodologiczne

    Open Access•Kamil Szafraniec•Acta Universitatis Lodziensis…•2020

  • Evolving L2 Translation Competence in Light of Technological Turn

    Open Access•Ondrej MOLNÁR•AUC PHILOLOGICA•2025

  • L’évaluation de la postédition « retour » en contexte d’apprentissage

    Open Access•Isabelle Robert, Isabelle S Robert•Meta Journal des traducteurs•2024

  • Translator Training by Distance Learning — A Dual Approach1

    Open Access•Karnedi Karnedi•Indonesian Journal of Applied…•2015

  • Stances toward translation training and the discipline

    Open Access•Jacqueline Aiello, Rossella Latorraca•Translation and Translanguaging…•2023

  • Translators’ work requirements and graduates’ preparedness

    Thu Thi Quy Do•Asia Pacific Translation and…•2020

  • Considerations of relevance to the target reader in Korean into English translation

    Vivian Lee•Asia Pacific Translation and…•2016

  • The role of coping strategies and emotional factors in predicting Iranian translation students’ translation ability

    Reyhaneh Khorasani, Afsaneh Ghanizadeh•Asia Pacific Translation and…•2017

  • Lost in post-editing. An exploratory study on translation trainees’ perceived EN>IT post-editing vs. translation performance

    Open Access•Rossella Latorraca•Ampersand•2023

  • Educating a Multilingual Workforce in Chinese universities

    Open Access•Yun Wu 吴赟, Zhiwei Jiang 姜智威•Círculo de lingüística aplicada a…•2021

  • Measuring translation revision competence and post-editing competence in translation trainees

    Isabelle Robert, Iris Schrijver et al.•Perspectives•2022

  • Translation Work Placement in Slovenia

    Open Access•Nataša Hirci•Perspectives•2022

  • Hans-Georg Gadamer’s philosophy of understanding and its implications for a model of hermeneutical translation competence

    Beata Piecychna•Perspectives•2022

  • A model for using the reflective learning journal in the postgraduate translation practice classroom

    Vivian Lee•Perspectives•2014

  • Mastering translation project management

    Dalia Mankauskienė•Perspectives•2024

  • Toward a Conceptual Model of Academic Translation Competence

    Open Access•Krisztina Károly•International Journal of Applied…•2024

  • You Sneak the Human Back in

    Open Access•D Giustini, Karol Muszyński et al.•Work and Occupations•2026

  • Writing biology, assessing biology

    Bassey E Antia, Richard A Kamai et al.•Terminology International Journal…•2021

  • The impact of an industry-driven translation training program on the performance of trainee translators

    Open Access•Buthainah M Al Thowaini, Mutahar Qassem•Cogent Arts and Humanities•2024

  • An evaluation of the EMT

    Open Access•Mohammad Reza Esfandiari, Nasrin Shokrpour et al.•Cogent Arts and Humanities•2019

  • From bilingualism to professionalism

    Open Access•Zheng Zheng•Cogent Arts and Humanities•2025

  • Remapping Translation Studies

    Open Access•Sonia Vandepitte•Meta Journal des traducteurs•2008

  • Team Work as a Method in Translation

    Konrad Klimkowski•Across Languages and Cultures•2006

  • Translation theory in post-editor training

    Open Access•Pál Heltai•Across Languages and Cultures•2025

  • Conceptualizing translation competence

    Márta Lesznyák•Across Languages and Cultures•2007

  • Self-study Strategies in Project-based Specialised Translator Training

    Paulina Pietrzak•Across Languages and Cultures•2019

  • Autonomy support, critical thinking, and motivation as key predictors of translator trainees' strategic competence

    Alicia Bolaños-Medina, Juan L Núñez•Across Languages and Cultures•2022

  • Using the features of translated language to investigate translation expertise

    Karien Redelinghuys, Haidee Kruger•International Journal of Corpus…•2015

  • Metacognition and translation competence

    Open Access•Hong Xie, Peng Wang•Acta Psychologica•2025

  • Ensino De Tradução

    Open Access•Marileide Dias Esqueda•Trabalhos em Linguística Aplicada•2018

  • Competência Em Tradução E Línguas De Sinais

    Open Access•Carlos Henrique Rodrigues•Trabalhos em Linguística Aplicada•2018

  • Investigating Blended Learning Mode in Translation Competence Development

    Open Access•Wenqing Peng, Mu Hu et al.•SAGE Open•2023

  • Technology Competence Training of Translation Educators in the Age of Technology-and-Information Empowerment

    Open Access•Lei Cai, Huaqing Tan et al.•SAGE Open•2025

  • The role of registerial expertise in translators’ logical choices

    Open Access•Yan Yue•Meta Journal des traducteurs•2021

  • When Translation Competence Is Not Enough

    Open Access•Matilde Nisbeth Brøgger•Meta Journal des traducteurs•2017

  • Project-Based Learning

    Open Access•Don Kiraly•Meta Journal des traducteurs•2006

  • Translation Skill-Sets in a Machine-Translation Age

    Open Access•Anthony Pym•Meta Journal des traducteurs•2014

  • Translating Mad Cow Disease

    Open Access•Ji-Hae Kang•Meta Journal des traducteurs•2013

  • Effects of Specific Training on the Ability to Deal with Cultural References in Translation

    Open Access•Christopher Scott-Tennent, Maria González Davies et al.•Meta Journal des traducteurs•2009

  • Professional Realism in the Legal Translation Classroom

    Open Access•Łucja Biel•Meta Journal des traducteurs•2011

  • Translation Skills and Knowledge - Preliminary Findings of a Survey of Translators and Revisers Working at Inter-governmental Organizations

    Open Access•Anne Lafeber•Meta Journal des traducteurs•2012

  • Effect of dependency distance of source text on disfluencies in interpreting

    Open Access•Xinlei Jiang, Yue Jiang•Lingua•2020

  • Descriptive Translation Studies – and beyond

    Gideon Toury, Gideon Tourey•Descriptive Translation Studies…•1995

  • Descriptive Translation Studies – and beyond

    Gideon Toury•Descriptive translation…•2012

  • The Translator As Communicator

    Basil Hatim, Ian Mason•Translator As Communicator•2005

  • Autrement dire… Pour une redéfinition des stratégies de formation des traducteurs

    Open Access•Daniel Gouadec•Meta Journal des traducteurs•1991

  • A Psycholinguistic Analysis of Translation Processes

    Open Access•Wolfgang Lörscher•Meta Journal des traducteurs•2002

  • Towards a Model of Translation Competence

    Open Access•Stuart Campbell, Stuart J Campbell•Meta Journal des traducteurs•2002

Unique citing works69
Citations per year1,23
Citation span1970 - 2026 (57)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedNo
Citation typesNeutral: 59

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae