Skip to main content

ETHNOS_APP

Home • Search • Journals • List 0

Bargainingtheory Andinternationalconflict

Bibliographic Data

ID6232809
AuthorsRobert Powell (0000-0003-2768-0555, University of California, Berkeley, corresponding author), Robert M Powell (0000-0001-7449-2499, University of California, Berkeley)
Year2002
Volume5
Issue1
Pages1-30
Publication date2002-06-01
Peer ReviewedYes
Open AccessNo
TypeARTICLE
VenueAnnual Review of Political Science (BOOK_SERIES)
Journal identifiersISSN: 1094-2939 • E-ISSN: 1545-1577
PublisherAnnual Reviews (PUBLISHER • US)
DOI10.1146/annurev.polisci.5.092601.141138
OpenAlexW2165933393
LanguageEN
Citations received156
References cited82

International relations theory has long seen the origins, conduct, and termination of war as a bargaining process. Recent formal work on these issues draws very heavily on Rubinstein's (1982) seminal analysis of the bargaining problem and the research that flowed from it. There is now what might be called a standard or canonical model of the origins of war that sees this outcome as a bargaining breakdown. This essay reviews this standard model and current efforts to extend it to the areas of (a) multilateral bargaining, which is at the heart of old issues such as balancing and bandwagoning as well as newer ones such as the role of third-party mediation; (b) the effects of domestic politics on international outcomes; (c) efforts to explicitly model intra-war bargaining; and (d) dynamic commitment problems

Economics · International trade · Law and economics · Mediation · Political economy · Political science · Politics · Global Peace and Security Dynamics · International Relations and Foreign Policy · Law · Political Conflict and Governance

  • Bargaining Between Rebel Groups and the Outside Option of Violence

    Håvard Mokleiv Nygård, Michael Weintraub•Terrorism and Political Violence•2015

  • Mutually Hurting or Mutually Beneficial Stalemates? Alternative Logics Shaping Conflict Outcomes

    Open Access•Nicola S Williams•International Studies Quarterly•2026

  • Institutions on the Edge

    Gretchen Helmke•Institutions on the Edge•2017

  • American Grand Strategy and East Asian Security in the Twenty-First Century

    Open Access•David C Kang•American Grand Strategy and East…•2017

  • Methodological Individualism and Rational Choice

    Andrew H Kydd•The Oxford handbook of…•2009

  • The 2022 Ethiopia’s first-ever national dialogue formation

    Open Access•Mersha Zenebe Felek•Cogent Social Sciences•2024

  • The effectiveness in international mediation of international organizations

    Open Access•Aoyuan Zhang, Haixia Qi•International Journal of Conflict…•2022

  • China’s Crisis Bargaining in the South China Sea Dispute (2010-2013)

    Open Access•Eryan Ramadhani•JAS (Journal of ASEAN Studies)•2014

  • Economic Shocks and Civil War

    Sylvain Chassang, Gerard Padrό i Miquel•Quarterly Journal of Political…•2009

  • A Theory of Power Wars

    Helios Herrera, Massimo Morelli et al.•Quarterly Journal of Political…•2021

  • Winning Hearts and Minds through Development? Evidence from a Field Experiment in Afghanistan

    Open Access•Andrew Beath, Fotini Christia et al.•2012

  • Principles of Conflict Economics

    Open Access•Charles H Anderton, John R Carter•Principles of Conflict Economics•2009

  • Reputation and Civil War

    Open Access•Barbara F Walter•Reputation and Civil War•2009

  • International Negotiation

    Open Access•Ho-Won Jeong, Ho‐Won Jeong•International Negotiation•2016

  • Vengeful Citizens, Violent States

    Open Access•Rachel M Stein, Rachel Stein•Vengeful Citizens, Violent States•2019

  • On the Historical Roots of Interstate Conflicts

    Open Access•Marcello D’Amato, Francesco Flaviano Russo•Journal of Conflict Resolution•2026

  • The Alliance Dilemma and the Onset of War. A Game-Theoretic Analysis of the Russia-Ukraine Conflict

    Open Access•Paolo Rosa, Stefano Benati•Peace Economics Peace Science and…•2025

  • Two Dismal Sciences Are Better Than One—Economics and the Study of National Security

    Ethan B Kapstein•International Security•2003

  • Crisis frames in the public discourse of the Municipality of Budapest after the Covid-19 pandemic

    Open Access•Gábor Pál•Frontiers in Political Science•2025

  • Do International Organizations Reduce the Risk of Crisis Recurrence

    Open Access•Zorzeta Bakaki•Journal of Global Security Studies•2018

  • Does Military Experience Really Matter? An Empirical Examination of Decision Framing and Deterrence Decision-Making

    Open Access•Jeffrey D Berejikian, Zachary Zwald•Journal of Global Security Studies•2024

  • Information, rebel organization and civil war escalation

    Open Access•Kazuhiro Obayashi•International Area Studies Review•2014

  • Urban Conflict, Rent Seeking, and Corruption Economic and Political Institutions in a Historical Perspective

    Open Access•Marie-Christine Thaize Challier•Review of European Studies•2018

  • Identity, bargaining, and third-party mediation

    Open Access•Ray Block, David A Siegel•International Theory•2011

  • The logic and illogic of the security dilemma and contemporary realism

    Open Access•Randall L Schweller•International Theory•2010

  • Poliheuristic Theory, Bargaining, and Crisis Decision Making

    Open Access•Min Ye•Foreign Policy Analysis•2007

  • Bombing to Bargain? The Air War for Kosovo

    Open Access•Susan Hannah Allen, Tiffiny Vincent•Foreign Policy Analysis•2010

  • A Game Theoretic Analysis of the Afghan Surge

    Open Access•Navin A Bapat•Foreign Policy Analysis•2010

  • International Relations Theory and East Asian History

    Open Access•David C Kang•Journal of East Asian Studies•2013

  • Nash bargaining solutions for international climate agreements under different sets of bargaining weights

    Open Access•YU Shu-min, E C van Ierland et al.•International Environmental…•2017

  • China, the United States, bargaining, and climate change

    Open Access•Robert Y Shum•International Environmental…•2013

  • Causal Pathways of Rebel Defection from Negotiated Settlements

    Open Access•Chelsea Johnson•Perspectives on Politics•2021

  • Uneven Power and the Pursuit of Peace

    Open Access•Mette Eilstrup-Sangiovanni•Comparative European Politics•2008

  • Domestic political institutions and the initiation of international conflict in East Asia

    Benjamin E Goldsmith•International Relations of the…•2013

  • Rational Origins of Revisionist War

    Open Access•Richard Jordan•International Studies Review•2022

  • Mediation and Peacekeeping in a Random Walk Model of Civil and Interstate War

    Open Access•Alastair Smith, Allan Stam•International Studies Review•2003

  • Algorithms at War

    Open Access•Benjamin Jensen, Benjamin M Jensen et al.•International Studies Review•2019

  • Dissolving Boundaries

    Open Access•Suzanne Werner, David R Davis et al.•International Studies Review•2003

  • Leanings and Dealings

    Magnus Lundgren, I Svensson•International Negotiation•2014

  • Transborder Ethnic Kin and the Dynamics of Peace Processes

    Sinem Arslan•Civil Wars•2019

  • Great Power Competition and the Logic of Strategic Choice in UN Conflict Management

    Bangjie Hu, Wen Shen•International Peacekeeping•2025

  • Inviting the Leviathan

    Jan Angstrom•Small Wars and Insurgencies•2008

  • Nationalism and war for territory

    Burak Kadercan•Cambridge Review of International…•2017

  • Oil prices and interstate conflict

    Open Access•Cullen S Hendrix, Cullen Hendrix•Conflict Management and Peace…•2015

  • Peace is in the air

    Open Access•Mahtab Shafiei, Kathryn Overton•Conflict Management and Peace…•2023

  • The bargaining framework and Russia's invasion of Ukraine

    Open Access•Scott Wolford•Conflict Management and Peace…•2024

  • Female fighters and the fates of rebellions

    Open Access•Robert Muir Wood, Lindsey Allemang•Conflict Management and Peace…•2021

  • Bargaining and the Failure of Asymmetric Deterrence

    Open Access•Catherine C Langlois, Jean-Pierre P Langlois•Conflict Management and Peace…•2006

  • Bargaining, War, and Alliances

    Open Access•R Harrison Wagner•Conflict Management and Peace…•2004

  • Considering concessions

    Open Access•Aila M Matanock, Natalia Garbiras-Díaz•Conflict Management and Peace…•2018

  • Power changes, alliance credibility, and extended deterrence

    Open Access•Jesse C Johnson, Stephen Joiner•Conflict Management and Peace…•2019

  • Development programs, security, and violence reduction

    Open Access•Heidi Kaila, Saurabh Singhal et al.•World Development•2020

  • Qui bono? Foreign military, economic, diplomatic interventions, and the termination of civil wars

    Huseyin Ilgaz•International Interactions•2021

  • Designing Alliances

    Jesse C Johnson•International Interactions•2021

  • Holding Out for Concession

    Jean-Pierre P Langlois, Catherine C Langlois•International Interactions•2006

  • Costly signaling in autocracy

    Robert Carroll, Robert E Carroll et al.•International Interactions•2021

  • Complementary mediation

    Elizabeth J Menninga•International Interactions•2020

  • The Dynamics of Mass Killings

    Gerald Schneider, Margit Bussmann et al.•International Interactions•2012

  • Alternative international systems? System structure and violent conflict in nineteenth-century West Africa, Southeast Asia, and South Asia

    Open Access•Charles Butcher, Ryan D Griffiths et al.•Review of International Studies•2015

  • Deterrence theory

    Open Access•Stephen L Quackenbush•Review of International Studies•2011

  • Violence, coercion, and settler colonialism

    Open Access•Chelsea A Pardini, Ana Espinola-Arredondo•Journal of Theoretical Politics•2021

  • Bullets for Ballots

    Aila M Matanock•International Security•2017

  • Ending the Korean War

    Elizabeth A Stanley•International Security•2009

  • Bargaining Theory and Rationalist Explanations for the Iraq War

    Michael K Mckoy, Michael Mckoy et al.•International Security•2012

  • The Perils of Profiling

    Kelly M Greenhill, Solomon Major•International Security•2007

  • The Strategies of Terrorism

    Andrew H Kydd, Barbara F Walter•International Security•2006

  • Spoiling Inside and Out

    Wendy Pearlman•International Security•2009

  • Bridge over Troubled Water? Envisioning a China-Taiwan Peace Agreement

    Phillip C Saunders, Scott L Kastner•International Security•2009

  • What Terrorists Really Want

    Max Abrahms•International Security•2008

  • Weak party escalation

    Jan Angstrom, Magnus Petersson•Journal of Strategic Studies•2019

  • Politics by many other means

    Jon R Lindsay, Erik Gartzke•Journal of Strategic Studies•2022

  • Políticas De Seguridad Contra El Narcotráfico

    Open Access•Fernando Estrada, Fabio Fernando Moscoso Durán et al.•Análisis Político•2016

  • U.S. Treaty Making with American Indians

    Open Access•Arthur Spirling•American Journal of Political…•2012

  • Political and economic protests in authoritarian regimes

    Open Access•Austin M Mitchell, Kana Inata et al.•Public Choice•2026

  • The Economic Coercion Trilemma

    Open Access•Michael-David Mangini•Journal of Conflict Resolution•2023

  • International Relations as a Social Science

    Open Access•Jeffry Frieden, Jeffry A Frieden et al.•The Annals of the American…•2005

  • Why Was the American Revolution a War? A Rationalist Interpretation

    Open Access•David A Lake•American Political Science Review•2025

  • International Relations Theory and the Relationship across the Taiwan Strait

    Scott L Kastner•International Journal of Taiwan…•2018

  • Unipolarity, Status Competition, and Great Power War

    Open Access•William C Wohlforth, William C Wohlforth William C Wohlforth•World Politics•2009

  • Do Intergovernmental Organizations Promote Peace

    Open Access•Charles R Boehmer, Charles Boehmer et al.•World Politics•2004

  • The Intrastate Contagion of Ethnic Civil War

    Matthew Lane•The Journal of Politics•2016

  • Rationalist Experiments on War

    Open Access•Kai Quek•Political Science Research and…•2017

  • War with Crazy Types

    Open Access•Avidit Acharya, Edoardo Grillo•Political Science Research and…•2015

  • Introducing ICBe

    Open Access•Rex W Douglas, Rex W Douglass et al.•Political Science Research and…•2024

  • Power and Political Institutions

    Terry M Moe•Perspectives on Politics•2005

  • Exploring the Bargaining Model of War

    Dan Reiter•Perspectives on Politics•2003

  • Why China's Rise Will Be Peaceful

    Open Access•David C Kang•Perspectives on Politics•2005

  • Arguing and Bargaining in International Negotiations

    Open Access•Peter Kotzian•International Political Science…•2007

  • The selection and signaling effects of third-party intervention

    Open Access•Yukari Iwanami•Journal of Theoretical Politics•2014

  • Proliferation, preemption, and intervention in the nuclearization of second-tier states

    Open Access•Christopher R Dittmeier•Journal of Theoretical Politics•2013

  • Logics of Violence in Criminal War

    Open Access•Brunhild Lessing, Benjamin Lessing•Journal of Conflict Resolution•2015

  • Deliberate Nuclear First Use in an Era of Asymmetry

    Open Access•Even Hellan Larsen•Journal of Conflict Resolution•2024

  • Muddying the Waters

    Open Access•Jessica Maves Braithwaite, Charles Butcher•Journal of Conflict Resolution•2023

  • Cheap Signals with Costly Consequences

    Open Access•Clayton L Thyne•Journal of Conflict Resolution•2006

  • How and When Amnesty during Conflict Affects Conflict Termination

    Open Access•Lee A Daniels•Journal of Conflict Resolution•2020

  • Expecting Elections

    Open Access•Nils W Metternich•Journal of Conflict Resolution•2011

  • Democratic versus Authoritarian Coups

    Open Access•Clayton L Thyne, Kendall Hitch•Journal of Conflict Resolution•2020

  • The Equifinality of War Termination

    Open Access•Elizabeth A Stanley, John P Sawyer•Journal of Conflict Resolution•2009

  • Recognition Matters

    Open Access•Nadav G Shelef, Yael Zeira•Journal of Conflict Resolution•2017

  • Territorial Conflict in the Digital Age

    Jordan Branch•International Studies Quarterly•2017

  • Game Theory and Economic Modelling

    David M Kreps•Game theory and economic modelling•1990

  • The Causes of War

    Open Access•Geoffrey Blainey•The Causes of War•1973

  • Discord and Collaboration

    Arnold Wolfers•Discord and Collaboration•1962

  • Bargaining Theory with Applications

    Open Access•Abhinay Muthoo, Marcia Morgan et al.•Bargaining Theory with Applications•1999

  • Democracy and Coercive Diplomacy

    Open Access•Kenneth A Schultz•Democracy and Coercive Diplomacy•2001

  • Perfect Equilibrium in a Bargaining Model

    Ariel Rubinstein•Econometrica•1982

  • Why Did the West Extend the Franchise? Democracy, Inequality, and Growth in Historical Perspective

    Daron Acemoglu, J A Robinson•The Quarterly Journal of Economics•2000

  • A Theory of Political Transitions

    Daron Acemoglu, James A Robinson•American Economic Review•2001

  • Games with Incomplete Information Played by “Bayesian” Players, I–III Part I. The Basic Model

    Open Access•John C Harsanyi•Management Science•1967

  • Power and International Relations

    Inis L Claude•Power and International Relations•1988

  • The Theory of Wages

    Open Access•John Hicks, J R Hicks•Theory of Wages•1963

  • Theoretical analysis of the “balance of power”

    Open Access•Morton A Kaplan, Arthur Lee Burns et al.•Systems Research and Behavioral…•2007

  • Back to the Future

    John J Mearsheimer•National and International Security•2018

  • International Relations

    David A Lake, Robert Powell•Strategic Choice and International…•2020

  • Perception and Misperception in International Politics

    Robert Jervis•Perception and Misperception in…•2017

  • Perception and Misperception in International Politics

    Open Access•Robert Jervis•Perception and Misperception in…•2017

  • The Balance of Power

    A F Pollard, Ashlee Pollard•Journal of the British Institute…•1923

  • Politics Among Nations

    Ramon Pacheco Pardo•Politics Among Nations•2017

  • Alliances, Threats, and U.S. Grand Strategy

    Stephen M Walt•Security Studies•1992

  • CHAPTER Five Commitment Problems and the Spread of Ethnic Conflict

    James D Fearon•International Spread of Ethnic…•1998

  • The War Ledger

    A F K Organski, Jacek Kugler•War Ledger•1980

  • Back to the Future

    John J Mearsheimer•International Security•1990

  • Offense, Defense, and the Causes of War

    Stephen Van Evera•International Security•1998

  • Balances of Power and the Escalation to War of Serious Disputes among the European Great Powers, 1815-1939

    William Brian Moul•American Journal of Political…•1988

  • Theory of international politics

    Kenneth Neal Waltz•Theory of international politics•1979

  • Cooperation under the Security Dilemma

    Open Access•Robert Jervis•World Politics•1978

  • Power Transitions and Great Power War from Westphalia to Waterloo

    Open Access•Woosang Kim•World Politics•1992

  • Game Theory and the Spiral Model

    Open Access•Andrew H Kydd, Andrew Kydd•World Politics•1997

  • Stability and the Distribution of Power

    Open Access•Robert Powell•World Politics•1996

  • The Security Dilemma Revisited

    Open Access•Charles L Glaser•World Politics•1997

  • What Makes Deterrence Work? Cases from 1900 to 1980

    Open Access•Paul Huth, Bruce Russett•World Politics•1984

  • Empirical Support for Systemic and Dyadic Explanations of International Conflict

    Open Access•Bruce Bueno De Mesquita, David Lalman•World Politics•1988

  • Declining Power and the Preventive Motivation for War

    Open Access•Jack S Levy•World Politics•1987

  • The Theory of Games and the Balance of Power

    Open Access•R Harrison Wagner•World Politics•1986

  • The Balance of Power

    Open Access•Ernst B Haas•World Politics•1953

  • The Tragic Element in Modern International Conflict

    Open Access•Herbert Butterfield•The Review of Politics•1950

  • Political Competition and Economic Growth

    Open Access•Bruce Bueno De Mesquita, James D Morrow et al.•Journal of democracy•2001

  • Fighting Battles, Winning Wars

    Open Access•Alastair Smith•Journal of Conflict Resolution•1998

  • How a War Ends

    Open Access•Donald Wittman•Journal of Conflict Resolution•1979

  • Policy Failure and Political Survival

    Open Access•Bruce Bueno De Mesquita, James D Morrow et al.•Journal of Conflict Resolution•1999

  • Understanding Success and Failure of International Mediation

    Open Access•Marieke Kleiboer•Journal of Conflict Resolution•1996

  • The Concentration of Capabilities and the Onset of War

    Open Access•Edward D Mansfield•Journal of Conflict Resolution•1992

  • Signaling Versus the Balance of Power and Interests

    Open Access•James D Fearon•Journal of Conflict Resolution•1994

  • Overwhelming Preponderance as a Pacifying Condition Among Contiguous Asian Dyads, 1950–1969

    Open Access•Erich Weede•Journal of Conflict Resolution•1976

  • Resolve, Capabilities, and the Outcomes of Interstate Disputes, 1816-1976

    Open Access•Zeev Maoz•Journal of Conflict Resolution•1983

  • Choosing Sides in Wars

    Michael F Altfeld, Bruce Bueno De Mesquita•International Studies Quarterly•1979

  • Testing theories of alliance formation

    Open Access•Stephen M Walt•International Organization•1988

  • Anarchy in international relations theory

    Open Access•Robert Powell•International Organization•1994

  • Rationalist explanations for war

    Open Access•James D Fearon•International Organization•1995

  • Third-party techniques for preventing conflict escalation and promoting peaceful settlement

    Open Access•William J Dixon, William G Dixon•International Organization•1996

  • Do Democratic Institutions Constrain or Inform? Contrasting Two Institutional Perspectives on Democracy and War

    Open Access•Kenneth A Schultz•International Organization•1999

  • The Critical Barrier to Civil War Settlement

    Open Access•Barbara F Walter•International Organization•1997

  • Anarchy and the limits of cooperation

    Open Access•Joseph M Grieco•International Organization•1988

  • Domestic Politics, Foreign Policy, and Theories of International Relations

    James D Fearon•Annual Review of Political Science•1998

  • Conflict, Agency, and Gambling for Resurrection

    George W Downs, David M Rocke•American Journal of Political…•1994

  • Deterring Intervention

    Suzanne Werner•American Journal of Political…•2000

  • Arms Races and Arms Control

    Andrew H Kydd, Andrew Kydd•American Journal of Political…•2000

  • Alliance Transitions and Great Power War

    Woosang Kim•American Journal of Political…•1991

  • Bargaining and War

    R Harrison Wagner•American Journal of Political…•2000

  • Offense-Defense Theory and Its Critics

    Sean M Lynn-Jone, Sean M Lynn-Jones•Security Studies•1995

  • Do Weak States Bandwagon

    Eric J Labs•Security Studies•1992

  • On the Value of Game Theory in Social Science

    Open Access•Roger B Myerson, Roger Myerson•Rationality and Society•1992

  • Arms Races and Dispute Escalation

    Open Access•Susan G Sample•Journal of Peace Research•1997

  • Politics Among Nations

    Peter Berger•Thought•1950

  • Reconfiguring The Arms Race-War Debate

    Open Access•Paul F Diehl, Mark J C Crescenzi•Journal of Peace Research•1998

  • The State of the Discipline

    Open Access•O Key, V O Key•American Political Science Review•1958

  • Bargaining in Legislatures

    Open Access•David P Baron, John Ferejohn et al.•American Political Science Review•1989

  • Stability in Anarchic International Systems

    Open Access•Emerson M S Niou, Peter C Ordeshook•American Political Science Review•1990

  • Peace, War, and the Balance of Power

    Open Access•R Harrison Wagner•American Political Science Review•1994

  • An Institutional Explanation of the Democratic Peace

    Open Access•Bruce Bueno De Mesquita, James D Morrow et al.•American Political Science Review•1999

  • Power, Alliance, and the Escalation of International Conflict, 1815-1965

    Open Access•Randolph M Siverson, Michael R Tennefo et al.•American Political Science Review•1984

Unique citing works156
Citations per year6,78
Citation span2003 - 2026 (24)
Citation velocitycurrent
Highly citedYes
Citation typesNeutral: 154

Tools

Open DOISci-Hub
Ethnos_APP • Open Source Project • MIT License • Frontend v2.0.0 • Privacy and Cookies • API Documentation: api.ethnos.app/docs • API Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17049435 • Frontend Source Code: GitHub • DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17050053 • cruz.rio.br • Expectantes Misericordiae